User:Vles1/Archive 6

Criminal cases against Yulia Tymoshenko supporters since 2010 — a number of criminal cases in Ukraine, which were opened since May 2010 against fellow Tymoshenko. On a set of these cases, there are a number of appeals the EU, U.S., Russia, human rights organizations, the Ukrainian society in Ukraine and in the Diaspora — in the claims stated in the political aspect of these cases. But Prosecutor of Ukraine states that the «political component» is missing.

Companions Tymoshenko against whom criminal cases were opened in 2010
Beginning in May 2010, opened a number of cases against Tymoshenko and her allies. More than a dozen «associates Tymoshenko» were arrested (including government ministers Tymoshenko); as of October 2011, half of them are in jail for 8-12 months. Most have been charged with abuse of power:

1) The Prime Minister — Yuliya Tymoshenko.

2) The Minister of Internal Affairs — Lutsenko.

3) The Minister of Defence — Ivashchenko.

4) The Minister of Finance — Danylyshyn.

5) The Minister of Natural Resources — Filipchuk.

6) The Deputy Minister of Justice — Korniychuk.

7) The Chairman of the Customs Service of Ukraine — Makarenko.

8) The Chairman of the regional customs — Shepitko.

9-10) The head of the State Treasury — Slyuz, Vice President — Gritsoun.

11-12) Deputy Chairman of «Naftogaz» (the state monopoly on trade in oil and gas) — Didenko. Maria Kushnir — Deputy Chief Accountant, «Naftogaz».

13) The Minister of Construction (and former mayor of Lviv) — Kuybida.

14) Governor of the Dnipropetrovsk region (former Minister of Transport and Communications) — Bondar.

Several officials have repeatedly called in for questioning, to open a criminal case, in particular, the First Vice Prime Minister Turchynov, but things were not open.

In late 2010 and early 2011 — have been jailed eight  representatives of the Movement of Entrepreneurs, «Common Cause», which was carried out «Tax Maidan 2010» in cooperation with Tymoshenko.

October 12, 2011, Attorney General of Ukraine declared its intention to initiate the resumption of criminal cases (which were closed in 2003—2005) to employees of corporation «United Energy Systems» (including by-law of Yulia Tymoshenko — 75-year-old Gennady Timoshenko).

European Parliament’s resolution: «The cases of Yulia Tymoshenko and other members of the former government»
June 9, 2011 The European Parliament adopted an important resolution on Ukraine, «The cases of Yulia Tymoshenko and other members of the former government»:

— «The European Parliament, taking into account its previous resolutions on Ukraine, in particular its resolution of November 25, 2010… Taking into consideration the statement of its President on the detention of Yulia Tymoshenko’s May 24, 2011; taking into account the statement by EU High Representative Catherine Ashton of 26 May 2011 about the case of Yulia Tymoshenko; taking into account the statement of Commissioner Stefan Fule, after his meeting with Yulia Tymoshenko, March 24, 2011 …

1. Stresses the importance of ensuring maximum transparency of investigations, prosecutions and court, and also warns against the possible use of criminal justice as a means of achieving political goals.

2. Concerned about the rise of selective prosecution of political opponents in Ukraine, as well as the disproportionate measures used, particularly in the case of Tymoshenko and former Interior Minister Lutsenko, draws attention to the fact that Lutsenko is under arrest in December 26, 2010»

Assessment «of criminal cases against Tymoshenko allies» in the EU, U.S., Russia
December 30, 2010 The U.S. State Department said the Ukrainian government on the concerns of criminal cases against Tymoshenko team, that «prosecution should not be selective or politically motivated».

January 13, 2011 Czech Republic «granted political asylum», the former minister of economy Bohdan Danylyshyn.

June 24, 2011 U.S. State Department said that the trial of Yulia Tymoshenko is politically motivated trial of the opposition representative.

June 22, 2010 (the eve of the trial of the Timoshenko) — British Ambassador to Ukraine Leigh Turner — gave an interview to the ukrainian newspaper «The Day», where the Ukrainian authorities have warned of persecution of the opposition:
 * «We are closely watching the development of criminal cases against former officials… we are concerned about the assumptions about possible political motives of those cases … In case of deterioration of the situation, we will be forced to reconsider its position and will consult with our European and other international partners on the most an adequate response. We clearly explained to representatives of Ukrainian authorities, that any impression on the selectivity and the disproportionate use of legal action can significantly and for a long time to harm the international reputation of Ukraine».

Ratings Tymoshenko after the verdict (after October 11, 2011)
October 11, 2011 (the day of sentencing Yulia Tymoshenko) administration of U.S. President called for «release of Yulia Tymoshenko and other political leaders and former members of the government». October 13, 2011 Support Group Co-Chair of Ukraine in the U.S. Congress Mercy Kaptur has registered a draft resolution on «the persecution of opposition leader Yulia Tymoshenko and her supporters».

October 27, 2011 European Parliament (absolute majority; votes of five of the six fractions) adopted a resolution on Ukraine (third resolution for the year), which in view of statements by heads of the European Union, said that «as to criminal liability is involved an increasing number of officials, including Ministers of the former government, the heads of government departments and inspectorates, the heads of law enforcement units, district court judges and heads of local authorities», that is why the European Parliament «condemns the guilty verdict to former Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko» (paragraph 2 of Resolution), «Insists that all the lawsuits'' against current and former high-ranking government should be in line with European standards» (paragraph 6 of Resolution).

The President and Prime Minister of Russia, made several statements about the «politically motivated trial of Yulia Tymoshenko», and October 11, 2011, the Russian Foreign Ministry issued a statement (see / 4E713869C43B4D2FC32579260043A7B2? OpenDocument Russian Foreign Ministry website): «One can not ignore the fact that the leadership of many states and world public perceive the whole judicial process as initiated solely by political motives».

The director of «Ukrainian branch of the CIS Institute» (the Russian State Institute for the Study of CIS) Vladimir Kornilov noted that « If Kiev would continue to ignore the opinion of the European Union, Russia and the United States in the case of Yulia Tymoshenko, it may be that Brussels will treat Ukraine as a second Belorus».

Prosecution (since 2010) of the former «Tymoshenko Cabinet»
Arrested and are in jail (as of October 2011 — 8-12 months) for a total of half a dozen colleagues from the Cabinet Tymoshenko. In most cases, charges of abuse of power.
 * December 30, 2010 The U.S. State Department said the Ukrainian government about concerns that the «persecution should not be selective or politically motivated».
 * January 13, 2011 Czech Republic «granted political asylum», the former minister of economy Bohdan Danylyshyn.

The case against ex-Minister of Economy Bohdan Danylyshyn
August 5, 2010 Bogdan Danylyshyn flew to Germany.

August 12, 2010 Ukraine’s Prosecutor General’s Office instituted criminal proceedings against Bohdan Danylyshyn (Minister of Economic Affairs in the government of Tymoshenko 2007—2010) under Part 2 of Art. 364 «Abuse of power or official capacity». Danylyshyn was put on international wanted list. October 18, 2010 Danylyshyn came from Germany in the «Ukrainian Embassy in the Czech Republic» — where his lawyer allegedly agreed to conciliation meeting.

However, on 18 September 2010, after a meeting at the Ukrainian Embassy, Czech police arrested Danylyshyn (following a request from Interpol), when he came out of the Ukrainian embassy in Prague.

After his arrest, Danylyshyn filed a request for «political asylum», and January 12, 2011 has received «political asylum in the Czech Republic».

The case against the former defense minister Ivashchenko
August 24, 2010 arrested a former acting Defense Minister Valeriy Ivashchenko. He was accused of making illegal decision on sale of property «Feodosia Marine Engineering Plant».

June 20, 2011 Vladimir Ivashchenko hunger strike in protest against his detention, but due to the rapidly deteriorating health, he was forced to stop the hunger strike on June 25.

The case against ex-Minister of the Environment George Filipchuk
December 14, 2010 arrested a former «Minister of Environmental Protection of Ukraine» George Filipchuk: «The General Prosecutor of Ukraine December 13, 2010 filed a criminal case against former Minister of Environment Protection of Ukraine Georgiy Filipchuk on the grounds of crime under Part 2 of Art. 364 of the Criminal Code (abuse of power), which caused grave consequences». Filipchuk charged with involvement in the case of the Kyoto money (see «The criminal case against Tymoshenko in 2010»).

April 8, 2011 Attorney General’s office announced the release from custody of George Filipchuk, in connection with the end of familiarization with criminal case material.

The case against ex-Minister of Regional Development and Construction Vasyl Kuibida
In June 2010, opened a criminal case against Basil Kuybida (Minister of Regional Development and Construction in the government of Tymoshenko in 2007—2010, the mayor of Lviv in 1994—2002, Ph.D. Public Administration). SBU accused Kuybida that he has appointed without competition head of the State Architectural Construction Control of the Rivne region. The trial began in August 2010, but the Court has repeatedly transferred — in September, in October, November.

Kuybida said that under the law if the Minister has agreed with the governor of some «candidate for the post of regional director of the State Architectural Construction Control», then the competition may be waived. Former governor of Rivne region Viktor Matchuk — confirmed the testimony Kuybida.

December 13, 2010 Shevchenko District Court of Kyiv has closed the above case. The prosecutor made a protest against the closure of the case, but 14.1.2011 «Court of Appeal of Kyiv» has confirmed the decision to close the case.

Basil Kuybida said the case against him excited, trying to keep him on election of the Mayor of Lviv:
 * «They started clinging to me after I had consulted about the possibility of my running for Mayor of Lviv. So much time I was in Kiev, and had to forget about elections in Lviv. As a result, they have achieved that I did not run for mayor of Lviv».

Indeed, the local elections in Ukraine took place 31.10.2010 and soon «the case Kuybida» was closed. During the local elections in the Ukraine — criminal cases were instituted against the mayors of several cities.

The case against the former First Deputy Minister of Justice Korneychuck
December 22, 2010 Prosecutor’s Office arrested former «First Deputy Minister of Justice» (in the Cabinet Tymoshenko) Eugene Korneychuck; He is the son-in-the head of the Supreme Court Vasyl Onopenko. Korniychuk was arrested on the day when his wife gave birth — a newborn baby in two days was in intensive care.

However, after several weeks (February 15, 2011) former First Deputy Justice Minister Eugene Korniychuk change the preventive measure for release on own recognizance (after meeting Basil Onopenko and President Yanukovych).

The case against Victor Bondar, the ex-governor of the Dnipropetrovsk region
December 24, 2010 Prosecutor’s Office arrested the former Minister of Transport and Communications, ex-governor of the Dnipropetrovsk region Victor Bondar. Strictly speaking, Bondar joined the «team of the Prime Minister Tymoshenko» — only in the last months before the presidential election-2010, but his position was very important in the election of 2010.

Against B. Bondar was prosecuted for his work as Acting Minister of Transport in 2006 (in the government of Yekhanurov, after dismissal of Minister of Transport Eugene Chervonenko) during construction of the bus station «Teremki». The prosecutor’s office said that the damage amounted to 625 thousand USD (5 million UAH). The criminal case was opened under Part 5 of Art. 27, Part 2, Art. 194, Art. 353 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, «complicity in the intentional destruction of another’s property, causing property damage in a large scale, combined with the unauthorized appropriation of power».

The case against Igor Didenko and Anatoly Makarenko
June 23, 2010 arrested the former chairman of the State Customs Service of Ukraine Anatoliy Makarenko. July 8, 2010 arrested a former first deputy head of the «Naftogaz» Igor Didenko.

July 22, 2010, First Deputy Prosecutor General Viktor Pshonka (six months later he was appointed Attorney General) said: «Taken into custody (21.07.2010) Taras Shepitko — Deputy Head of the Department of Energy Regional Customs». Pshonka stressed that the decision of the Stockholm court is not grounds for a criminal case.

All three were charged that in pursuance of the Ukrainian-Russian intergovernmental agreement on 19.1.2009 (on overcoming the «Ukraine-Russia gas crisis-2009») — customs clearance and was to balance the state company «Naftogaz» 11 billion cubic meters of gas from the company «Gazprom» (the gas was initially designed the Swiss company «RUE», but it has not been paid).

It Taras Shepitko in March 2009
Even under President Yushchenko — March 2, 2009 the Security Service (head Valentyn Nalyvaichenko, first deputy Valeriy Khoroshkovskiy) opened a criminal investigation into allegedly taking possession of Naftogaz «6.3 billion cubic meters of transit natural gas to more than 1 billion USD.» In this case, was detained, «deputy chief of the Energy Regional Customs» Taras Shepitko. However, the Acting Chairman of the Board of «Naftogaz» Igor Didenko appealed the decision to institute criminal proceedings in the District Court of Kyiv Shevchenko, and March 24, 2009 Shevchenko district court declared illegal certain actions of the SBU, and reversed the decision of the Security Service to initiate the criminal case. Shepitko was released from jail.

Maria Kushnir, deputy chief accountant «Naftogaz»
Maria Kushnir this is the fifth defendant in a «criminal case on gas RosUkrEnergo» (for which arrested Tymoshenko, Didenko, Makarenko, Shepitko).

July 23, 2010 SBU opened a criminal case against the deputy chief accountant of Naftogaz Maria Kushnir. July 26, 2010 Pechersk District Court in Kyiv issued a warrant to arrest Kushnir. The head of the SBU Khoroshkovskiy said : Kushnir was employed to «Naftogaz» specifically for operations on customs registration of gas RosUkrEnergo. «Her function was to just put a signature. It was she who gave the command to put gas in the „balance of Naftogaz“ and signed the initial document».

Originally Kushnir was charged with «Part 2 st.367 of the Criminal Code» (neglect of official duty, entailing grave consequences), which provides for imprisonment for a term of «up to three years». But 9 September 2010 in respect of Kushnir was prosecuted for «Part 2 st.364 of the Criminal Code» (abuse of authority or official position, which entailed grave consequences).

September 10, 2010 in cooperation with law enforcement authorities of the Russian Federation, Kushnir was detained in Volgograd Oblast (Russian Federation); and a month later extradited to Ukraine. Since then (until November 2011) M. Kushnir is in jail, and in the press there are no reports on the progress of her case.

Chronology of events at the suit of RosUkrEnergo in the Stockholm arbitration
In April 2008, RosUkrEnergo has filed first suit against Naftogaz (in the Court of Arbitration at Stockholm Chamber of Commerce). In January 2009, RosUkrEnergo has filed another three suit against «Naftogaz». «Naftogaz» also filed a counter the four suit against «RosUkrEnergo». All suits in this dispute have been combined into one case.

April 2, 2010 «Court of Arbitration in Stockholm», issued an interim decision on the claim of RosUkrEnergo to Naftogaz ($ 2 billion), and ordered «Naftogaz» to return to the plaintiff $ 197 million.

June 8, 2010 Stockholm arbitration decided (based on a «settlement agreement» under which Ukraine, «Naftogaz» recognized all claims RosUkrEnergo), according to which «Naftogaz of Ukraine» is obliged to return RosUkrEnergo «11 billion m ³ of gas plus 10 % of compensation».

In January 2009 the 11 billion cubic meters of Russian gas destined RosUkrEnergo (RUE), but RosUkrEnergo has not paid the price of gas to Gazprom. Therefore, in January 2009: — Naftogaz repaid «RosUkrEnergo debt to Gazprom» in the amount of 1.7 billion dollars. And in return, «Gazprom» passed «Naftogaz» compensation — the 11 billion cubic meters of gas (ie, at a price of $ 156 per 1,000 cubic meters.);

— at the same time RosUkrEnergo was excluded from the scheme of gas supply (in Ukraine and abroad), a gas supply agreement entered into directly state-owned companies «Naftogaz» and «Gazprom». Prior to April 2010 «Gazprom» owned 50 % stake in RosUkrEnergo, but in April 2010 «Gazprom» came from the founders of RosUkrEnergo — RosUkrEnergo became fully privately owned company with a controlling stake in D. Firtash.

In the period from November 2010 to April 2011 — «Naftogaz» gave the Swiss company RosUkrEnergo — 12.1 billion cubic meters of gas (11 billion cubic meters, plus 10 % of compensation), and RUE paid «Naftogaz» 1.7 billion dollars. As of 2011 (when the price in the European Union 490 dollars per thousand cubic meters), the total value of the transferred gas — about 5.4 billion USD.

Point of view D. Firtash — outlined in his interview with the magazine «Focus».

Exemption Makarenko and Shepitko — after a year in jail
July 5, 2011 Anatoliy Makarenko and Taras Shepitko — were suddenly released from the jail (however, their criminal cases are not closed, and remained recognizance not to leave).

July 5, 2011, Anatoly Makarenko and Taras Shepitko — were suddenly released from prison (however, their criminal cases are not closed, and remained recognizance not to leave). Press claimed that «the liberation of Makarenko», is associated with upcoming meeting (06.07.2011 in the Crimea) of Russian Prime Minister Putin and Yanukovych, because even in the summer of 2010 «commander of the Russian fleet» (who knew Makarenko for naval service in Russia) have been asked to Putin and Yanukovych — the release from prison Makarenko. And Putin has supported their request in a speech on the Day of the Navy of Russia, 2010.

In connection with the release of Makarenko in the press in Ukraine there are «leaks» (from the deputies of fundamentally different factions of the Verkhovna Rada) that Russia is advised to «stop harassing Tymoshenko». Similarly, at a press conference July 7, 2011, in Moscow (on the results of talks between Putin and Azarov), Prime Minister Putin said that Russia is against the revision of the «gas contract from 1/19/2009,» and believes that criticisms of the treaty by the Government of Ukraine has a political component, the desire to prove that all the predecessors have done poorly.

Tatiana Slyuz
December 24, 2010 declared wanted by Tatiana Yaroslavovna Slyuz (Chairman of the State Treasury of Ukraine), she is charged with involvement in the case of the «Kyoto money» (see Criminal cases against Yulia Tymoshenko since 2010). The prosecutor’s office claims that Slyuz is abroad.

Gritsoun Tatiana, the first deputy chairman of the Treasury
July 19, 2010, was detained Tatiana Gritsoun (Former First Deputy Head of the State Treasury of Ukraine). July 22, 2010 Pechersk district court sanctioned the arrest of her — she is charged «abuse of power or position, resulted in grave consequences» (Part 2 of Article 364 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, provides imprisonment for 3-6 years):

— Gritsoun (from September 2009 to April 2010) gave instructions not to release 800 million hryvnia tender guarantees for participants in the privatization tender «Odessa port plant» (OPP) for the companies «Nortima» and «Frunze Flora» (these companies also won in court penalties of more than 2 million UAH, ie, 180 thousand euros). Gritsoun blamed for the fact that it prevented the return of collateral against the payment order the State Property Fund of Ukraine.

As of November 2011 Tatiana Gritsoun is in jail.

The essence of the conflict over the OPP is:

Prime Minister Tymoshenko has sought, through the privatization of strategic enterprises OPP — much to replenish the state budget (during the crisis in 2009). At the same time, Ukraine was preparing for the presidential election — and President Viktor Yushchenko led the fight against Tymoshenko, including, issued a decree prohibiting the privatization of the OPP. Because of this Ordinance, the competition did not attend the most powerful investors. Only three companies have submitted applications to participate in the tender, the tender price remained practically at the grassroots level. The firm «Nortima» (owned by Igor Kolomoisky) has won the auction But Tymoshenko said that the Odesa Portside Plant will not be sold, because the participants had agreed on a minimal cost. In response — Kolomoisky promised to sue, but Tymoshenko has suspended the return of collateral, which is paid «Nortima» and «Frunze Flora». But third bidder — a Russian company «Nitrogen-Service», which represented the interests of «Gazprom», immediately got back a collateral. Tymoshenko said that the money in the state budget is not — and collaterals will be refunded in full, but after the privatization of «Odessa port plant».

The case against the former Police Minister Yuriy Lutsenko
December 26, 2010 arrested former minister of Ministry of Internal Affairs Yuri Lutsenko. Against Lutsenko launched three criminal cases :
 * Inflated pensions of its driver (worth about 100 euros per month and single payment at retirement 2.5 thousand euros).
 * On the expenditure of funds for the celebration of Police Day at the Palace «Ukraine» in 2008—2009 — total were spent 60 thousand euros.
 * Continuation of the illegal surveillance of persons involved in case of poisoning of Yushchenko (part 3 st.364 of the Criminal Code — malpractice committed by a law enforcement officer).



Hunger Strike by Yuriy Lutsenko — 30 days, and 25 kg
Protesting against the illegal arrest, Yuriy Lutsenko April 23, 2011 began a hunger strike (during the hunger strike he had not eaten anything, but drank coffee with sugar). April 28 — signed by an official act for the management of the jail «voluntary refusal of food», to May 10 — lost 19.5<ref

«During the hunger strike in jail Lutsenko has lost 20 pounds». The site of the newspaper «Facts», 10.05.2011.] kg body weight and «transferred to the medical unit Lukyanovka jail due to ill health». the same day — Lutsenko admitted to the «Kiev hospital ambulance on the street. Bratislava, 3» On May 19 due to poor health — Lutsenko put «drip glucose, intravenous nutrition.» May 23, 2011 was scheduled for trial, which was a question of a «preventive measure» (ie, Lutsenko to release from custody). Lutsenko stopped the hunger strike — only after the trial, May 23 (to stand, so a 30-day hunger strike, losing about 25 kg of weight) — he said:
 * «I consider it inappropriate to continue the hunger strike. I started it to prove that we have in Ukraine there is no prosecution. Today’s sessions of the court I have proved that we do not have a fair trial, but I need more health in order to break it».

«Letters from Prison»
While in detention, Lutsenko has written (by June 2011) six «Letters from Prison» — journalistic articles on topical political issues.

Lutsenko supported — Head of the Committee of the EU-Ukraine Marek Siwiec
29 June 2011 head of the «Parliamentary Cooperation Committee», «European Union»-Ukraine in the European Parliament, Marek Siwiec (former head of the «Polish National Security Bureau») — officially appealed to the Ukrainian authorities to release Lutsenko to court — under his personal guarantee:

— «I have decided to appeal to the competent judicial authorities (Ukraine) to consider my personal guarantee for the release of Lutsenko and giving them freedom to stand trial, — said the MEP. Siwiec recalled the European Parliament resolution, which states an increase in prosecutions of former government and the opposition».

Important European Parliament resolution: «Cases of Yulia Tymoshenko and other members of the former government»
June 9, 2011 «The European Parliament» has — a very important resolution on Ukraine, «Yulia Tymoshenko affairs and other members of the former government»:

— «The European Parliament, taking into account its previous resolutions on Ukraine, in particular its resolution of November 25, 2010 … Taking into consideration the statement of its President on the detention of Yulia Tymoshenko’s May 24, 2011, taking into account the statement by EU High Representative Catherine Ashton of 26 May 2011 in the case of Yulia Tymoshenko, taking into account the statement of Commissioner Stefan Fule, after his meeting with Yulia Tymoshenko, March 24, 2011 …

1. Stresses the importance of ensuring maximum transparency of investigations, prosecutions and court, and also warns against the possible use of criminal justice as a means of achieving political goals.

2. Concerned about the rise of selective prosecution of political opponents in Ukraine, as well as the disproportionate measures used, particularly in the case of Tymoshenko and former Interior Minister Lutsenko, draws attention to the fact that Lutsenko is under arrest in December 26, 2010»

Evaluation of the U.S. government and European Union countries
June 24, 2011 U.S. State Department said that the trial of Yulia Tymoshenko is politically motivated trial of the opposition.

June 22, 2010 (the eve of the trial of the Timoshenko) — British Ambassador to Ukraine Leigh Turner — gave an interview to «The Day», where the Ukrainian authorities have warned of persecution of the opposition:
 * «We are closely watching the development of criminal cases against former government officials… We are concerned about the assumptions about possible political motives of those cases. While Ukraine holds negotiations on an Association Agreement with the EU and the chair of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe, we call on the Ukrainian authorities to ensure compliance by Ukraine of their international obligations … We will continue to monitor the subsequent consideration of these cases in the courts, especially the cases filed against leaders of opposition political forces … In case of deterioration of the situation, we will be forced to reconsider its position and will consult with our European and other international partners on the most appropriate response. Now we have clearly explained to the representatives of Ukrainian authorities, that any impression of selective and disproportionate use of legal action can significantly and permanently damage the international image of Ukraine».

«Square Tax-2010», «Common Cause» as Tymoshenko supporters
«Tax Maidan-2010,» although by themselves before going to the «small and medium-sized enterprises» (under the leadership of the organization «Common Cause»), but among the political forces, they focused primarily on the «united opposition Tymoshenko»:
 * On the «Square Tax-2010» were «house deputies from the Yulia Tymoshenko Bloc (and from the People’s Self-Defense), which were declared as adoptive BYuT deputies and National Assembly» to protect against interference Maidan police station. BYuT does not take the lead in «Tax Maidan», but cooperation with BYuT was clear — in those days, A. Turchynov said: «We helped with tents, and our deputies are constantly on duty at A. Turchynov: We helped with tents, and our deputies are constantly on duty at the Maidan». The site «RBC-Ukraine», 2.12.2010.]
 * On the first day of Maidan with a keynote speech («Maidan demands veto on tax fascism», 11/22/2010.) Has made Tymoshenko. On stage, she stood with the leader of the Maidan-2010, leader of the organization «Common Cause» Alexander Danyluk.
 * By the «common cause» and its leader, Alexander Danyluk, certainly recognized Timoshenko, «opposition leader», and repeatedly participated in joint meetings in 2011, Danyluk also said many times about this in his speeches (see youtube.com / watch? v=GYXrkZ42_1c Speech by Danilyuk at a rally in support of Tymoshenko (near Pechersk court, 24/06/2011), where Danyluk recognize themselves and their organization as an «ally Tymoshenko»).

Developments on «Tax Maidan-2010»
The fall of 2010 in Ukraine, a wave of mass Photographic materials on the topic «Tax Maidan». The site of the newspaper «Moskovsky Komsomolets», № 25 507, 24.11.2010.] of small and medium-sized businesses — they were protesting against a number of steps, «Yanukovych» to reduce «social standards» by conducting a series of «oligarchic reforms»:
 * New «Tax Code» suggested significantly (several times) to raise taxes on «small business» (especially increased taxes for the «smallest businesses», which until then was the «simplified tax system»), also suffered from medium-sized businesses. Individual entrepreneurs were forbidden (by introducing an additional fee) to perform work for the «legal persons», also provided «proof housing entrepreneur Tax Inspectorate without warrants.»
 * New «Pension Code» and «Labor Code» — also significantly worsened the situation of the masses.

The culmination of the protests was «tax Maidan» (all-Ukrainian meeting «of small and medium-sized enterprises» vs. «Tax Code Azarov, Tigipko» was held 22.11.2010 — 03.12.2010). Maidan-2010 has made the abolition of «destroying small business provisions of the „Tax Code Azarov, Tigipko“». In these protests, «small and medium enterprises» supported almost exclusively by BYT Timoshenko (22.11.2010 Tymoshenko came to Independence Square with a keynote speech); at the beginning of the protests — BYT sought not a substitute for the «movement entrepreneurs» to provide «mass action, free from political confrontation».

Crackdown on «Tax Maidan-2010», the arrests of activists
November 27, 2010 in the tent to the protesters on Independence Square — came President Yanukovich and Prime Minister Azarov, they promised to entrepreneurs «to hear their requests.» Indeed, some of the most odious provisions of the «Tax Code» has been corrected in the new edition of the Code 29.11.2010, but:

— 3 December 2010 the police demolished the tents of the remaining activists of the «Tax Maidan». : «At 5:00 am Square was surrounded by four zagradotryadami MUP».

— 28 December 2010 have been arrested three activists of the «Tax Maidan»: Garkavenko IA Zaplatkin O. V. Gruzinov and a fourth person arrested (co-organizer stock Mandic Alexander) was soon released. As of 14 January 2011 — were criminal cases for 7 activists of the «Tax Maidan», are entrepreneurs: Okhtyrka, Mandic, Kavenko, Zaplatkin, Georgians, Melnichenko, Fedchuk. They are charged with «damaging the tiles on the Independence Square», a $ 230 thousand UAH. (21 thousand euros.) He was charged under the article «intentional destruction of or damage to another’s property, causing damage on a large scale, by prior agreement of parties.» They are accused of damaging the granite covering the area of Independence Square — through hammering in the granite coating of metal rods in the number of 132 «They arrested three activists of the tax Maidan». The site «Comments PRO.UA», 29.12.2010.]

— In December 2010 — was arrested and activist of the «Tax Maidan» Sergei Costache (as of July 2011 is in jail).

Thus, for the «peaceful protests against the Tax Code» (which was still largely repealed and revised in consultation with the president and prime minister) — were arrested and are in jail without trial for more than seven months (as of July 2011) 8 people. The leader of the «Tax Maidan» Alexander Danyluk and «association of small entrepreneurs» — continue to cooperate with BYT Tymoshenko during the protests in May-August 2011.

Collaboration with President Yanukovych part of the opposition, which does not recognize the leader Tymoshenko
However, there is some opposition, which does not recognize Tymoshenko as their leader, and therefore can not qualify as «associates Timoshenko» — although it is also a certain detachment of the opposition. After coming to power of Viktor Yanukovych have been targeted and arrested almost exclusively political team Tymoshenko and Ministers of the Cabinet of Ministers.

Companions Yushchenko
Viktor Yanukovych with working part of the opposition — the closest associates Viktor Yushchenko obtained high positions: minister «of the Ministry of Emergency Situations» Balogh ; chairman of the Supervisory Board of the National Bank Peter «Chairman of the Board of the National Bank of Ukraine Petro Poroshenko supports the establishment of national land registry.» UNIAN, 05.04.2011.] Ambassador to Belarus — [[Immortal, Roman Petrovich|Roman Immortal Eugene Chervonenko — Head of Aviation

Boxing. Chervonenko: «The Ukrainian flag will protect a person Haye», 02.07.2011.] Vladislav On the appointment of B. Kaskiva Chairman of the State Agency for Investment and management of national projects in Ukraine] (former leader of [[Time (Party)|«Time» prior to October 2006) — The head of the «State Agency for Investments and Management of National Projects»; Marina Stavniychuk (term Venice Commission) — worked for a while, «Deputy Head of Presidential Administration Yanukovych».

Other political forces opozitsionnye
Also, there is no prosecution with regard to political forces, ex-speaker of the Arseniy Yatseniuk Sergei Tigipko Anatoly Gritsenko Oleg Tyahnybok.

There are examples of cooperation with Yanukovych even «former politicians BYT», but only if these policies — complete break with the BYT. Two of them were «notable posts»:
 * Feldman (№ 43 in the lists of the 2007 elections BYuT, the former head of BYuT in Kharkiv region, the owner large market in Kharkov) — 25.06.2010 removed from the Buttes «Fatherland» (but the parliamentary mandate of BYT — refused to surrender) 03/16/2011 entered into «Regions Party», 7/8/2011 elected political council [[The Party

«Today, at a meeting of the Political Council of Party of Regions MP, member of Party of Regions parliamentary faction Oleksandr Feldman was elected a member of the Political Council». The site «Comments.ua», 8.7.2011.]
 * Portnov (№ 58 lists BYuT election-2007, a famous lawyer, group «Privat», led a team of lawyers Tymoshenko on the process after the presidential election, 2010) — Defender Tymoshenko went to work for Yanukovych] was appointed to the post of «Deputy Head of Presidential Administration» (chapter AP had nine alternate members). At the same time excluded from the Buttes «Fatherland», 4/16/2010 handed «deputies from BYuT mandate.» 05/04/2011 fired from office, «the deputy head of presidential administration.»

Feldman and Taylor — in the past «important members of BYT,» but not «close associates Tymoshenko» (№ 43, № 58 in the list). Total of «faction BYuT» — for the 2010—2011 year were excluded (mainly for «voting against the decision of the faction»), about a third of the deputies — out of 156 remained «a little over 100 members» (July 2011).

Multimedia content

 * General Makarenko and T. Shepitko freed from jail (after years in detention without trial), 07.05.2011.
 * Lutsenko (his wife, his brother) in the courtroom — his comments on yesterday’s arrest. 27.12.2010. Lutsenko (27/12/2010) in the district court of Kyiv Caves the next day after his arrest: «If Thief came to power, the Minister of Police should sit down».
 * Statement Tymoshenko on the day of arrest Didenko, 09/07/2010: «The authorities need to legalize their right — to take away from Ukraine (for RosuUkrEnergo) 5.4 billion dollars … This in Ukraine has never been over 19 years of independence».
 * Statements in court Didenko
 * General Valeriy Ivashchenko escorted to the treatment of «hospital emergency room». Firtash TV channel «Inter», 03/20/2011.
 * history of state officials, immigrants from Ukraine (Zvyagilsky, Lazarenko, Zherditsky, Buckeye, Bodelan, Belokon …) due to the «work of Bohdan Danylyshyn». The TV channel «TVi» transfer «exclamation point» (ukr. Badge hail), Natalie Siedlce. Kyiv, 18.11.2010. second series (it was dedicated to «the cause of Danylyshyn»), Kyiv, 20.11.2010.
 * «Firtash, Boiko, Inter. 12 billion cubic meters of gas to RosUkrEnergo. It was majestic — it became a private». 10 series gas investigation of the program «exclamation point» (ukr. Badge hail), TV channel «TVi». 29.11.2010.
 * «Tax Maidan», Kyiv, 22.11.2010.
 * «Tax Maidan», Kiev, 11.22.2010 (displaces people from Maidan police station — chanting «Shame (shame)» and «police and the people»).
 * Yulia Tymoshenko: «Maidan requires a veto on tax fascism» (keynote address on the first day of the «Tax Maidan»). 22/11/2010.