User talk:Bignole/Archive/2017/November

Batman credits
I have just read your comments at Talk:Batman_v_Superman:_Dawn_of_Justice. There are two other related discussions at Talk:The_Dark_Knight_(film) and Talk:Batman_(1989_film). Betty Logan (talk) 21:20, 9 November 2017 (UTC)

Images of the other killers
Since there is one image of Stu Macher and Billy Loomis the original Ghostface killers, could you add in three more images of the other Ghostface killers please?

1. [|Debbie Loomis] and [|Mickey Altieri], the second Ghostface killers.

2. [|Roman Bridger], the third and final Ghostface killer.

3. [|Jill Roberts] and [|Charlie Walker], the fourth and new Ghostface killers. 31.48.57.250 (talk) 21:21, 11 November 2017 (UTC)

Discussion at Talk:Shin Godzilla
You are invited to join the discussion at Talk:Shin Godzilla. Lord Sjones23 (talk - contributions) 04:08, 15 November 2017 (UTC)

Justice League, Mid-Credit scene
I absolutely disagree with you saying it’s a gag part. It’s an iconic comic book moment. Just look it up on google. Flash vs Superman racing. Plus, Its is an important post movie scene and it deserves to be up there in it’s own right. Do restore it. ShotgunMavericks ❯❯❯    🕊✍🏻   19:42, 19 November 2017 (UTC)

User:Bignole, It’s a bit confusing that you replied on my talk page rather than continue here. Although I do get the point you made that the moment isn’t essential to the timeline, What’s the harm in keeping it up there? Afterall, look at the Wikipedia article of Thor Ragnarok, The post credit scene with Jeff Goldblum is mentioned there even though its a gag moment. Why not this one then? ShotgunMavericks ❯❯❯    🕊✍🏻


 * It's not confusing. Most people reply to people that way, unless otherwise stated (i.e., people usually leave a message on their talk page saying they will always respond at the location of the original message). I don't, but if it's easier for you I can. With regard to Thor, I don't edit that page. I probably would clean it up, but at the same time I imagine that the Marvel fanboys that run that page (no disrespect intended) love post-credit scenes so much that they would fight to keep an otherwise non-essential moment. Had there been running dialogue about the two of them and who was fastest (I don't count a throwaway line from Superman calling Flash "slow-poke"), then maybe one could argue that they were finally trying to settle the bet. But that never happened thorughout the film.


 * Technically, WP:MOSFILM discusses not to include "minutiae like dialogue, scene-by-scene breakdowns, individual jokes, and technical detail." The race, although fun and I loved it, is just an individual joke for comic book fans. Nothing more. I would imagine this to be true for Thor, though I haven't seen that one yet and cannot comment. But, I would argue that the one listed at Guardians should be removed, because it's a sight gag for Howard the Duck and Cosmo, nothing more and without context it confuses a reader as to why this is important.

Wonder Woman
Hi, I'd warn you about 3RR, but I don't want to template regulars. I just wanted to caution about you regarding reverting further. I've reported the user to AN3 after they ignored my 3RR warning. Callmemirela  🍁 talk 21:42, 27 November 2017 (UTC)