User talk:Epriscilla/sandbox

Peer review
Lead:

Your lead section is clear and to the point. The definition is clearly stated. However, the lead does not summarize the total content of the article. Also, it was unclear to me if the rest of the article is based only on cichlid fishes as mentioned in the lead, or on other species as well.

Structure/ body:

- The overall structure of the article needs to be edited to improve the organization of the article as well as the content of each section. There are numerous sentences that are confusing and do not clearly relate to or support the topic.

- The section “Mouth brooding” seems to be insignificant to the topic of this article, since it is not stated that this behaviour leads to the consumption young.

- I am confused in the headings of the article, in that it is unclear if “a)Stealing from mouth brooding phase” and “b)Stealing from guarding phase” are separate headings or included under behaviour. I would suggest including them under behaviour since they would not be proper headings on their own.

- The “Behaviour” section should be rearranged. It is disorganized in that information in the first paragraph belongs in the two headings below.

- Much of the information in the “b)Stealing from guarding phase” section does not relate directly to the eating of young, therefore it is unnecessary to include without tying it directly to the topic.

- The article is primarily about fish, it is unclear if the behaviours and morphologies discussed are about cichlid fishes or other species. This should be clarified. Specific examples of species should be provided if the behaviours and morphologies discussed are about different fish species.

- This article is not well balanced. The lead section mentions that animals other than fish also exhibit paedophagy but only fish are discussed. To provide a more balanced description of paedophagy, this behaviour should be described in the context of different animals. A new section should be included to mention paedophagy in other animals.

- The article uses a neutral point of view for the most part, but it could be improved by using more formal language. The section “Trade-offs” is questionable in its neutrality and factuality. This section would be better worded using only facts and avoiding terms like “…is not always an easy task…” and “…their persistence is rewarded…” which imply an opinion. Sources:

- Many sentences are not cited. All facts stated throughout the article must be cited with a reliable source. - The references provided are not written correctly. They are missing authors and proper links. - I am not able to tell if last two sources listed are reliable sources.

Spelling/ grammar:

- There are many sentences that need to be reworded and restructured. - Many sentences are missing proper punctuation. Most sentences are missing periods and many sentences need commas. - There are mistakes in spelling and grammar, the following are a few examples that need to be edited:

Location section, spelling mistake: “…but in regards to paedophages it is know to contains 8 species”

Location section, grammar mistake: “…but in pardophages only contains several species…”

Mouth Brooding section, punctuation mistake: “Upon hatching development occurs…” consider adding a comma between hatching and development.

Behaviour section, punctuation mistake: “When this species exhibits paedophagy it has been observed circling and waiting outside the bower, which is the spawning location for many cichlid fishes, until the eggs have been laid before attacking the mouth brooder” consider splitting into 2 sentences, as it is a little too wordy. Perhaps “When this species exhibits paedophagy, it has been observed circling and waiting outside the bower, which is the spawning location for many cichlid fishes. It waits until the eggs have been laid before attacking the mouth brooder.”

b)Stealing from guarding phase section, punctuation mistake: “The parent will do its best to chase away the predator to protect the offspring, on the other hand, this abrupt movement from the parent distresses the offspring who then all aggregate together until their mother successfully comes back where they continue with guarding behaviour” This sentence is also wordy and would be better split into to sentences.

Overall this article should be carefully reviewed and edited to ensure it follows the wikipedia guidelines. AshlynGray (talk) 00:31, 18 March 2018 (UTC)