User talk:Andrewsaillant/Squat lobster/Austin.park36 Peer Review

"Broadly, squat lobsters are classified into two superfamilies: Chyrostyloidea and Galatheodidea.[13] Chirostyloidea contain the families Chirostylidae, Eumunididae, and Kiwaidae. Galatheoidea contain the squat lobster families Galatheidae, Munididae, Munidopsidae, and the porcelain crabs in the family Porcellanidae. The systematics of squat lobsters and the classification of deep-sea squat lobsters is an area of active research due to the limited fossil record.[14] Deep-sea squat lobsters, exist at depths greater than 200m, are classified in the Mundidiae and Munidopsidae families of the superfamily Galatheoidea.[13] Deep-sea squat lobsters display greater morphological divergences and lower genetic divergences evolutionary compared to their shallow-water counterparts."

"This relationship, however, was re-examined in the late 21st-century."

"Molecular and morphological data indicate that Galatheoidea is not a monophyletic group; Galatheidae, Porcellanidae, Kiwaidae, and Chirostylidae have independent origins.[16] Galatheoidea is the largest superfamily in the Anomura suborder, which is reflected in the wide range of habitats of species belonging to this "superfamily.""

"Hence, deep-sea squat lobsters were classified in the Chirostyloidea superfamily in 2012 as DNA sequencing indicated that squat lobsters are not a monophyletic group."

"Fossil galatheoid squat lobsters have been found in strata dating back to the Middle Jurassic of Europe.[20] No fossils are currently assigned to the Chirostyloidea."

(The above text was for my use to easily see all of the added content at once)

I think the content added was good in that it was concise and used scientific/technical language. It also added important and much needed information about squat lobster's classification. The text was presented in a very neutral tone and did not seem to have any bias towards anything. The strength of the content added is that it gives more background information about the squat lobster's family and origin. I also noticed that some of the original sentences were altered in a way that paralleled and flowed better with the new material added. One suggestion/aspect that I would double check is if "galatheoid" needs to be capitalized or not (when talking about the fossil squat lobsters). Other than that, I liked how the information was to-the-point and helps readers with the background of squat lobsters.

I edited Grace's portion that she added.