User:Yellowedpage/Evaluate an Article

Evaluate an article
This is where you will complete your article evaluation. Please use the template below to evaluate your selected article.


 * Name of article: Wahkohtowin
 * I am Cree and have a vested interest in the representation of Wahkohtowin on the internet. It is also highly relevant to the NS504 course.

Lead


'''The introduction is concise and clear. It does not include a description of the articles major sections. The lead includes only information available in the article. The lead is not overly detailed.'''

Content
'''The article's content is relevant to the topic. The content was last updated in Feb 2020, so relatively up to date editing. I believe content from community sources/more recent academic work is missing. This article is dealing with one of wiki's equity gaps.'''

Tone and Balance
'''The tone is neutral. No heavily biased claims. I believe the community is underrepresented, though not sure how to include. No persuasion that I can see.'''

Sources and References
'''The facts are sourced well. Most recent source is 5 years old. Good mix of Indig. and Settler scholar sources. The links work. Sources could be more plentiful, I think.'''

Organization
'''The article is clear and concise. No errors. Well organized'''

Images and Media
I would like to see images, there are none.

Checking the talk page
'''No conversations, start class, low importance. Part of the wikiproject Indigenous Peoples of North America.'''

Overall impressions
'''Not active. The article is concise and clear, the article needs more citations of newer articles and real world examples of wahkohtowin, it would also be good to see media on the page. I don't believe the article is complete.'''

Optional activity

 * Link to feedback: Talk:Wahkohtowin