User talk:Cunfu2012

Hi Wctaiwan:

I am not sure if this is a right way to response to your comment on my editing or not. Both posts were Open Letters to Nature, and they were sent to Nature by the writers in their real names. Nature has acknowledged the reception to at least one of them. If this is not considered reliable source, it will be very difficult to find more reliable ones, since China is not a free press country.

Your edit to Fang Zhouzi
Hi, and welcome to the English Wikipedia. I see that you've added examples of objections to Fang winning the John Maddox Prize, but they're both forum posts. Could you please find better sources? Ideally, it's best if you can find a source reporting on the objections, but failing that, criticism published in major publications would probably be fine as well.

In general, forum and blog posts are not considered reliable. Furthermore, there is no way for a non-Chinese speaking reader to know, based on the sources, if the consensus in the Chinese community condemns Fang being awarded the prize, or if it's just a vocal minority or a mixed reaction.

Lastly, a minor point--an edit which actually changes content or references is generally not considered minor edit, so please don't mark such an edit as minor in the future. Thanks. wctaiwan (talk) 10:31, 20 November 2012 (UTC)