User:Ywrhea/Evaluate an Article

Evaluate an article

• Name of article: Chinese poetry congress

• I chose this article because it relates to a topic I am interested in. Besides, Chinese poetry congress is a great TV show that promotes traditional Chinese culture.

Lead

• The Lead introduce the article topic in a concise way, but the Lead does not include brief description of the major sections.

Content

• The article's content is corresponding to its topic.

• The content is out of date, because this TV shows has already broadcast 5 seasons, but this article only does not include all of them.

Tone and Balance

• This article illustrates information with a neutral tone, which is very objective.

Sources and References

• The majority of facts in the article can be traced with reliable secondary sources of information. However, some sources are out of date

• The links of this article can work well.

Organization

• This article is concise, clear, and easy to real, but its grammar can be improved.

• Its organization is loosely organized, which requires more cohesion.

Images and Media

Guiding questions

• This article only contains one image, which can be a little bit helpful for understanding this topic. I think this article can add more images to make it more appealing.

Checking the talk page

• There are no many discussions on its talk page. It is rated as “Start”, which is quite reasonable because it lacks much information.

Overall impressions

• This article still requires lots of revise and modification, especially its organization and sources of information has lots of space to improve. It is also necessary to add more details.

~