User talk:Emergingsolutions

This message is for Anu Malik and Alisha Chinai - and the organizers of Indian Idol.

Anu Malik: While I have started liking the rather frank comments and understand the underlying reasons for sometimes harsh behavior, which I guess is his style not meant as such to be really harsh and is directed to be constructive. But please Anu, do not over do as the janta will not appreciate your sentiments.

Alisha: Your judgmental qualities have been rather below the level that is required if you’re one among the likes of Udit Narayan and Javed Akhtar. What to talk of Anu Malik, he is a music director and I also feel that he has the ears to judge the qualitative aspects of any voice and singing. And, I think he is sincere to the job. Except that he has too much of the “meh” (me) in him, which is not good. We all know he is good but he does not stand near the names like Laxmikant Pyarelal, R.D. Burman and the rather new duo, Nadeem Sharawan. I love their compositions.

What a performance Amit is giving now!! It would be very sad if Junta votes him out, considering that he is very good, everyone thinking that the whole India is going to vote for him – and they do not vote for him. Something I must not forget to mention – you have not been fair to Parleen – instead the young Puja should have gone out. Too many comments in support of females have ended the carrier of Parleen. Please don’t influence junta comments and votes. Whether a male or female – only the better should survive.

I am a lover of good Indian music and have been listening and privately singing now for over 45 years starting very young in life. My ears are also very well tuned.

I would love to hear from one of your female singers (may be deepali) the song from Laxmi-Pyare, Suno Sajna Papihe ne Kaha sub se pukar ke, sumbhal jao chaman walo kea aye din bahar ke. This will show how good the female singer is.

Keep it up; you’re all doing a good job. The programme is very interesting.

Abdul Aleem Islamabad – Pakistan +92-321-8549922