User:Zachmathewss/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Beethoven concert of 22 December 1808

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because it seemed like it would be very interesting to learn about the details the happened during this concert. I’m imagining this article will talk about the location in which this concert takes place, what music was programmed, and what the audience thought about it.

Evaluate the article
 Evaluating Content 


 * Everything in the article seemed to be relevant to the given topic.
 * All information appears to be up to date. Maybe could add some more details of how each piece performed went during the concert.
 * The article does a good job at representing all populations.

 Evaluating Tone 


 * Overall the article seems neutral, no signs of bias towards a side.
 * Perhaps some viewpoints could be misinterpreted from one’s that attended this concert and gave their regards.

 Evaluating Sources 


 * The sources in citations work and the articles support the claims.
 * Most information that is in citations comes from reliable sources, such as biographies or the Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians.
 * The sources used are a variety of biographies, independent scholars, and university presses.

 Checking The Talk Page 


 * The talk page on this article shows a user questioning why there are so many recreations of this concert listed at the bottom and the writer clarifying as to why there are so many listed.
 * The majority rating of this article is C-class, low importance, with one C-class mid importance.