User talk:Bookpublishersreviewer

Inability to reach consensus
This needs to be a neutral biography of person, not a place to editorialize. To wit -

- once a book is on a bestseller list it is, stunner, a bestseller. it doesn't matter if 100,000 gnomes bought the book. it is still a bestseller. besides it was also on the USA Today bestseller list for some period of time and on the Los Angeles Times and blah blah blah - if someone wants to turn this into a place to editorialize about the full response to someone's book this is not that place - someone should start a wiki page on tempting faith and then let everyone have at it. otherwise this will turn into an endless discussion with all of the pros pitted against all of the cons and let's face it, this just isn't that important. - it is clear that a person who participated in a few bass tournaments isn't first a pro bass fisherman and then a writer and then an author. include bass fishing if you will but contextualize it.

Kuo
Pleae use discussion and wait for replies, he is not notable as a bass fisherman. otherwise we should change the title to Kou (bass fisherman). Off2riorob (talk) 17:56, 16 March 2010 (UTC)