User talk:174.242.73.206

I don't know if you'll see this, as your IP is dynamic, it appears, but the rolling block evidence from books is here. Dicklyon (talk) 21:51, 29 May 2021 (UTC)

I'm not even sure what that means. I've been dealing with these guns for over a decade and I've always seen it as Rolling Block. That's the historical and academic term regardless of what google chart may say. Here are a few examples.

            


 * OK, let's look at those:


 * 1)  – A forum (not a WP:RS).  Yes, has "Remington Rolling Block Rifle" and "Remington Rolling Block rifle" and "Remington Rolling Block military rifle" and "Klamath Indian Reservation Rolling Block" in sentences.
 * 2)  – Magazine article, yes, with "Remington Model No. 5/1902 Rolling Block rifles" and "Remington Rolling Blocks" and "ammo for the Rolling Block" in sentences.
 * 3)  – Editorial with "the Remington rolling block was just as popular"   and "The 'rolling block' nomenclature was never officially used but became a popular nickname" and "U.S. Army shunned the Remington rolling block". Not proper name.
 * 4)  – NRA article with "Remington Model 1871 Rolling Block pistols".  Capped in the context of a specific model designation.  Probably there's more to this article that I can't see, as a non-member.  this other article there has an example of "rolling block" used generically and also "Remington Rolling Block rifle".  So, mixed.
 * 5)  – I can't see the article.  "the Remington Rolling Block Action Rifle" in the one-sentence teaser (copied from the title-case title?).  Clearly over-capitalized.
 * 6)  – I can't see the article.  "Remington's Rolling Block" in the one-sentence teaser.
 * 7)  – No sentences available to check, but lowercase "rolling block" in the table.
 * 8)  – NRA Museum.  "Remington's No. 1 Rolling Block action rifles were available in many calibers. The rolling block action consisted..." and "Remington Single Action Army revolvers, rolling block rifles and pistols...".  So maybe the first is a specific model name, but clearly they support lowercase generic.
 * 9)  – NY History site, gallery label.  "Remington rolling blocks were among the breech-loading rifles and carbines that..."  Lowercase only.
 * 10)  – Grand Rapids Museum.  No use in sentences, so no evidence either way.
 * 11)  – Royal Museum Greenwich. "Remington rolling block pistol. The pistol is half-stocked with a flared butt (no cap) secured by steel strips back and front. The lock is a Remington rolling block in two parts."  Just lowercase.
 * 12)  – Maine memory network.  No sentences, but description "Remington rolling block rifle, 1864" and keyword "rolling block".  Just lowercase.
 * 13)  – Museum of Technology. "The Remington Rolling Block rifle produced... The rolling block is one of the strongest actions... Rolling block rifles were made for smokeless powder cartridges. A rolling block is a form of firearm action..."  Capped only in the context of "Remington Rolling Block", lowercase otherwise.
 * The point is, per WP:NCCAPS we use sentence case for article titles; so don't be distracted by title case in titles in sources; it's not relevant. Dicklyon (talk) 21:54, 30 May 2021 (UTC)


 * I've started a discussion at Talk:Rolling block and copied this list to there. Please join. Dicklyon (talk) 21:59, 30 May 2021 (UTC)