User talk:Cesyen

Welcome

 * }

Vandalism
Hi, I think that you should be a little bit less quick with using the word "vandalism". If I were in the habit of vandalizing WP articles, I would never have survived this long and been able to make over 75,000 edits here, without getting blocked. For a definition of vandalism, see WP:VANDALISM. The redirect I made is covered by WP:BOLD. I redirected it to the main article on the Framework programmes, because that is what we do with almost all of those articles. They generally all suffer from the same problems (see the notes here) and most of them have been deleted after a deletion discussion. The problem is that there are almost never any independent reliable sources about these projects, meaning that they fail our notability guidelines (please note that this is not a judgement about the quality of these projects, only whether it has generated enough interest outside of its own participants). This seems also the case for IDPbyNMR: all references are from before or around the time the project was started and are about the subject of the project, rather than the project itself. Not too surprising, considering that the project only started in 2010 (see WP:TOOSOON). So, you see, I had good reasons to redirect this article and even though you obviously disagree with them, you should at first assume good faith before accusing someone of vandalism.

I will now restore the redirect. If, after reading the above, you still feel that I am wrong, feel free to restore the article. In that case, we'll solicit more commentary from the community by starting an AFD (deletion discussion). Thanks. --Guillaume2303 (talk) 10:23, 14 April 2012 (UTC)
 * PS: I just had a look at the list of fellows on this project website and it would appear to me that you may perhaps want to read this page, too. --Guillaume2303 (talk) 10:36, 14 April 2012 (UTC)