User talk:Ajtimes

Re: Berditchev (Hasidic dynasty)
Ajtimes, neither Rabbi Abraham nor Rabbi Seidenfeld belong in a Wikipedia article; the fact that you replaced one with the other made me notice the article, so I removed both.

There are policies of verifiability here on the one hand, and Neutral point of view and promotion on the other. Not every rebbe'le should be mentioned or advertised. Those who are mentioned in reliable, published sources should get mentioned; those who aren't should not. If you cannot find and cite such sources (and I would be very much surprised if you would—my contacts in Monsey have never heard of any Berditshever Rebbe besides for Rabbi Abraham, and he is quite obscure too) then I will remove it again, in accordance with policy.

Another thing I should point out that Wikipedia is not the place to pass a ruling on who is the "right" or "wrong" Berditshev. Wikipedia will always reflect what is published in independent reliable sources—unless there is an obvious error in them.

הסרפד (call me “Hasirpad”) (formerly R——bo) 02:46, 7 January 2013 (UTC)
 * As for your claim that Rabbi Abraham is not a descendant of Rebbe Levi Yitzchak, he claims that he is a descendant of Rebbe Eliezer, son of Rebbe Meir, son of Rebbe Levi Yitzchak, according to letter he wrote published in תולדות חב"ד ברוסיה הצארית, p. 25, quoted in תולדות שמואל מונקעס, p. 62; תולדות חב"ד ברוסיה הצארית was written by quite a serious researcher.
 * הסרפד (call me “Hasirpad”) (formerly R——bo) 02:57, 7 January 2013 (UTC)