User:WeepingBritney/Jasmonic acid student review

Breadth (5) Does the article cover its field completely? Yes Are all the common terms of the field defined? Are all the basic concepts of the field described? The article could have gone into more detail as to the specific role of Jasmonic Acid on a molecular level. Were important topics missed? No. Depth (5) Amount of detail appropriate for topic- Yes, is very specific about roles and is clear. Gives more information then Lehninger (wasn't even mentioned). History given? No, does not provide history of how it was synthesized or developed. Readability/Writing (4) Is the writing clear? Yes Is the writing interesting? Yes, brief and to the point. Is the writing organized, good flow? Yes Architecture to the article (beginning, middle, end)? Yes. Is the writing redundant? No. Learnability (4) Is the level of explanation good for undergraduate students? Not too simple or complex? I feel like it is just the very basic information about it. The article needs to go into depth about the exact role that Jasmonic Acid plays and how it interacts with other hormones.. etc. Is the teaching well-organized, clear progression of topics? Yes. Figures (4) Are there Figures at all? One drawing of its structure Are the Figures clear? Yes, also has a table which provides some scientific information about it. Are the Figures three-dimensional?NO Are the Figures consistent with each other? Only one. References (3) Are there references? Just one Are the references recent? Did not provide a date Are the references from "good" journals? Didn't say where it was from. I think it's from a textbook. Quality (4) How up-to-date is the article? When would this article have last been an up-to-date review of the field? It is up to date. Glaring errors, minor errors, and misleading statements? None How precise and quantitative is the article? It's very good.

Britannica did not mention Jasmonic Acid or Jasmonate

Breadth (0) Depth (0) Readability (0) Learnability (0) Figures (0) References (0) Quality(0)