User talk:Cnilep/Archive/02 November 2013

Beethoven's liver
I am sorry to take so long to reply, but I have deliberately stayed away from the discussion to let others have their say. I see that Beethoven's liver stays but Grin Report has gone. I have not read the AfD since deliberately I have stayed off Wikipedia while it was discussed, it is right for others to have their say. That article was around for five years and was just simply wrong, so you are right that I made a point, but I made it with notable and reliable sources (I overdid it with those but on purpose, in that sense it is POINTy. The point was simply RS and N and I don't think on the whole it is bad to make those points some times.)

I am deliberately replying to you first, one other editor before you, but before I read the AfD and get bogged down in it. I can only assure you of my good faith. In real life I have used this article in the sense of "it must be true, it is on Wikipedia". Madden states that it is covered with pea-sized nodules and twice its normal size. I think I may have slipped since I meant to write pathologist but I see it says psychiatrist. I *thought* I sais pathologist, which is what Madden was. But again, didn't dare to correct.

I'll take off the PROD. It can now stand on its WP:OWNFEET.

S.
 * Thank you for your reply. Happy editing. Cnilep (talk) 00:00, 2 November 2013 (UTC)