User talk:Amandari6969

Nina Garcia
Hello knightlago

while i understand that you have found an article that supports the changes you wish to keep on her page they are untrue data... her age is not what that page lists nor is her name the name the page lists ... i will have to contact the owner of the page to have them correct that data but this could take some time due to my unfamiliarity with the company ... i would ask that in the mean time you allow my changes to stick ... perhaps remove the article that has the incorrect data as " bad source " or some equivalent.

thanks so much for your help in this matter ...


 * Unfortunately, that is not how Wikipedia works. All articles must be properly sourced per policy. The sources I have provided are reliable, and they support the information in the article. Thus, the onus is on you to provide different sources that contradict the information in the article that you claim is wrong, instead of merely claiming the information in the sources is wrong. I am therefore going to revert your changes again. Please do not revert my edit again. Please add reliable sources to support the claims you are making, or at least provide something here that supports your assertions. KnightLago (talk) 22:49, 15 September 2010 (UTC)

knightlago,

again we are on the same disagreements ... i have submitted to lifetime tv, imdb , and marie claire to put ( factual ) data into her profiles so that i will have ( 3 ) sources with ( factual ) data ...

i would ask that you heed to this activity and allow the correct data to remain ... this will be validated but sources that actually have access to ( factual ) data and not repeated linked ( incorrect ) data ...

thanks so much for your help in this matter ... —Preceding unsigned comment added by 207.59.111.26 (talk) 19:24, 16 September 2010 (UTC)

We appear to have some disagreements over the above article. Regarding your changes: hello there


 * The name in the infobox is for the commonly used name. That is Nina Garcia, not Conrod.
 * this i can agree with perhaps we can take out the conrod ... but the castellanos is def not true ...


 * The birth name section in the infobox is for the birth name, not the commonly used name. Her birth name is Ninotchka Garcia de Castellanos per the source.
 * this is not her birth name at all ..
 * There is a source that says that this is her birth name. Do you have something that says different?

again we can prehaps remove the conrod ... if we must have it mentinoed in the article later on ...
 * Regarding the Conrod name, the article does not say that Nina has chosen to adopt her husband's name.
 * Go ahead and mention it in the article.

this birthday is wrong as well as her age
 * Regarding her age, the source provided in the article specifically lists her birth date. The source you are linking to does not.

As for your other changes I am fine with them. I am going to revert to the previous version for the reasons I have explained above. I will watch this page if you want to reply to the points I raised above. Thanks! KnightLago (talk) 02:00, 14 September 2010 (UTC)
 * You did not address this point. The source I provided has a specific birth date. Do you have something different?

thans so much for your help here im just trying to keep the data correct and i think that there is some confusion there ...


 * No problem. I have responded to your comments above and reverted the article again. Please make you changes one at a time so we can work on making the article better together and keep the changes we both agree are correct. Please review my comments above. Thanks. KnightLago (talk) 23:44, 14 September 2010 (UTC)