User:Thparkth/afdanalysis/Jeff the Diseased Lung

The result was no consensus. It appears to have generally been conceded that the article prima facie meets WP:GNG, but there was a significant strength of feeling on the "delete" side that an article about a segment/character from a TV show needs to go further than this and positively demonstrate notability that is independent of the TV show. Although this was a significant minority view, it is not directly based on notability policy, which imposes no such requirement. Nevertheless, if this minority view had been supported by a clear majority, the outcome would have been "delete". In this discussion there was no consensus about how to interpret notability policy with regards to this class of topic, and hence no consensus as to the overall outcome.