User talk:AliveFreeHappy/cnote

RG Cartridges
None of the Real Guns are notable. These are Joe4570's hobby projects. Yes he does a good job with the projects, testing and take quite a bit of care. However, none of these matter in the end. The question to ask is is it noteworthy enough to be written up. And the answer to that is no, at least for the moment, as there is no reliable information outside the promoter/hobbyist/developer. I actually enjoy reading about his projects on his website, interesting? Yes. But not yet ready for a Wiki article. However, If we had a Real Guns article (I think you mentioned this elsewhere) about the website these cartridges may be inserted in there as a byline. So the question become is there enough material discussing the Real Guns site? —Preceding unsigned comment added by DeusImperator (talk • contribs) 05:09, 25 September 2010 (UTC)

Full and Intermediate Power Ammunition
These articles should not stand alone and there is no reason for these articles not to be merged into another article. Please go ahead and merge these articles.
 * Do you think they should be a "new" article or compressed and merged into Cartridge (firearms)? AliveFreeHappy (talk) 02:54, 30 September 2010 (UTC)
 * IMHO they should be merged into the cartridge page. Also if there are full, intermediate there is going to be a low category too. How would one differentiate between these. Is there a stricture or rules governing where one begins and the other ends? How about High power rifle cartridge which we hear about? These are terms which we see but what is their meaning in the end? This article is about terms. I am not to be a post-modern deconstructionalist here but Remington provides three levels of ammo for the Ultra Mag line and they talk about their ammo in similar terms. Such terms will cause confusion to some persons. So it will need to be well defines when this is merged ie that we are not talking about different power loadings of a cartridge but cartridges as a class divided into power levels. Remington has power level ammo for say the 300 RUM they have low power which matches the 30-06 intermediate which matches the 300 win mag and then full power. The meaning depends on the context being used.DeusImperator (talk) 01:07, 1 October 2010 (UTC)
 * I agree. I think if we're going to talk about them, we need to find some reliable source that clearly defines what the categories are. AliveFreeHappy (talk) 15:57, 1 October 2010 (UTC)

Add the Jonson cartridges to the list too
The 7.62 Jonson and the 9mm Jonson probably should be added to the list too.
 * I checked the for information on the cartridges but could not find any information regarding them except for the 7.62 cartridge. But that is at the Jonson lab site. nothing independently collaborates any of the claims regarding the cartridges. Some of the claims are absolutely silly and I think someone may be trying to spike the hooch in this case. Johnson labs might not even need an entry as they are not notable. A 10 page website is for a company is much ado about nothing. The jonsons should go I think.
 * I couldn't find anything either.

.22 Reed Express
Anyone seen anything on the 22 Reed Express outside of reedammo? AliveFreeHappy (talk) 23:40, 3 October 2010 (UTC)

- Nope... DeusImperator (talk) 01:44, 5 October 2010 (UTC)