User:Zattaras/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
I choose Refugee children.

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I choose this article because it focuses on the problems of Refugee Education and also debates the solutions. I will be using it for my Area and Sector portions of this assignment and I have confirmed this with the Professor to only cover one article in this assignment.

Evaluate the article
1) Lead Section

Since I am looking at a subsection of the article, I am looking at the subsection introduction. It only has one small sentence introducing the section and then goes into statistics. I think it could use more of an overview.

2) Sources and References

There are a lot of diverse sources for this article. Most are scholarly and link to where they are used in the article. However most of them don't link out of wikpidiea.

3) Organization and writing quality

The article is organized very well and the sub sections of the Education section is organized well. Although I think that the subsection names can be edited to be more clear. Grammer and Spelling is good.

4) Images and Media

Images are cited properly. However for the length of the article the images used are not alot. They also are captioned well to add to the information and learning of the article.

5) Talk Page Discussion

This article is part of WikiProjects for WikiProject Human rights, WikiProject Globalization, and WikiProject Psychology. Comments on the talk page are very old and talk about how a student was working on this page in the past as part of their course work. This probably means that no has updated or worked on the article in a long time.

6) Overall Impression

Article does a good job outlining the areas and bring you different prospectives and history on Refugee Education in North America. However, it does not talk about the global aspect which is something that I can add too and bring this perspective. I think that aspect needs to be assessed for the article to be complete.