User:Tjklink44/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Prison Commissary :
 * Article Evaluation
 * The article contains valuable information about prison commissaries, such as how they operate, what items are available for purchase, their historical background, and the use of certain items as currency in prisons. However, it lacks neutrality as it mainly focuses on the functions and effects of prison commissaries without discussing potential criticisms or alternative viewpoints In terms of equity gaps, the article highlights an aspect of prison life that is often overlooked in mainstream discussions. It sheds light on the economic dynamics within correctional facilities, which can disproportionately impact historically marginalized and underrepresented populations. However, the article could further explore the socioeconomic factors that contribute to the reliance on prison commissaries and the implications for inmates from diverse backgrounds. The Talk page gives some background on the article's assessment and its relevance to different WikiProjects. It seems that the article has been rated as Start-class, which means it may still need more information and improvement. It is also connected to WikiProjects related to correctional facilities, law, food and drink, and retailing.  Since the WikiProject Correction and Detention Facilities is no longer active, it suggests a lack of community engagement specifically focused on this topic. However, the article's association with WikiProjects related to law, food and drink, and retailing indicates potential areas for further development.  Discussing the possibility of expanding the article's historical, social, and economic contexts could enhance its depth and be beneficial.
 * Sources
 * Prison commissary

Option 2

 * Penal Labor in the United States:
 * Article Evaluation
 * Relevance to the topic: This article provides a thorough overview of penal labor in the United States, covering its historical origins, legislative advancements, modern practices, and criticism. It offers a comprehensive examination of various aspects related to the topic. Neutrality: The article presents information in an unbiased tone, offering facts and descriptions without any obvious bias.  Citations for each claim: The article supports many claims with citations, including legislative acts, historical events, and statistical data.   Reliability of citations: The citations in the article generally appear reliable, referencing legislative acts, historical records, scholarly articles, and news sources.  Tackling equity gaps: By shedding light on the history and current practices of penal labor in the United States, this article addresses a significant equity gap. It explores how penal labor disproportionately affects certain populations, such as prisoners, particularly in terms of low wages, lack of worker rights, and systemic exploitation. By highlighting these issues, the article contributes to addressing the underrepresentation and misrepresentation of this topic.
 * The Talk page for the "Penal labor in the United States" article is centered on improving the article according to Wikipedia's guidelines. There are no ongoing discussions or specific suggestions for improvement visible on the Talk page.
 * This article is rated C-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale
 * This article has been rated as Mid-importance on the project's importance scale.
 * Sources:Penal labor in the United States

Option 3

 * Prisoner abuse :
 * Article Evaluation The article "Prisoner Abuse in the United States" covers various forms of mistreatment experienced by incarcerated individuals. It discusses physical abuse, psychological abuse, sexual abuse, and torture, providing examples and explanations for each. It also includes sections on white noise, verbal abuse, sexual violence, strip searches, enemas, torture, and the right to health, which adds depth to the discussion. The article presents the information objectively, describing different types of prisoner abuse without taking a particular stance. However, it's important to consider different viewpoints since the cited sources may have their own biases or perspectives.  The article provides references for each claim made, including reputable organizations like The New York Times, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, and legal definitions from USLegal. This strengthens the credibility of the information presented.  The article also addresses equity gaps by discussing issues that disproportionately affect certain populations, such as the mentally ill, female prisoners, and detainees in specific facilities like Guantanamo Bay. It highlights systemic issues within the prison system, including overcrowding, lack of proper medical care, and violations of prisoners' rights, particularly within the context of the COVID-19 pandemic.  Talk page  The article lacks a rating on Wikipedia's assessment scale, which could help assess its quality and pinpoint areas for enhancement.  While guidelines are in place, there is room to increase active participation from editors to discuss and create article improvements.


 * Sources:Talk:Prisoner abuse

Option 4

 * Prisoner reentry:
 * Article Evaluation **Relevance to the Topic:** The article covers prisoner re-entry comprehensively, discussing various aspects like employment, housing, healthcare, and programs for specific demographics. It explores the challenges faced by formerly incarcerated individuals and initiatives for their successful reintegration into society. The content is highly relevant to the topic of prisoner re-entry. **Neutrality:** The article maintains a neutral tone, presenting information and findings without bias or opinionated language. It objectively discusses different re-entry programs, their effectiveness, and the challenges of prisoner reintegration. Overall, it follows Wikipedia's policy of neutrality.  **Citations:** The article supports each claim with citations, referencing studies, articles, and research reports. This establishes the credibility of the information and allows readers to verify the claims independently. The citations enhance the article's reliability and trustworthiness.  **Reliability of Citations:** The article cites reputable sources like academic journals, research organizations, and news outlets such as The New York Times Magazine. These sources are generally considered reliable for providing accurate and evidence-based information.
 * The talk page has not yet been rated.
 * Sources:Prisoner reentry

Option 5

 * Article title:
 * Article Evaluation:
 * Sources: