User:Tessiosepovici/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Thank U, Next (song)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because my course is called "Communicating Feminism," and I thought it would be interesting to look at Arian Grande. She is an extremely famous actress and singer, and her song, "Thank U, Next" was a big hit when it came out.

Evaluate the article
(Compose a detailed evaluation of the article here, considering each of the key aspects listed above. Consider the guiding questions, and check out the examples of what a useful Wikipedia article evaluation looks like.)

Lead section: The lead section is pretty good and describes the details of the actual song, what the song is about, and the significance it had on society. The topic sentence could be a bit stronger.

Content: I think the article has a good spread of content. It goes from describing the releasing, to lyrics, to how other celebrities thought of it, to how well it did in North America and Europe. The article talks about the famous music video, live performances, and the impact it had.

Tone: This article has a neutral tone and cites when opinions of other people are used.

Sources: This article has lots of citations and a long list of references.

Organization and Writing Quality: For the most part, this article is written very well. The sentences are clear and straightforward. I would possibly put critical reception closer to impact and legacy as I think both those sections have to directly do with what other people say about the song.

Images and Media: There are a few images from the music video and album cover. I would replace the image of Adele with something else because I think it is kind of confusing to readers.

Talk Page: There is only one suggestion and the article is included in various WikiProjects.

Overall impressions: I think this article does a good job at explaining various viewpoints about the song Thank U, Next. It even includes what key the song is in! It also gives multiple charts showing when the song was most popular and the awards it won. I would change the photo of Adele to something Ariana Grande/Thank U, Next themed and make those two sections I noted earlier closer together because I think they have to do with one another.