User talk:119.175.117.169

Gil-galad
Hi, and welcome to WikiProject Middle-earth. You are of course right that there are differing accounts among Tolkien's many drafts in his legendarium. However, you can't just delete whichever version you don't like, along with its cited source! I've reworked the paragraph to explain some of the key changes involved --- somewhat reluctantly, as it's the first thing we say about the character, and it's really complicated. Perhaps a footnote would be better, but whatever we do, we have to cite our sources, that's fundamental to all Wikipedia editing. All the best, Chiswick Chap (talk) 13:51, 28 August 2022 (UTC)