User:Zlloading/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Political journalism

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose it because I would like to be a political journalist when I grow up, and I was expected an informative page on the history and present day experiences of political journalists.

Evaluate the article
These answers are in response to each bullet point stated above, in direct order from as the questions are stated.


 * Yes
 * No
 * No
 * It is concise.
 * Yes, everything on the page is very relevant
 * It is as up to date as any other Wikipedia page, which is up to date
 * No
 * No
 * Yes
 * No
 * No, a solid combination of view points are presented.
 * Somewhat, yes
 * No
 * Yes
 * Yes
 * Somewhat
 * Yes, 100% I have used them in my journalism classes.
 * Yes
 * Somewhat, yes
 * None that I saw
 * Although short, yes
 * Somewhat, leaning towards no due to the number of photos.
 * Yes
 * Yes
 * Somewhat
 * Not any
 * Low, no
 * They paint it in a much smaller light.
 * The status is meh, and has a lot of work to do until it can be called great.
 * The information and the way in which it is said.
 * More photos, and a longer page as a whole.
 * Underdeveloped.