User talk:Camidfit

Dear Camidfit (whoever you are),

You have removed my edits about the Digital Twin with the following comment: "Removed material that replaced existing correct material. The material that replaced existing material was irrelevant/erroneous."

To my knowledge, I did not replace any existing material.

What in my material was erroneous in your opinion? All the new material is supported by numerous references in well-known high-impact journals - but it is apparently forbidden to put in citations to articles where I am myself one of the authors. Ok, I do understand the conflict-of-interest aspect but this seems to go beyond that.

On what grounds do you judge our work to be irrelevant? The material that I had added builds on work by highly renowned professors in Belgium, Germany and the UK. On the Wikipedia page on Internet of Things, even references to the first work on IoT by MIT has been removed. There are of course many articles by others in the research community also. However, do keep in mind that when a concept is new, there tends to be less articles than on something well-established. Between 2002 and 2010 I used to be quite lonely when speaking about Internet of Things at conferences.

With all respect for Dr. Michael Grieves (whose name I discovered only a few days ago), he does not have a great number of publications (https://scholar.google.fi/citations?user=0gGMvgkAAAAJ&hl=en&oi=ao) and they have a very low number of citations until 2018. It seems to me like the first article with Digital Twin in the title is from 2014.

So who are you, the Gods of Wikipedia, who decide on what is relevant and what is not? What are your criteria? "I have not heard about those guys so they must be irrelevant"? MrOllie (whoever that is) removed my contributions based on the argument of conflict-of-interest, so apparently you at least know who I am. But that's hardly a reason for removing all my edits in Wikipedia.

Who in Wikipedia has the authority to arbitrate on this kind of things anyways?

Sincerely, Framling (talk) 11:59, 11 September 2019 (UTC)