User:Tiffanyrodi/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Harem

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because I thought the topic of a Harem was interesting and foreign to me. I only have an impression of what a harem is from what I have seen and read and I wanted to get more information on the history and if they still exist today. My first impression of the article is that it is informative and looks like it has links to content that is valid.

Evaluate the article
This article on Harems appears to be relevant to the topic, although there is no star rating showing that it is a featured article. There was not any information that I found that was out of date or missing. I did not note any gaps in the information. The article appears to have a neutral tone and there are no viewpoints that are over or under represented. Upon checking some of the links, I found that they did work and referenced scholarly articles or other Wikipedia pages, not popular media (newspapers, magazines, etc). The table of contents looked well structured and the article was well illustrated. There were 138 references and several external sources, which seemed to be relevant except for the one on "popular culture references of harems" in which the link did not work. There were not any comments on the talk page but I did note a B class rating. The article was the subject of a Wiki Education supported course assignment from 2019, so I am not sure if that is why there was not anything listed on the talk page. I did view the history tab and noted that the article had several changes this year and many of them did not have the identity of who made the changes, which makes me think that is not as strong of an article as it could be.