User talk:Dod Phir ext

Violations of WP:BLP at List of Egyptian Armenians
Please stop adding unreferenced or poorly referenced biographical content, especially if controversial, to articles or any other Wikipedia page, as you did at List of Egyptian Armenians. Content of this nature could be regarded as defamatory and is in violation of Wikipedia policy. If you continue, you may be blocked from editing Wikipedia. Read WP:BLP carefully. Your edit is in violation of the guidelines.

Genealogy only source is the people living in the vicinity of other people. He is of Armenian or Arab origin, yet all local sources say he is of Armenian origin as the end of this conversation in this site concluded after some false claims from an Arab tribe that he is of Arab origin, Sisi family of Menoufiyya are well known locally that they're from Armenian origin https://www.alnssabon.com/t41122.html. Such things can't be measured by external foreign references because it's passed down by generations and won't be violating the guidelines and you must provide a source that Sisi is of Ancient Egyptian origin (which you won't find) because the family name technically referring that he is from Armenia. Furthermore, you and the other ip address keep editing all pages corrupting even original edits. Not to mention that you're from Beni Swif where many of the families came from Arab migration by local people citations. If you keep doing that, I will report both of you for targeted and organized vandalism of multiple wikipedia pages denying Armenian contributions and heritage in Egypt. Finally, I will get more reliable undeniable historical book sources. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Dod Phir ext (talk • contribs) 11:33, 9 November 2021 (UTC)


 * I have urged you several times to carefully read WP:BLP. Strictly high-quality scholarly sources are necessary for claims about living persons. The links you are providing are: one to an Arabic forum, and the other is an iffy local newspaper, which is not a scholarly source, and does not constitute a source here. This is discussed clearly in the guidelines. Good faith was assumed, but competency is required. You are in total disregard of the Wikipedia BLPs guidelines here. Telling me that you have tracked my location, whether or not it is accurate, is a form of intimidation, and doesn't pertain to the article. Shouting vandalism at me will not fool the Administrators. There is no "both of us", so far I have edit this article from the IP "197.38.8.41" and the current IP "197.38.97.37". Do not shout "organized vandalism" obliviously, I haven't edited any other articles about Armenians. Again, you will not fool the Administrators. I have fairly warned you. You are saying that you are going to get an "undeniable" source; Wikipedia doesn't care what you think "undeniable" means, your source either conforms with the guidelines regarding BLPs or it doesn't. Also, try to be civil in your edit summaries and on the talk pages. 197.38.97.37 (talk) 11:56, 9 November 2021 (UTC)

Final warning regarding the Violations of WP:BLP at List of Egyptian Armenians
You may be blocked from editing without further warning the next time you violate Wikipedia's biographies of living persons policy by inserting unsourced or poorly sourced defamatory or otherwise controversial content into an article or any other Wikipedia page, as you did at List of Egyptian Armenians.

First I didn't intimidate you, you participate with your IP, it's no brainer that I would search up IP location to see what nationality is discussing with me, the second IP address is 156.193.84.115, it needn't be the same person as you, but he edits in the same pages as you edit, and he deletes info. from original articles, removing "Egyptian Armenian" father to just "Egyptian" father in Anoushka (Egyptian singer) page and again another IP address 156.193.159.193 changing "This is a list of notable Egyptian Armenians who have contributed to modern Egypt." to "Armenians born and raised in Egypt" while that's incorrect, all those edits happened in close timelines indicating act of targeted vandalism of Egyptian Armenian pages. Finally, You can proceed with whatever warnings and procedures you like, there is no violation in the info. I provided and there were no intimidation, all I told is that Beni Swuef is known for many Arab migrations historically and you could be one of them with high percentage actually, and that Egypt is well known to have multi ethnic societies even in ancient Egypt (and I can provide many historical and current academical articles, books, citations confirming that. You are the one with seemingly radical national agenda. Yet, I removed Sisi from the articles just because according to the second source I looked at, there were a confusion whether he is of Arab tribe or of Armenian origin, once I can confirm with certainty and more reliable sources whether he is of Arab or Armenian origin, I would add him again to the page of his Arab tribe or Armenian Egyptian. You should learn how genealogy is passed down in Egypt, Arabia and Middle east, articles or sources in English is irrelevant and won't be found when talking about genealogy of any person of the Arab world, because sources would be in Arabic unless translated (anyone now can google translate any online page I provided), again there is no violation or intimidation in my talk, I like you to proceed with your warnings. If you don't want anyone to know your IP address, just create account. Once you provide your ip address in edits, you publically giving permission to anyone who see them to look them up if he wants, it's your problem, not mine. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Dod Phir ext (talk • contribs) 16:09, 9 November 2021 (UTC)


 * First, comment on content, not on the contributor; also, take note of WP:UNCIVIL; refrain from making claims about other editors' personal lives. Second, WP:BLP is strict enough that it applies on talk pages as well. Third, everything you are saying doesn't concern me, and is not of any relevance to the guidelines that must be applied to the article. Fourth, this is not about what language your links are in (again, read the guidelines). Fifth, my sole focus is the strict Wikipedia guidelines regarding biographies of living persons, everything else you are saying is nothing more than utter hogwash and has zero of my attention. I will indeed pursue this if you violate the guidelines again, whether you would "like me to proceed" or not; you seems to have total disregard for the guidelines. The warnings you have received are not sent to you for fun. You don't seem to have something of substance to say here, other than nonsensical claims and ad hominems, so this will most likely be my last response to you; I have already given you the usual warnings, as is recommended, and action will be taken if violation is repeated, whether it is at List of Egyptian Armenians or any other page, as per the guidelines. 197.38.97.37 (talk) 18:00, 9 November 2021 (UTC)