User talk:CooterNeaera

George Herbert
Hi, I've just reversed your edit at George Herbert because of the way your synopsis is worded, which smells of WP:POV. If it's necessary to say that much, then the points should first be advanced on the Talk page with evidence. The most telling argument against is that in 1596 Donne was still a Catholic recusant, so far as I know. On the other hand, Magdalen Herbert (George's mother) was a recipient of a verse letter from Donne, as was George's elder brother Edward (Lord Herbert of Cherbury), the latter of whom remained Donne's lifelong friend. The claim made of Donne's special relationship is therefore not so incredible as you believe. It could be that the editor who originally added that claim has overstated the source in which he found it; it's now up to you, as a responsible editor, to look for such a source and modify the wording once you've found it. Sweetpool50 (talk) 16:52, 5 January 2021 (UTC)