User:Yejin04/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title : Plastic pollution :
 * Article Evaluation : This article is too long to read all, but this article containing lots of informations. this article is looks like overly detailed. Also it is content relevant to the topic which is about pollution. I think there is no missing things to make informations and warning about plastic pollution. this problem is kind of heavy topic, so the tone is giving warning to the readers. this article is based with facts that our earth is getting worse because of pollutions, and nature get disturb by plastics. the article contain a lots of sources that related to plastic pollution. the sources are cited in the second page named "sources". Pollution is present problems, so they include few current references. when I check few specifically 6 links, they are all working. this article is nice to look, which is good organizations, also the writing quality is high to know about the topics. it is hard to read because too long, but the sentences and paragraphs are clear to read. they contain lots of images, and the images makes more clear understanding or giving informations quickly. there is not many discussion on talk page, but they says the Oceans part is low importance in the article. my overall status is 8 out of 10. this article's strengths are makes us to think our life specifically about plastics. this article could be improved to be more clear and short pages. :
 * Sources : Plastic pollution :

Option 2

 * Article title : Roh Moo-hyun (Korea past President) :
 * Article Evaluation : this article include the article's topic which is about the president. there is detailed but the rumors are not include, so is is not detailed, also it doesn't contain fakes. the president was died in 2009, so there is no current relevant to the topic. I did not know very much of him because when he was in the president's sit, when I was not born yet to 4 yrs old. so I am not sure there is any missing informations, but I am agree that there is enough informations to know about that time and his life. the article's tone is not deep, but this make us to know better in the time that he was working. also it contain just general informations about the president's life, but on death section, there is heavy pointed. the viewpoints are became with Korea citizens and other people that know about him. sources are working I check 7 sources in the "source" page. the president died in 2009, so there is no current sources or informations. he was not a stars that have a lots of informations because of his privacy, so I cannot find better articles. the organizations are good to read, that following the times of him. writing quality is not that hard but some words or sentences are not clear to understand. within those, other sentences or paragraphs make clear to understand about the topic. there is not that much of images, but for the image, it makes more understanding or giving specific informations to topic. in "talk page", there is some discussion for the politics but not as much to know him better. the article's overall status is 9 out of 10. this article is more easy to write or making article, because it is the life journey about one person. the article's strengths are that makes to know about the president, Roh Moo-hyun, also know the informations about him that why he make that decisions or the human's weaknesses. this article could be improved with make more smooth sentences to know, also there is too many things contain about provocative things.   :
 * Sources : Roh Moo-hyun :

Option 3

 * Article title : Niagara (Frederic Edwin Church) :
 * Article Evaluation : this article include the describes about Painting Art named "Niagara", specifically the artist Frederic Edwin Church. in my opinion, the informations are not clear to understand the topic. it is concise article. the article's content relevant to the topic which is the Art's theme or the meanings. I saw this Art piece in Corcoran Collection, National Gallery of Art in Washington D.C. the narrator in the Gallery tells a lots of information, but there was few missing points in the Wikipedia. this article is appear not heavy biased because this is the only thing that information about one Art piece. the article's makes to better knowing to the Art Piece. the Article's sources are based on the Art Piece, Niagara, so almost every references are based on human think. Art could be pointed in very many ways. I check 4 links to make sure that this is available sources and all works. the sources are not current because it is not that famous Art Work in the Art field. So there is not many articles or news that contain the Art, "Niagara". this article is short, so the organizations are good enough to read. also the writing quality is professional, so if the reader is interest in Arts, it will be clear to read. but who is not knowing much of Art, they was hard to understand. Images are the Art and Gallery. so there was not many images, but the most important thing which is the Art "Niagara" and the Artist Frederic Edwin Church. there is no discussion for the article. this article rated B class. my overall status for the article is 7 out of 10. the article's strengths are that containing the informations and also the meaning, the processings. the article's improvement is that contain more information that about why and how to make this Art Piece. :
 * Sources : Niagara (Frederic Edwin Church) :