User talk:Al89762537/Iceland Plateau

Matthew's Peer Review
Lead Section: You adopt a really good tone out of the gate that makes it easy for any aged reader to understand what you are talking about and I think that is a major strength of your article overall. In terms of the lead section, I like that it was short, concise, and describes exactly what the Icelandic Plateau is without any distractions. The outside article links provide helpful resources while not divulging too much from your focus. Very good work!

Structure: Once again, extremely well laid out. You put some thought into how your article would look and it does a good job mimicking exactly what wikipedia's typical format is. I know exactly what I am going to read before I read it based on the headers and this is the efficiency and structure you aim for. Good work!

Balance of Coverage: You really cover all the bases on what someone would want to know about the Icelandic Plateau. However, you could delve more in detail about what some geological terms mean, like a ridge-hotspot interaction. I know you linked the article, but you can always just give a quick one sentence summary defining what kind of interaction this is and why it's important for a reader to know that information.

Content: Once again *chef's kiss*, you're doing great on this and I really learned a bit about the Icelandic Plateau. My only criticism comes from the last paragraph; you stated that the Icelandic crust has a "few key differences" from oceanic crust, but then do not tell the reader what those are. It would be useful to list this in order for readers to easily differentiate the two crust types. Maybe list the rock types found on the oceanic crust since you list those on the Icelandic crust.

Sources: Good range of sources that are all reflected and cited within your article. You understand your material and where you got that information. Very good work in terms of communicating your information and providing sources that back it up. Mkistner6 (talk) 21:51, 12 November 2021 (UTC)