User talk:2601:6C5:300:B230:3D3E:EAC7:9D69:324F

Nick Drake
You can't remove a review just because you don't like it. ... disco spinster   talk  21:58, 4 November 2022 (UTC)


 * I'm requesting a padlock on this article so you and others cannot revert the change.
 * Your characterization of my edit as something I undertook "because I don't like it" is false.
 * The term "depressive" to describe a person who may or may not have depression is insensitive at best. It is defining someone's identity by their mental state, which may involve isolation, trauma, unpredictable chronic stress, and so forth. "Hypersensitive" by definition means that Nick's perception of the world was the problem and not the world itself. His portraits in his videos paint a very different picture. Nick appeared to be an observer and recorder of those disaffected by various forms of social adversity.
 * Saying that "I don't like depressives and those who are hypersensitive and that Nick was both" is a discriminatory ad hominem attack and says nothing about a critique of his music. The source is irrelevant; if anything the fact that the person cited is "famous" for giving music critiques makes it so much the worse. 2601:6C5:300:B230:3D3E:EAC7:9D69:324F (talk) 22:23, 4 November 2022 (UTC)
 * It's the writer's opinion, that's what a music review is, and just because you disagree with it, or think it's insensitive, does not have any relation to whether it should be in the article. ... disco spinster   talk  22:49, 4 November 2022 (UTC)
 * 1) A music review is not shielded from discriminatory language simply because it is a music review. I'm curious if you would have that attitude if the author used the "Ni" word in a review about a black artist?
 * 2) It is not a music review simply because it is written by a music reviewer. It has to contain something of substance pertaining to the music itself, not just discriminatory platitudes 2601:6C5:300:B230:3D3E:EAC7:9D69:324F (talk) 23:12, 4 November 2022 (UTC)
 * You seem to be under the impression that your opinion should dictate what goes and what doesn't go into a Wikipedia article. It doesn't. Incidentally, if Robert Christgau used the "n-word" in a review about a black artist, that would be newsworthy in itself. ... disco spinster   talk  00:06, 5 November 2022 (UTC)