User talk:Bpg23

The Panic Channel
Please stop vandalising The Panic Channel page. The band is NOT emo. They are an alternative rock band. Thank you. Enfestid 22:07, 1 September 2006 (UTC)
 * Please read the supergroup page for the Wikipedian definition of supergroup. It is not your definition that matters, it is that of Wikipedia that matters. Please read the second paragraph of the article (supergroup) for further clarification. This has already been addressed in the history of The Panic Channel article. Please read it.


 * Secondly, please do not try to psychoanalyze me and tell me what I may or may not regard to be a negative term. I have absolutely no problem with emo bands, but the band is absolutely and 100% not emo. Can you tell me in any way, shape, or form that The Panic Channel fits the definition of emo as defined by the Wikipedia article on it? The band doesn't even remotely resemble the definition there. It does, however, fit the definitions as listed on the page.


 * Your examples of how the band is emo are not only inaccurate, but highly questionable. The name makes them emo? Since when did the name of a band have anything to do with the music itself? It never did. And your reasoning of why they are emo because of the song "Why Cry" doesn't even answer the question of why they are emo. Because they tried to write a mainstream song and failed? That makes them emo how exactly again?


 * The emo genre does exist. But The Panic Channel is not emo. Please do not tell me why I connotate emo as a negative term when it is clearly you judging from your statement on why the band is emo: "The first single, why cry, is further evidence that they are Emo, because the depth of the music is completely lacking and they have clearly just tried to write a radio friendly single. They failed." Clearly you are not a fan of "Why Cry" (and possibly the band). That doesn't make them emo, though.


 * Please do not continue to vandalize the page. Thank you.
 * Enfestid 03:43, 2 September 2006 (UTC)
 * You state "The name makes them emo? Since when did the name of a band have anything to do with the music itself? It never did." Why don't you read the sentence on the panic channel page that reads "The band's name refers to a state of panic induced by the world media as well as "channeling the energy inside and outside the room when we create these songs ... we like to think of creating music as a way to channel the panic into something tangible," as stated by Navarro"
 * Again: how does this classify them as emo? Is there anything you're even trying to get at here? It's their definition of what creating music is. I fail to see anything that even relates to what we're discussing here.
 * Enfestid 21:23, 2 September 2006 (UTC)