User talk:Brildanz1

Please see the talk page this contributes little to the article and you do not have the consensus of the other Editors, I don't like edit wars and this is beginning to look like one.Tirronan (talk)

I do not see any consensus in the talk page - nor do I see any meaningful argument there, from you or anyone else, in favor of classifying this battle as a French victory. Given the disastrous state of the French army after the battle -- its effective collapse, Napoleon leaving the remnants of the army, etc. -- the thesis about a French victory is highly questionable. Nonetheless, with some stretch of imagination the battle could be considered a strategic victory for Napoleon, for reasons I indicated earlier. I don't like edit-warring either and will not arm-wrestle with anyone over what stands in this little box. If you want to guard the page vigilantly, protecting your interpretation of the battle's outcome, then enjoy it. If, on the other hand, you want a meaningful discussion, I am willing to listen to arguments, provided those are available.Brildanz1 (talk) 04:54, 1 September 2011 (UTC)