User talk:2603:8000:C33E:E2BD:F938:D7A2:DDB0:495D

Edits to Ur, Uruk etc.
Hi there, please stop trying to add tables to these articles and discuss your edits on the respective talk pages first. Thanks! Zoeperkoe (talk) 13:24, 1 March 2023 (UTC)


 * I noticed that you reverted my editions for Uruk and Ur, but I'm not entirely sure why. For Uruk; I added the names of a few rulers that weren't previously there but could be found on the same source in which a few of the rulers (not named on the Sumerian King List) already in the table could be found. That same source even names the periods in which the rulers may have lived in. For Ur; I added the names of the kings from the second dynasty which appear nowhere else on Wikipedia. 2603:8000:C33E:E2BD:54C3:B403:82A9:7CE2 (talk) 16:39, 1 March 2023 (UTC)
 * In some cases the revert may have removed information that could have been useful, but also in a number of cases rulers were added to these tables that are unlikely to have been historical, even though (some) older books claim them to be. The fact that a ruler appears in something like the Sumerian King List usually is not sufficient evidence that he was historical. This is especially true for all the so-called "antediluvian" rulers. If you want to add rulers again, I would suggest to provide a reference for each individual ruler that you add to any of the tables. Hope that helps a bit! Zoeperkoe (talk) 09:15, 2 March 2023 (UTC)
 * The rulers on the Sumerian King List have been on the Uruk article for roughly half a decade, though; in fact, you only re-added those same rulers with the current revision. I added rulers from the same source used for Lugalnamniršumma, Lugalsilâsi I, and Urzage to add Lugalsilâsi II and Ursangpae (among others), but you removed the latter for whatever reason--none of which appear anywhere else on Wikipedia. Entirely up to you. I'd much rather not start an edit war over this. If you feel that those rulers aren't as important as the ones from the SKL and/or that the source isn't sufficiently reputable to be used to add the other Uruk rulers named on it, then so be it. 2603:8000:C33E:E2BD:1580:C209:4D7C:CD6B (talk) 11:39, 2 March 2023 (UTC)
 * Maybe I acted too fast. My apologies. Feel free to make the edits that you feel are necessary. Zoeperkoe (talk) 10:20, 4 March 2023 (UTC)