User:Wyndham Freeman/Solange II

Changelog
Added many more details in the facts section and the entire significance section.

Facts
The appellant applied for an import license and was refused. The appellant challenged the import licensing regime (Regulation 2107/74) in the Frankfurt Administrative Court (Verwaltungsgericht), but the case was dismissed. The court held that the regulation was passed in accordance with the objectives of art. 39 EC (art. 45 TFEU).

The case was appealed to the Federal Supreme Administrative Court (Bundesverwaltungsgericht), which suspended the case and sent a preliminary reference to the European Court of Justice (ECJ). The ECJ responded that the regulation was valid. In response, the appellant appealed to the German Federal Constitutional Court (GFCC, BverfGE, Bundesverfassungsgericht), citing several breaches of German constitutional rights. The appellant claimed that, following with the judgment of Solange I, the GFCC should disapply EU law which conflicts with the fundamental rights protection afforded in the German Basic Law (Grundgesetz).

German Federal Constitutional Court
The Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht) ultimately rejected the complaint.

since the 1974 Solange I decision,

Significance
In contrast to the earlier Solange I decision, the Federal Constitutional Court accepted the judgment of the ECJ as binding and final in Germany. It is notable that the GFCC did not give up its competence to scrutinize EU law in light of the German Basic Law's fundamental rights. Rather they suspended this scrutiny, to be renewed if a case could demonstrate a decline of fundamental rights standards in the EU below those guaranteed by the Basic Law.

Additionally, both Solange I and Solange II demonstrate an atmosphere of constructive argument within the European courts. The Solange Doctrine of the GFCC helped the ECJ and EU institutions to eventually develop their own systems of fundamental rights protection, offering an equal or higher level of protection than the German Basic Law.