User:Tkeogh11/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Alice Roberts

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
Archaeology has always been a field that I am interested in so I decided on this article to examine as a result. I also wanted to do a newer person in the field because there would possibly be room to add their new contributions.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section:


 * The lead section provides a clear and concise overview of Alice Roberts and her major contributions.
 * It appropriately introduces the article's major sections.
 * The lead doesn't contain information missing from the article and maintains conciseness.

Content:


 * The article covers relevant aspects of Alice Roberts' life and career.
 * Content appears up-to-date, though periodic checks are advisable.
 * No irrelevant content is present, and the article is balanced in representing her achievements.

Tone and Balance:


 * The article maintains a neutral tone and avoids bias.
 * It accurately represents Alice Roberts' viewpoints and contributions without persuasion.

Sources and References:


 * Reliable sources back up the facts in the article.
 * Sources seem to reflect available literature.
 * Ensuring periodic updates and diverse perspectives in sources could be beneficial.

Organization and Writing Quality:


 * The article is well-written, clear, and organized into meaningful sections.
 * No apparent grammatical or spelling errors.

Images and Media:


 * Images enhance understanding and adhere to copyright regulations.
 * Well-captioned and visually appealing layout.

Talk Page Discussion:


 * Discussions on the talk page indicate ongoing engagement.
 * The article is rated as "Start-Class" and part of WikiProject Biography.

Overall Impressions:


 * Informative and well-structured but may benefit from periodic updates and inclusion of diverse perspectives.

Completeness Assessment:


 * Reasonably well-developed but could be further improved with recent developments and more details about her impact.

In summary, the article about Alice Roberts is informative and well-organized but could benefit from updates and diverse sources.