User talk:2001:268:C20C:D6BB:745D:5282:DF3E:BB3

In Wikipedia's "Biographies of living persons" document, the foremost principle for creating biographical content is maintaining a Neutral Point of View (NPOV). The performance of Peloton, which is highly relevant to the subject, exhibited a mixed record during the subject's marketing leadership. However, the initial information posted in the biography was overwhelmingly positive and lacked a neutral perspective.

Users FreeBirdie54 and 2600:1700:2b96:0:9db:c77a:7011:5be8 have consistently attempted to remove balanced information (such as purely objective citations of revenue growth) undermining the page's commitment to neutrality in biographies of public figures. These two users on one hand deem citations referring to declines in revenue growth as irrelevant or caused by extraneous sources, while on the other hand they attempt to selectively use the same data as evidence that the subject matter was hugely successful based on the same metric in a single quarter. It appears they are trying to have their cake and eat it too.

The accusations of vandalism by FreeBirdie54 are silly and unfounded. I have preserved all mentions of awards and major accomplishments in the biography as they were, while Users FreeBirdie54 and 2600:1700:2b96:0:9db:c77a:7011:5be8 have tried to suppress the presence of balanced information. A vandal typically has a specific agenda and aims to remove or manipulate content that contradicts that agenda. Ironically, this is precisely what logs show FreeBirdie54 and 2600:1700:2b96:0:9db:c77a:7011:5be8 have attempted to do in this case.

On 14:40, 2 August 2023, FreeBirdie54 cites Wikipedia's opinion policy as the reason for his or her edits, even though no personal views are highlighted or removed in the editing process. Additionally, during the edit the user dismisses a citation to Peloton's revenue growth as "nonsense," despite the fact that the numbers are verifiable and the subject herself, in an interview with AdAge just three months ago, stressed the importance of marketing leaders being judged by growth metrics.

Furthermore, FreeBirdie54 appears to be displeased that information regarding the subject's emphasis on "music and community in marketing efforts" was included, even though it was originally added by user 2600:1700:2b96:0:9db:c77a:7011:5be8.

Biographical pages are intended to present a neutral and unbiased portrayal of their subjects. Their function is not as fan pages or platforms for self-promotion.