User talk:170.251.220.169

Jonatan Goitía
Hello! Thank you for your edits on the Jonatan Goitía, they are very much appreciated - especially the parts about Banfield and Riestra. However, to keep the article neat and in order I reverted your edits before readding them in the right way. I'm here to explain my revert, just to help you in the future.

Statistics: The source you helpfully provided didn't say when his appearance for Riestra in Primera D Metropolitana was - so it cannot be added to the career statistics as we don't know if it came in 2009-10 or 2010-11. Also, it says he debuted but doesn't specify if it was his sole appearance or one of many - so the infobox apps/goals column needs to be left blank. As well, I noticed you added the Sportivo Barracas	totals to the career stats - this isn't the correct way, as with some players you could be left with a massive, question mark filled, table (see here) so it's best to not include them if they aren't divided into seasons - unfortunately BDFA doesn't do that. Lastly, one season seasons (e.g. Goitía at Atlas) shouldn't have a total row with it - see the manual of style here. P.S. there isn't a need to pipe Primera D Metropolitana to Primera D.

Birth place: For the birth place, Soccerway and BDFA both state Mariano Moreno - they both supersede Diario El Zonda in terms of reliability, El Zonda also just say "Moreno" which isn't that helpful in this case. If you could find other sources to back up Moreno then please share here and then we can have a discussion.

Hopefully this helps, which is my intention and hope it won't discourage you from editing consistently - as I mentioned, the Diario El Zonda addition is a massive help in getting correct content on the article. If you have any questions then please do share, either with me or you could ask the editors at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Football. R96Skinner (talk) 19:42, 24 January 2019 (UTC)