User:Yuhang Zheng/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title
 * Zhang Nuanxin
 * Article Evaluation
 * The article’s content is relevant to the topic. It is biographic introduction of Zhang Nuanxin, the director of Sacrificed Youth. The article is neutrally written, and no persuasion of viewpoint is shown. Citations are properly included in each claim. Citations are mostly academic sources, which appear to be quite reliable. The article introduces a female director (not widely known) in Chinese history, which tackles the equity gaps. On the Talk page, one adds some information to the director’s early career section. Also, another user expressed their concern about the accuracy of Chinese geography mentioned in the article. They also suggested that the author could include more information on the director’s aesthetic style.
 * Article Evaluation
 * The article’s content is relevant to the topic. It is biographic introduction of Zhang Nuanxin, the director of Sacrificed Youth. The article is neutrally written, and no persuasion of viewpoint is shown. Citations are properly included in each claim. Citations are mostly academic sources, which appear to be quite reliable. The article introduces a female director (not widely known) in Chinese history, which tackles the equity gaps. On the Talk page, one adds some information to the director’s early career section. Also, another user expressed their concern about the accuracy of Chinese geography mentioned in the article. They also suggested that the author could include more information on the director’s aesthetic style.
 * The article’s content is relevant to the topic. It is biographic introduction of Zhang Nuanxin, the director of Sacrificed Youth. The article is neutrally written, and no persuasion of viewpoint is shown. Citations are properly included in each claim. Citations are mostly academic sources, which appear to be quite reliable. The article introduces a female director (not widely known) in Chinese history, which tackles the equity gaps. On the Talk page, one adds some information to the director’s early career section. Also, another user expressed their concern about the accuracy of Chinese geography mentioned in the article. They also suggested that the author could include more information on the director’s aesthetic style.


 * Sources
 * Dai, Jinhua. "The visible and the invisible: The Chinese Female Film and Chinese Female Film Maker." September 23, 2013. - http://www.doc88.com/p-4774137693988.html
 * ^ Jump up to: a b c d e f g h Zhang, Zhenqin. From “self-consciousness” to “freedom”—The studies of Nuanxin Zhang’s filmmaking." Films in the new period, from 1977-1987, 1988, 87-98.
 * ^ Jump up to: a b c Li, Meng, and Xiaodong Ma. "The studies of Nuanxin Zhang's film style." Journal of Capital University, April 2012. http://www.xzbu.com/4/view-3690521.htm.
 * ^ Wang, Hetong. "The analysis on the artistic style of Nuanxin Zhang in the historical dimension." Digital Media Studies. Accessed July 2017. http://www.xueshu.com.cn/nmggbydsjs/201707/30308109.html
 * ^ Jump up to: a b Yao, Shuguang. "The Establish of Chinese Film Criticism." New Films, July 26, 2017. http://art.cssn.cn/ysx/ysx_ysx/201707/t20170726_3591651.shtml.

Option 2

 * Article title
 * Sent-down youth
 * Sent-down youth


 * Article Evaluation
 * The article's content befits the theme in Sacrificed Youth.The article is neutrally written and represents a fairly comprehensive introduction of the history of this socialist movement. Citations are properly included in each claim. Director quotations can be found throughout the article. Citations are mostly academic sources, which appear to be quite reliable. One thing noteworthy is that both English and Chinese sources are included to contribute to the page. The article introduces a specific groups socilasit Chinese history, which tackles the equity gaps. On the Talk page, there is a debate over the title of the article. Some considers it is important to include China in the title as it can give readers an indication of what they will read. However, some consider sent-down youth is already a term in Chinese studies. No specific reference to the nation is needed here.
 * The article's content befits the theme in Sacrificed Youth.The article is neutrally written and represents a fairly comprehensive introduction of the history of this socialist movement. Citations are properly included in each claim. Director quotations can be found throughout the article. Citations are mostly academic sources, which appear to be quite reliable. One thing noteworthy is that both English and Chinese sources are included to contribute to the page. The article introduces a specific groups socilasit Chinese history, which tackles the equity gaps. On the Talk page, there is a debate over the title of the article. Some considers it is important to include China in the title as it can give readers an indication of what they will read. However, some consider sent-down youth is already a term in Chinese studies. No specific reference to the nation is needed here.


 * Sources
 * Shu Jiang Lu, When Huai Flowers Bloom, p 114-5 ISBN 978-0-7914-7231-6
 * "Jueding 1966 nian gaodeng xuexiao zhaoshou xinsheng de gongzuo tuichi bannian jinxing决定1966年高等学校招收新生的工作推迟半年进行". State Council 国务院. Retrieved December 24, 2021
 * ^ Zhang, Lixi; Li, Huibo. Funv koushu lishi congshu-nv zhiqing juan妇女口述历史丛书-女知青卷 (in Chinese). pp. 211–213.

Option 3

 * Article title
 * Dai people


 * Article Evaluation
 * The article's content befits the theme in Sacrificed Youth as the film touches upon the intercation of Han people and Dai people during Cultural Revolution. The article is neutrally written and represents a thorough introduction Dai ethnic people. However, some sections are less discussed, such as the section of Literature and Science and Dwellings. Citations are properly included in each claim. Citations are mostly academic sources and sources from authoritative organization. Similar to the previous one, references are in both languages. The article introduces a minority group in China, which tackles the equity gaps. On the Talk page, one editor raises question about the difference between Tai people and Dai people
 * Sources
 * ^ Haimei Shen. Risk Society, the Predicaments of Folk Religion and Experience of Modernity: The Guardian Spirits in the Mandi Dailue Ethnic Society of Xishuangbanna. China: An International Journal, Vol. 11, No. 2
 * ^ Ma, Chuang (2016). "Changes of Intermarriage Circle of the Pashi Dai (Muslims in Dai Society): A Case Study in the Hui Village in Manluan". In Rong, Gui (ed.). Hui Muslims in China. Leuven: Leuven University Press. pp. 87–95. ISBN 978-94-6270-066-6.
 * 云南省地方志编纂委员会 [Yunnan Gazetteer Commission], ed. (1998).   云南省志. 卷五十九, 少数民族语言文字志 [Yunnan Provincial Gazetteer, Vol. 59: Minority Languages Orthographies Gazetteer]. Kunming: 云南人民出版社 [Yunnan People's Press].
 * "Ethnic Groups". China.org.cn. Archived from the original on 2008-07-24. Retrieved 2008-10-17.
 * ^ Ma, Chuang (2016). "Changes of Intermarriage Circle of the Pashi Dai (Muslims in Dai Society): A Case Study in the Hui Village in Manluan". In Rong, Gui (ed.). Hui Muslims in China. Leuven: Leuven University Press. pp. 87–95. ISBN 978-94-6270-066-6.
 * 云南省地方志编纂委员会 [Yunnan Gazetteer Commission], ed. (1998).   云南省志. 卷五十九, 少数民族语言文字志 [Yunnan Provincial Gazetteer, Vol. 59: Minority Languages Orthographies Gazetteer]. Kunming: 云南人民出版社 [Yunnan People's Press].
 * "Ethnic Groups". China.org.cn. Archived from the original on 2008-07-24. Retrieved 2008-10-17.