User talk:35.2.101.55

Topic Peer Review 1
Hey Group 1! I read through your Wikipedia draft and it appears to be on the right track! There are a few suggestions I have that could be beneficial!

First, you should consider describing what RNA recognition motifs are in detail for non-experts to specifically introduce what PABPC is dealing with. Why is PABPC important? What is its general role in cellular biology? It seems to me that the first section is a little confusing on why RRMs are important. However, I liked how you supported your RRM findings with the study that describes how RRMs look like. You could go into more depth with how the structure of RRM is related to its function. Also, you briefly talk about the domains of human and yeast, but not prokaryotes. Are PABPCs in both eukaryotes and prokaryotes identical? Explaining about the difference/similarity between the two groups will enhance the quality of your page. The PABP and eRF3 interaction is mentioned, but also should be explained further. The Wiki page seems to have the general outline of the final product, yet lack the sufficient length of a particular Wikipedia page. I'm sure you guys will have it completed before the due date, so I'm not really worried about that. This page should have hyperlinks for certain terms, so we can refer back to already existing pages to learn more about them. The Rotavirus and the example of mutation OPMD are good examples related to this binding structure, but they should be explained more specifically since some of the information sounds a lot like the simple abstract of the whole picture. In addition, there should be lots of figures to make the page more intriguing! You have 5 references, including non-journal ones, but they should be in the right reference format! Overall, you did a good job providing the outline of the binding structure. I liked how you explained the studies and the specific biological basis behind the structure to show credibility. Good work people!

limjiho1835.2.113.83 (talk) 18:17, 22 October 2015 (UTC)