User talk:Dilatlahrat

Hi there,

Obviously, it is not the only op-ed that he wrote so by all means, please do add whatever you think is relevant. I do think that the issue of torture in Morocco is important and I would like to stress this particular angle. You know as well as me that the material in question is not defamatory. Benchemsi did condone the use of torture - it may have been a bad article (he may or may not agree with it today) but he DID write it - and it's not really up to you to censor it on Wikipedia.

Best,

GR.

Calumny
I disagree. Benchemsi, who received international awards for advocating democracy and human rights (http://www.pointinfo.org/Ahmed-Reda-Benchemsi-laureat-du-Prix-Samir-Kassir_a1050.html, http://www.edubourse.com/finance/actualites.php?actu=18354), never condoned the usage of torture. In the referenced editorial, he wrote that he would never support the methods of Laanigri (the then Moroccan police chief, widely known as the top responsible for torture), but that in 20 years, there may be a debate between the supporters of the regime and its opponents, on whether torture would have prevented (or not) the expansion of terrorism. I agree that this was neither the best, nor the most inspired of his editorials. Yet it featured a debate, not the writer's opinion. Benchemsi's opinion on torture (broadly: not only is it condemnable, but it is ridiculously inefficient to stop terrorism) is here: http://www.telquel-online.com/113/edito_113.shtml. Under Benchemsi's direction, TelQuel magazine published many cover stories on human rights organizations' reports revealing/condemning the use of torture in Moroccan secret prisons (like this one: http://www.telquel-online.com/113/index_113.shtml). More recently, Benchemsi exposed cases of Moroccan citizens tortured to death in Police stations (here: http://www.telquel-online.com/424/edito_424.shtml) and deplored the authorities' silence on this tragedy. Benchemsi's defunct Arabic magazine Nichane (http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/libertycentral/2010/oct/08/morocco-press-freedom) named the torturers and asked for their trial--which no other Moroccan newspaper did. I am not Benchemsi, and I have neither time nor willingness to write his proper, comprehensive biography. But I hate injustice. Benchemsi was forced into exile by Morocco's authorities because of his courageous journalistic support of democracy. Trashing him (or anybody) with slander is despicable. Best, Dilatlahrat (talk) 17:08, 29 April 2011 (UTC)