User talk:Alienspacebaby

B Gata H Kei reviews
I commented out the recently added B Gata H Kei reviews as the websites need to pass WP:A&M/RS. See the list there for some online websites that might have reviews. AngusWOOF (talk) 20:29, 17 January 2013 (UTC)


 * The B Gata H Kei article is a mess as some sources are quite biased, and others like Anime News Network, Tokoyo MX, Funimation, behind the voice actors, hibiki radio station and sharp point press, are not in WP:A&M/RS Quoting a news report, which in turn quotes biased sources is not an acceptable way to impose bias on an article.   If I were to impose the same standards to the biased sources which are not in the WP:A&M/RS as were applied to my edit the article would be cut in half and be unreadable.  So how do we proceed? — Preceding unsigned comment added by Alienspacebaby (talk • contribs) 17:54, 16 March 2015


 * Anime News Network is listed under Situational in the WP:A&M/RS. The staff reviews there are acceptable reliable sources. Tokyo MX, Funimation, Behind the Voice Actors, and Sharp Point are assumed under the Retailers section of WP:A&M/RS as they provide the factual data such as air dates, titles of the program, and voice actor cast announcements. At this point the article's reviews have been scrubbed already, so the article was in good shape to assess to B on the wikiproject, so no action is needed. -AngusWOOF (talk) 18:54, 17 March 2015 (UTC)