User:Wikieditor933/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Christine Michel Carter

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose to evaluate this article because it is an article about women's rights that is classifies as a start class article with low importance.

Evaluate the article
(Compose a detailed evaluation of the article here, considering each of the key aspects listed above. Consider the guiding questions, and check out the examples of what a useful Wikipedia article evaluation looks like.)

Lead Section

The lead section of this article is concise and straight to the point. However, the lead section fails to list the articles main sections and does not provide a brief overview of the article. If a reader wants a quick overview of the article they will not find it in this lead section.

Content

The articles content is relevant to the topic. It content includes important aspects of Carter's life such as her writing career and her work in advocacy. The section titled "Personal Life", however, discusses Carter's marriage particularly her divorce with her husband. This piece of information seems out of place within the article's main focus on women's rights.

Tone

The article has an academic tone with no indicated bias.

Sources and References

This article contains multiple sources that are relevant to the topic. Most of the sources are current and up to date. However, there is a lack of scholarly sources. The sources found in this article mainly originate from some blogs and websites. Nevertheless, the sources in this article are appropriate for the topic at hand. There are multiple links which are relevant and provide additional information for the reader.

Organization

The article does have organization and structure. However, there is only one main section which discusses her career. There could also be more information added to this section.

Images

The article contains some images and media that are relevant to the topic. All media used in the article are properly labeled and abide by Wikipedias copyright policy.

Talk Page

The articles talk page currently has no ongoing discussions.

Overall Impressions

The article is rated as a C-class article. The article provides some basic information about Christine Michel Carter and her career. Its organization is clear and well-structured which makes the article easy to navigate. Its tone is also unbiased and academic. However, the article could use more information in its lead section in order to provide readers with a basic overview. It could also do without some irrelevant information such as Carter's divorce and her marriage life which does not contribute anything of significance to the article.