User talk:Charbonnet

Sally Miller - Not sure why WillC undid my contribution to add the book by Carol Wilson: The Two Lives of Sally Miller, but I am new to editing and would love to know if there was something I posted that was not correctly done, since the book itself is an important contribution to a study of the topic.
 * As far as I can tell, WillC has no reason to have removed your contribution. His latest edit summary "prove this "book" exists" is absurd since quickly googling the title immediately pops up its amazon.com page. Just go ahead and re-add your contribution, and if WillC reverts you again you can try leaving a comment on the article's discussion page. RobHar (talk) 23:45, 29 May 2010 (UTC)

Thank you. I will.

The ISBN for the book is 978-0-8135-4058-0 (Paperback) My comment when I redid the page was "Google it.  It's on Amazon. I recently read it.  Best book on the topic." Yes, "Best" is my opinion. John Bailey's book is very good. However, as Professor Wilson says in her book, and I agree, that although Baily's account is extensively researched it is "semi-novelized and speculates." That makes it a great read, but Professor Wilson's book is simply a scholarly account, which I appreciate. The Sally Miller article needs editing.