User:Zhuolin Wu/Choose an Article

Choice 1: Free love

Is the article's content relevant to the topic? This article talks about the social movement- free love. The movement intents to separate love from other forms of social interactions like marriage. A lot of the readings in class talks about the relationship between love and marriage. I think the article's content is relevant to the topic.

Is it written neutrally? Since the article mainly focuses on the history of free love, I find it very neutral.

Does each claim have a citation? Most of the claims in this article have a citation, however, some don't. This is where I want to work on. Following is a list of sections that do not currently have any citations: the Utopian Socialism section, Australia, Germany. Also, the Recent section in the article needs more citation.

Are the citations reliable? Yes. The citations are from research, news and scholarly journals. I find the citations reliable.

Does the article tackle one of Wikipedia's equity gaps (coverage of historically underrepresented or misrepresented populations or subjects)? Although the article is about free love, it focuses more on women. With that, I do think that the article tackle Wikipedia's equity gaps.

Choice 2: Maternal bond

Is the article's content relevant to the topic? This article talks about the special bond between mother and the child. The role and the sacrifice of motherhood is frequently talked about in class. I find this topic very relevant.

Is it written neutrally? This article talks about different stages of motherhood that creates maternal bond. It also talks about maternal separation anxiety. I find this article very neutral. However, I do believe that more information can be added to make this article more comprehensive. For example, breastfeeding can play a role in the maternal bond as well.

Does each claim have a citation? Yes. All claims in this article has a citation. The incompleteness of the article is its main concern.

Are the citations reliable? Yes. The citations are from research, books and scholarly journals. I find the citations reliable.

Does the article tackle one of Wikipedia's equity gaps (coverage of historically underrepresented or misrepresented populations or subjects)? The article is about motherhood. Obviously, there is a strong focus on women. I do think that the article tackle one of Wikipedia's equity gaps.

Choice 3: Cycle of abuse

Is the article's content relevant to the topic? This article talks about the cycle of abuse. This is present in a lot of the readings.

Is it written neutrally? This article is neutral.

Does each claim have a citation? Yes. All claims in this article has a citation. The article can be better with more information on the topic.

Are the citations reliable? Yes. The citations are from research, books and scholarly journals.

Does the article tackle one of Wikipedia's equity gaps (coverage of historically underrepresented or misrepresented populations or subjects)? No. The article does not tackle one of Wikipedia's equity gaps.