User talk:Aaron at Elenberg Fraser

Wikipedia editing
Hello Aaron, please be aware that your recent edits to Elenberg Fraser are apparently in breach of several Wikipedia editing guidelines, including WP:COI and WP:EL. -- ELEKHHT 03:23, 27 April 2015 (UTC)


 * I have read all the guidelines and I am confused as to where the problem is. Elekhh you stated on the talk page that the Selected Awards and Selected projects list should be added, which I did. I was in the process of verifying them all with links such as I see on all the other architecture firm pages, but my changes were all deleted. Rather then referring me to pages of guidelines would it be possible to make a suggestion as to what was done wrongly or how it should be done? I have no interests in adding promotional text or similar, I want a completely unibiased and informative Wikipedia entry. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Aaron at Elenberg Fraser (talk • contribs) 27 April 2015‎


 * You removed a referenced encyclopaedic and neutral description and replaced it with a description that was shorter, more promotional in tone and based on a primary source. The result of such an edit could have been the deletion of the article, hence the quick revert. With the attempted additions of projects and awards there were three problems: (1) this is an encyclopedic article that supposed to summarize the most relevant facts about the subject. It shouldn't contain non-notable awards or non-awards (such as 'finalist' or 'shortlisted'), (2) both projects and awards have to be referenced, (3) references should follow the referencing guideline, and not be embedded in the text as external links. I explained all this already on the article's talk page. When I get the chance I will try to make the changes for you. -- ELEKHHT 23:13, 29 April 2015 (UTC)