User talk:Adshadem

Welcome
Hello, Adshadem, and welcome to Wikipedia! It appears you are a course instructor leading a class project.


 * New to Wikipedia or want to learn about best practices for Wikipedia assignments?

The training includes instructions for setting up a structured course page, with tools for tracking student work and encouraging peer review. Please also see this helpful advice for instructors.

If you run into problems or want some feedback on your Wikipedia assignment plans, try posting to the education noticeboard.

We hope you like it here and encourage you to stay after your assignment is finished! Thegooduser  Life Begins With a Smile :)  🍁 21:45, 2 February 2019 (UTC)

Feedback on Women in the Economy (Winter I)
Hello Adshadem, if I understand correctly you're the instructor for the students editing for the "Women in the Economy (Winter I)" course. First off, I'm very impressed by the quality of your students' articles - I've reviewed a handful of them so far as part of New Page Patrol and they've been very well-written and well-sourced. I did notice one issue that several had in common that I wanted to bring to your attention: most of them have a fairly extensive "Research and Publications" section. This isn't inherently a problem, but the issue is that the content of these sections looks like synthesis - it's analysis of the subject's publications by the students. Around Wikipedia, we want to hear what independent, reliable sources say, rather than what our contributors come up with on their own. This isn't a pressing issue, and I will tag these sections for other editors to review and possibly clean up, but I wanted to start a conversation with you about this in the hope that we could maybe find a better way for future students to approach this topic while still meeting your course objectives. If you reply, please make sure to ping me with so that I see your message. Thanks, and I look forward to hearing from you! creffett (talk) 00:35, 27 November 2019 (UTC)