User:Worm That Turned/Lightweight community desysop

At the moment, the sysop can be removed through a number of processes.

Timeline

Idea
Current Arbcom desysop process takes nearly 2 months. Multiple admins have recently left the encyclopedia when faced with it, more after going through it (c.f. recent cases open by arbcom on hold) Create a lightweight process - similar to Administrators/RfC for BARC - a community desysopping process, which closed as no consensus with 115:77 in support.

Feedback from BARC

 * Criticism
 * Don't need a second Arbcom
 * Bureaucrats weren't elected for this
 * No community making a decision
 * Too bureaucratic
 * Power from those who can be voted out to those who can't

Suggestion: Group of Peers below like opt in jury service. Bot to choose random eligible users.


 * Proposal not fleshed out enough
 * Need to be ready to use before proposing. Make clear it can be altered in the future.
 * "We already have a process that works"
 * Takes too long. Admins quitting if they're subjected to it.


 * Positive thing to keep
 * Gate keeper to stop frivolous complaints.

Group of peers
The group should consist of 11 random users who meet all the following criteria:
 * Users who have added themselves to Category:Community desysop group of peers
 * Users who are currently active (at least 50 edits in the last 30 days)
 * Users who have made at least 1000 edits and 1 year of tenure
 * Users who are not currently blocked or partially blocked
 * Users who do not currently have any editing restrictions
 * Users who not INVOLVED with the administrator

When a request is started, a bot will scour the category for random users who meet the criteria, and put a message on the talk page of the first 11. Those users will then either accept being part of the group, or not - if not, or if no response in 24 hours, the bot will request more individuals.

This group of peers will deliberate make the final decision.