User talk:Btmiller

Ahmed Omar Abu Ali
I just added to the article on Ahmed Omar Abu Ali based on a recent WaPo article.

The article was strangely spartan -- just one or two sentences.

I looked at its history, trying to figure out why it had an NPOV tag.

What I saw was that various people had made about a dozen non-controversial edits, and then a contributor from an anonymous IP number, added a large, visually ugly, POV, contribution.  That IP number was only used once, for that single edit.

You were the next contributor. You added the NPOV tag. Personally I just would have reverted to the previous version.

I don't think anything that was written before the vandal merited an NPOV tag. I don't think the article merits an NPOV tag now. If you agree how about removing the tag? -- Geo Swan 16:01, 27 September 2005 (UTC)


 * Done -- I have removed the NPOV tag Btmiller 10:21, 8 October 2005 (UTC)