User:Wslack/Desk

For AMA business

Links

 * 1) Policy Library
 * WP:LOP
 * WP:Guidelines


 * 1) Resolving Disputes
 * 2) Foundation issues on Meta
 * 3) Copyrights
 * 4) General disclaimer
 * 5) Civility
 * 6) Etiquette
 * 7) Assume Good Faith
 * 8) No Personal Attacks
 * 9) WP:LAWYER

AMA business
Hi all, I'm -- \/\/slack (talk) with the AMA. I've been looking over this page and its related ones. Here are some observations:


 * Realsched.exe violates NPOV, and contains almost no useful content. As a part of RealPlayer, issues with it should be in the criticism section, with link for both sides of the pro-con argument.
 * There is no reason to call RealPlayer a good audio/video player without a citation. There is also no reason to call it a bad audio/video player without a citation.
 * A reviews section would be helpful with leading reviews from various sources. The "Worst 25" listing would go here.
 * RealAlternative would go under the Criticisms section (which differs from reviews in that it focuses on negative aspects found, as opposed to features, which does positive aspects)
 * Users must keep their personal feelings out of this article. Everything said should be referenced, especially considering what has been said.

Comments

 * A reviews section would be helpful with leading reviews from various sources. The "Worst 25" listing would go here.
 * RealAlternative would go under the Criticisms section (which differs from reviews in that it focuses on negative aspects found, as opposed to features, which does positive aspects)
 * You mean, it should be three sections: Criticism, Reviews, and Features? Or only Criticisms (negative aspects) and Reviews (positive aspects)? --Urod 15:56, 6 September 2006 (UTC)