User talk:Erik Zachte/EasyTimeline

Source:. , please remove this line to acknowledge. 84.127.80.114 (talk) 23:42, 17 September 2014 (UTC)

First time line made with EasyTimeline
This is the oldest diagram prepared with EasyTimeline. I built it offline and uploaded it from my PC. This is before EasyTimeline became a Mediawiki extension.

Graphic not showing
I have succesfully installed EasyTimeline (no errors) but can't see the graph in my wiki. I can't find any support information or any means to diagnose my problem. Do you have any suggestion? User:Mcasatti

I am having this problem too... It appears to be set up correctly, I have the php and pl file in /extensions/EasyTimeline and I have the correct paths in the LocalSettings.php file. The page source shows that it is looking for the image file and map, but they are not being created in the images/timeline directory. I have verified that the permissions on the images/timeline directory are correct but to no avail.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.--Shirizaan (talk) 15:46, 5 February 2008 (UTC)

Hi Eric, I have the same problem. I installed EasyTimeline, created all directories, checked the permissions, but nothing happends. I only get the error message "Timeline error: Executable not found.". When I try to run the script on the console I got the error, that the file, which is defined in $fname, is not created. When I create the file, put the information of the website in and run the script on the console, all works fine and the PNG-file will be created. Is it possible, that an open_basedir restriction or the safe_mode takes effect? Thanks for all Tipps. -- User:Noffycws, 11. September 2008 —Preceding undated comment was added at 20:11, 11 September 2008 (UTC).

Hello Erik, Thank you for writing EasyTimeline. I have it installed on my MediaWiki site and it is working to the point of generating the output image (I can see it in the images/timeline directory and it is correct). However those images are not visible on the page. I am sure the file permissions are right. Do you have any suggestions? Thanks, Andrew Gronosky 24 January 2014  — Preceding unsigned comment added by 72.74.23.208 (talk) 03:11, 25 January 2014 (UTC)

ET
Jeluf's ET implementation is looking good already. He suggested checking in the code into CVS. Would it be possible for you to also maintain the code over our CVS server? That would make collaboration a lot easier. There are several graphical CVS clients for Windows such as WinCVS. Of course you don't have write access to the CVS server yet, for that I would need your SourceForge username.--Eloquence* 20:25, Apr 25, 2004 (UTC)

Pacific War
Hi Erik, the only real contribution of Nazi Germany in the Pacific Theatre was naval; U-Boats and raiders/auxiliary cruisers, e.g. the Kormoran, which sank & was sunk by HMAS Sydney off Western Australia in November 1941 were operating in the Indian Ocean from an early stage of WW2 and some Nazi naval forces later used ports in Malaya, Singapore and the Dutch East Indies (e.g. U-862). I intend to include a little on this in the Pacific War article at some time soon. Regards,Grant65 (Talk) 04:32, Apr 26, 2004 (UTC)

EasyTimeline documentation
I was rather expecting some nice documentation to be prepared which would be resident within Wikipedia, probably on Meta-Wiki within the Manual of Style. I just don't feel comfortable with the documentation for a Wikipedia feature residing on an external site: it doesn't feel consistent. Call me obsessive or anal-retentive if you like (nothing new, I can assure you :-) but in this kind of situation I like to have all my eggs in the same basket. I have no idea of the status of your website, but if it should move or even (fates forfend) disappear we would be left bereft. Your idea about a LotR timeline is a good one, and I have some other possible ideas (some alas involving non-standard calenders such as I mentioned the other day, so they'll have to wait): I'll have to see if I can squeeze enough contiguous time out of RL Work to put something together. Ciao. --Phil | Talk 08:32, May 17, 2004 (UTC)
 * I was thinking of having a go at using something like html2wikipedia, or maybe being bloody-minded and just hacking it together myself. Basically I wanted your OK to use your original text, since you went to all that trouble putting it together. --Phil | Talk 11:44, May 17, 2004 (UTC)

EasyTimeline version identifier
It might be a good idea to support a syntax like

By default, the latest version would be assumed. This would make it possible to support multiple versions of the program simultaneously, so that old timelines would not have to be rewritten. What do you think?--Eloquence* 05:06, Jun 2, 2004 (UTC)


 * I am not quite sure a version id would work well: no-one will add the id until needed; once they notice someone has fallen over with the new version, they would have to establish which version worked well, which may be three versions back. Using the id rightaway makes sure no bugs will be fixed automatically with any edit/save. I think I have to do my utmost to keep the syntax downward compatible. When behaviour is modified I will have to add a functional tag that request this new behaviour. Erik Zachte 20:12, 2 Jun 2004 (UTC)

EasyTimeline
Yeah, I was just playing about. I found it quite easy, I suppose, but then I'm probably not a typical Wikipedian in terms of technical ability, and certianly not lowest-common-denominator level. Other than the initial looking at things and fiddling, it seemed fine, though using variables makes for more easily tunable pictures, it also makes for less readable syntax, IMO. Also, sometimes previewing the timeline would result in no picture, and I'd have to preview it again, sometimes needing to change something (a bug in the rendering code resulting in a non-standard image file?). But no, it was quite do-able.

Thanks for the hard work you've put in to give me the opportunity to play with timelines!

James F. (talk) 13:47, 15 Jun 2004 (UTC)


 * There seems to now be a bug in the EasyTimeline code - if I edit my timeline test (say, change the wording), the preview shows a rather broken layout (but the text does indeed change); see, for example this test...
 * James F. (talk) 01:10, 3 Jul 2004 (UTC)

EasyTimeline colon bug
Check out Template:Timeline CGI in movies. The bug is self-explanatory - colons in links confuse the timeline script that thinks they are defining some parametres. Paranoid 23:09, 23 Jun 2004 (UTC)
 * Fixed. Erik Zachte 23:07, 26 Jun 2004 (UTC)

Can't get bars in the right order
Hello, I'm es:User:Comae, from the Spanish Wikipedia. I've been translating meta's EasyTimeline guide, and attempting to do some timelines for our Wikipedia. But I can't get it right with es:Template:Línea de tiempos de reinos de España. Bar titles are in the right order, but bars are inverted. Could you please take a peek at my code? Thank you very much. --es:User:Comae 23:41, 25 Jun 2004 (UTC)
 * Fixed. Erik Zachte 23:07, 26 Jun 2004 (UTC)
 * Thank you, Erik!! --es:User:Comae 00:10, 27 Jun 2004 (UTC)

Soviet bug
I had to revert to a pre-easy timeline version of List of leaders of the Soviet Union since the version with easy timeline obliterated the table that was supposed to appear on the right side of the page. If you are able to fix it could you also modify the timeline to include Malenkov? Thanks. AndyL 11:36, 27 Jun 2004 (UTC)

I'm using IE Explorer 5.1 for the Macintosh. What happens is that the table that's supposed to appear to the right of the graph appears no where on the page at all while the footnotes appear after a lot of white space. The graph appears on the left side of the page. AndyL 17:23, 27 Jun 2004 (UTC)

Just in case you're looking at my reverted version of the page try this link AndyL 17:25, 27 Jun 2004 (UTC)

A suggestion
I'm Comae again. At the Spanish Wikipedia we have been talking about genealogical trees. It would be very useful for Mithology, kings, Tolkien, and others. The trouble is that we can´t find an usable way to do it, getting links in the tree. I've used HTML lists, but they don't make the cut. Tables are difficult to edit and correct. I was trying to do it with timelines, which may come in handy, but it's not as intuitive for non-tech people to edit later. Now, I see you are already busy with all the trouble with timelines, but I thought you may use a suggestion for future versions, or find an alternative. Thank you for the patience. (I hope you can understand this strange babbling I call "my English") --es:User:Comae 01:03, 29 Jun 2004 (UTC)


 * Don't worry, I feared it. We are Wikipedists, not Superman. Thank you anyway. Also, I'm glad you have your priorities right ;D --es:User:Comae

Tour de France vs Soviet leaders
Tour de France works for me. AndyL 07:08, 29 Jun 2004 (UTC)

Parenthesis "" don't work in links
Can´t get working links in timelines with parenthesis. For example, I can't link Plutón (planeta) in a timeline. Could you fix it? Thank you very much. --es:User:Comae 18:32, 5 Jul 2004 (UTC)


 * Comae, yes it is a bug and I will fix it, but it will take some weeks before a new version is online. In the meantime you can code it as follows (click edit page for code)

Timeline on fr:
Bonjour, I hope it's the right place to submit such observation : copied Template:Timeline_Tour_de_France_Winners into wikipédia in french but the result is a blank page. Someone told me it's utf-8 related problem. Thank you for all the features you did ! Greudin


 * Greuding, there are two issues here. Yes EasyTimeline does not handle UTF-8 code yet. I can't tell you when it will, as this is a significant adaptation, it involves custom font support for one thing. I will surely do this, I'm only very busy on another project right now. However you should still see something, an image with some garbled text, or when you input contains errors, an error box. Both do not happen on several Wikipedias, only old images are still shown, so someone made a change which disabled EasyTimeline, I tried wikitech yesterday but got no response, I'll try again. Cheers, Erik

Template:Timeline Tour de France Winners
No one seems to be able to update this so that it works. Any idea what we are doing wrong? Rmhermen 20:01, Jul 25, 2004 (UTC)


 * Somehow somebody messed up, so EasyTimeline is not invoked on any Wikipedia since a few days. I tried to reach a developer with server access through wikitech two times, but too much is going on there apparantly, will try now on IRC. Erik Zachte 22:37, 25 Jul 2004 (UTC)


 * Update: EasyTimeline disappeared form the server some days ago. I has been reinstalled but is not yet active. Further research needed. Erik Zachte 03:32, 27 Jul 2004 (UTC)


 * Any news on when EasyTimeline will be back? I wanted to update the geologic timeline with corrected information (as seen on Geologic Timeline Geologic timescale), but I see that EasyTimeline is still not working (at least not for me :) Gwimpey 03:56, Aug 3, 2004 (UTC)


 * I haven't forgotten it. Several people looked at it. Script was missing from the server. Also access rights were wrong, script could not run. Then Apaches were out of sync on this module. So three steps forward but there is still a missing piece. Now that I have server access I can do some more digging, but I'll have to be slow and careful as I don't know Wikimedia internals well enough yet. Erik Zachte 04:05, 3 Aug 2004 (UTC)

EasyTimeline fixed
Congratulations! It looks great now. It's a pity our beloved 'eñe' it's still unsupported :( Maybe the spanish characters test table in es:Wikipedia:Líneas_de_tiempo could be helpful... Anyway, we can go back to work again! Cheers!--es:User:Comae

ATaleOfTwoCases
Thanks for the EasyTimeline-generated timelines! I became aware of them via Tour de France. But I have a gripe as well, possibly not directed at you but having to do with Category:Graphical Timelines: too bad this and the other similar timeline categories aren't titled like Graphical timeline etc (lowercase t in "timeline")... Since categories can't be Moved like articles (at least not by mortal wikipedians -- don't know about sysops or wikipedia developers) I guess there'd be quite a lot of work fixing this. The cat titles where "timeline" is the first word is OK, of course, likewise the templates. --Wernher 21:20, 10 Aug 2004 (UTC)


 * I plead guilty. I did come up with that category name. By the way I just realize this page starts with "Editing User talk:... Are there clear rules about this? I know the rules for normal sentences, with subject, verb, etc, but I'm not sure in other situations. For instance it is quite customary to capitalize all major words in a book title. Erik Zachte 02:50, 11 Aug 2004 (UTC)

UTF-8 support in Easytimeline
Thanks for your fine work on the Easytimeline module. There's a minor glitch however - UTF-8. I urge you to add UTF-8 support to Easytimeline now that more and more Wikipedias have been converted to it. Hope to see an UTF-8 enabled EasyTimeline soon. Regards, Kpjas 18:22, 15 Aug 2004 (UTC)


 * EasyTimeline has been made UTF-8 aware recently. 2 caveats: only extended ascii range accented characters are recognized so far, and a few of those, e.g. &egrave; &ntilde; are missing from the internal font used by Ploticus (which does the rendering). Complete unicode support will come once external fonts support has been added. This will take some time (months), as I am pretty busy with other Wikipedia work right now. Cheers, Erik Zachte 22:41, 15 Aug 2004 (UTC)


 * Bothering you some more, first easytimeline is great thanks alot for making it and in turn giving us all a great tool. I know you're currently working on full unicode support, but in the meantime would it be possible to do some kind of replacement to support the following characters:    A Á B (C) D Ð E É F G H I Í J K L M N O Ó P (Q) R S T U Ú V (W) X Y Ý (Z) Þ Æ Ö (The Icelandic alphabet) so that timelines like these: is:Snið:Tímalína íslenskra forsætisráðherra will work? (the ð character doesnt and the links are incorrect.) thanks. --  Ævar Arnfjörð [ Bjarmason]   14:43, 2004 Aug 16 (UTC)


 * I'm sorry, till external font support has been added there is not much I can do. Here is a list of extended ascii characters (special symbols omitted, and out of ascii order). As you can see some characters have no counterpart in the Ploticus font and are replaced by unaccented characters (or shown with wrong accent).

ÀÁÂÃÄÅÆàáâãäåæ Çç ÈÉÊËèéêë ÌÍÎÏìíîï ÐÑñ ÒÓÔÕÖØòóôõöø ÙÚÛÜùúûü Ýýÿ Þßðþ


 * Adding external font support for the whole unicode range is second on my todo list, but I'm currently very busy with another Wikipedia project, it will take quite some time (months) before this issue has been resolved. Also it is not a trivial affair, I will have to patch Ploticus (open source c program) in the process, to make it suitable for EasyTimeline requirements (unicode fonts have variable character widths, this has some implications on how Ploticus shows inline links) So please be patient and either delay working on timelines or add some comment in the script that explains why characters are not yet rendered properly (or else other people will try to correct it with no succes). Thanks, Erik Zachte 17:21, 16 Aug 2004 (UTC)

Just like our French and Icelandic colleagues we are very enthusiastic about creating various timelines in the Russian Wikipedia, but this is not possible unless we use latin names for events and persons which is not favorable in this case.

Is there any way a third party could contribute to development of Unicode-enabled version of EasyTimeline? -ACrush


 * As I have heard recently, current Ploticus does already support UTF-8 (Chinese as well as all the others), so it might be not so big a problem to tackle in upgrading Easy Timeline! Amen. --ACrush 10:36, 15 Apr 2005 (UTC)

It is a bit more complicated than you think. EasyTimeline allows embedded links in a text. This is crucial on a wiki. This is something that Ploticus does not support. So EasyTimeline works around Ploticus by drawing texts in segments, non linked text, linked text, non linked, linked, etc. With unicode fonts, which are generally not monospaced, texts can only be positioned properly if one knows the length of a text segment in pixels, given a certain font name and point size. In fact unicode fonts are so much different in size depending on which font is used that even without embedded links text positioning would be a mess without these metrics. In Ploticus chart texts are often only placed along the axis or tuned for a specific chart, so that is a difference with Wikipedia. Since Ploticus has freetype support it is logical to add this function to Ploticus so that EasyTimeline can query for these metrics (I have a proposal for that on the shelf). I know I promised to add unicode support long time ago, but the thing is I have several projects which take more time than I have free time besides my day job. It is certainly my goal to return to Easytimeline this summer. (In fact I offered to do a workshop about it on Wikimania, that will serve as a good reminder) Erik Zachte 21:03, 15 Apr 2005 (UTC)

If you know someone who can build both a Linux and Windows version of Ploticus, based on these instructions, that would be helpful to speed things up. I tried to build Ploticus for Linux, I believe I used Mandrake, not sure, it is quite a while ago, which had wrong libraries at the time. Erik Zachte 21:17, 15 Apr 2005 (UTC)


 * I 'd like to see UTF-8 working. Especially the links. If variable font is a problem, why not adding a symbol infront of every text and link on that symbol instead of whole text. If the symbol can also be specified, that would be great help. I can use the symbols beside the color to categorize the events.
 * I compiled Ploticus a month ago using http://www.cygwin.com/ on my XP. Cygwin is a Linux-like environment for Windows. I needed to modify your perl script to bypass os detection. It thinks it is windows, but it is linux really. I used it to work offline.


 * I have vacation now and one or two days to spare for this issue. It would be great if you could compile a modified Ploticus under cygwin so that I can test script modifications under Windows. I'll post a Ploticus patch on your user page somewhere next week. Erik Zachte 9 July 2005 12:47 (UTC)

Progress report: I spent the last week of my vacation to dig into this external font/unicode support issue. I got it working on cygwin. Now I need to ask the author of Ploticus to provide a new Linux version with my patch applied (so that Ploticus can be queried for font metrics). Again if someone can build Ploticus exe on Linux with these instructions that could speed things up considerably. The problem is I don't have Linux myself, only basic knowledge of it, and my attempt to prepare a Mandrake compile PC failed (Mandrake complained about missing libraries for Ploticus build and could not add them automatically) According to RedHat or Debian seem better suited for it. If you can help I'll send you the patched c file.

Good news is with proper font (e.g. very impressive shareware font code2000) most languges can be displayed. Bad news is Ploticus (or underlying FreeType libs) do not show Hebrew, Arabic, etc in proper right to left direction. Erik Zachte 01:31, 16 July 2005 (UTC)

Musical pitch range
Thanks Erik for compliments. I want put this to an English version on en:. I speak little english. Is the title musical pitch range OK ? Lzur 11:50, 3 Sep 2004 (UTC)

Vocal and instrumental pitch ranges. Lzur 13:35, 3 Sep 2004 (UTC)

In Template:Vocal and instrumental pitch ranges link to "basso" is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/alto_28%voice) . It's should be http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alto_(voice) or http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alto_%28voice%29 Lzur 13:43, 6 Sep 2004 (UTC)

EasyTimeline
Is it possible to make playoff trees in EasyTimeline? // Sander of Sweden 08:35, 2004 Sep 18 (UTC)


 * With perseverance you might be able to bend the syntax into a playoff tree. But the resulting script would not be very intuitive as a model for reuse by others. A html table seems more appropriate, until someone makes a new &lt;playoff&gt; extension. Erik Zachte 13:07, 18 Sep 2004 (UTC)
 * Take a look at wikitex which is currently being tested on Wikisophia: there is a tree-drawing tool which might help. --Phil | Talk 07:59, Sep 20, 2004 (UTC)

EasyTimeLineScale
Hello! I'm working with a timeline over swedish goverment secretaries for various departments (it's here!) and I've run into some problems. I would to have years as major scale and election years as a minor scale but the problem is that the period between parlimentary elections changes from 3 to 4 in 1994 (i.e. the next election was in 1998 not 1997). This appear to be impossible to accomplish?! (i've tried "LineData" but the lines are too thick to fit into the chart). Cheers!/ Narym 18:13, 27 Sep 2004 (UTC)


 * I added width:0.5 for LineData. I'm afraid I'm a bit behind with the documentation, some options are not yet covered. Erik Zachte 20:28, 27 Sep 2004 (UTC)


 * Thanks, great work! Narym 21:21, 27 Sep 2004 (UTC)

How to install EasyTimeline in an own MediaWiki project?
Hello!

At first I hope you understand my school English...

I am running my own MediaWiki project (inspired by the Wikipedia) and I like the graphs, generated by your tool very much. I would like to have it included into my wiki, too (like in Wikipedia), but I can't find any documentations about it. At your site I only can download the script for using it "offline" at my local computer - or am I blind and couldn't see a page called "How to include EasyTimeline into MediaWiki"?

Perhaps you can give me some hints on my German talk page, how to do this...

Yours, --Erlando 17:36, 12 Oct 2004 (UTC)

Template:Timeline_Classical_Composers_Medieval
Apparently the Template:Timeline_Classical_Composers_Medieval was incorrectly the same as Template:Timeline_Classical_Composers_Classical. I hope I changed it correctly?

Donar Reiskoffer 11:02, 27 Oct 2004 (UTC)

EasyTimeline vertical bars
Any chance we might eventually have the ability to create multiple vertical bars that don't overlap. I was playing around with it and apparently the only option is a single overlapping vertical column. Just as an example, it would be nice to be able to take a chart like you see at Template:Timeline Geological Timescale and turn it on its side so that the three vertical columns are side-by-side. &mdash;Mike 09:06, Jan 16, 2005 (UTC)


 * Mike, as a test I took this unual 'timeline' from and rotated it 90 degrees (I removed the texts which would have been been misplaced on the map, as they are in hard-coded coordinates). I would say these bars are vertical and non-overlapping. Is this what you want? Erik Zachte 14:29, 16 Jan 2005 (UTC)


 * Yes, that works. It looks like it is because I wasn't using the 'bar:'.  And I couldn't find any example that used multiple vertical bars to copy from.  Thanks &mdash;Mike 19:45, Jan 16, 2005 (UTC)

Problem with Timeline reported on Meta
Are you aware of the problem reported m:Help talk:EasyTimeline syntax? If you put a timeline into a template, it is apparently not possible to use parameters because the transclusion system doesn't substitute the parameters inside the  tags. --Phil | Talk 18:01, Feb 2, 2005 (UTC)

You might not be the person to talk to about this, but the English website link at statistics for all Wikipedias no longer routes directly to the English page. Moogle 03:56, 9 Feb 2005 (UTC)

Links aren't working in my EasyTimeLine graphs
If I put a link in a page it is highlighted like a link but is not clickable. I have my own mediawiki setup. I just installed (05Mar2005) the latest EasyTimeline.php and EasyTimeline.pl so I have the latest versions. I copied the code from an example, so I verified I am using the correct syntax. EasyTimeline seems to work in every other way, that I can tell. It just does not allow links. I am running on a Linux server. I am using EasyTimeLine to show (at a high level) development schedules. Since I have the latest EasyTimeline, I am assuming this has to do with my setup. Any ideas on what could be causing this?
 * Please check revised Help:EasyTimeline_activation, no ready-made solution, but possibly some useful hints. Please give feedback when you solved this. Thx. Erik Zachte 23:49, 21 Mar 2005 (UTC)


 * I checked out the link. The workaround submitted by Twhite worked for me. Thanks for the help! --MikeKordik 18:48, 22 Mar 2005 (UTC)

That fix worked for me, but the links aren't quite right. They look like  when they should look like. Do you know why this extra "$1" is in there? Is it left over from a failed substitution? Thanks for your help! Matthew Simoneau 21:14, 28 July 2006 (UTC)

Link colors in EasyTimeline
Being the developer of EasyTimeline, I'd like it if there's a way to customize the link color. The reason that this is needed can be shown at User:KelvSYC/Timelines, where my "history of the NHL" timeline (a wip) has a bar color corresponding to a team's colors. The blue ones, of course, obscure the links to the relevant team pages.

Also, speaking of feature requests, I'd like proper centering support, as the links are slightly off-center (it's left-aligned to the center of the bar), but it's something I could live without.

kelvSYC 01:50, 23 Apr 2005 (UTC)

EasyTimeline for Biology
Hello Erik Zachte! I would like to introduce my template for evolution of mankind http://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C5%A0ablona:Hominidae Is there anybody working on similar evolutionary templates? Regards, http://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedista:Snek01 --194.212.142.251 19:38, 26 Apr 2005 (UTC)

EasyTimeline

 * hello, Erik. thank you for everything you made (and make) ;D here we have a timeline. try to click on Parménide... there's a little problem with the accents, no ? ciao ;D Alvaro 16:39, 2005 May 5 (UTC)
 * sorry, I didn't have seen that Alvaro
 * A possibly related problem: some links in these timelines seem to be replacing spaces with 5F in URLs, where it should in fact be %5F, and thus breaking the links. This seems to occur only after a comma or an accented character (see the lower of the two timelines in particular). &mdash; Dan | Talk 02:09, 8 May 2005 (UTC)

Definitely a bug. I'll put it on the list. Thx Erik Zachte 12:20, 8 May 2005 (UTC)

Links in EasyTimeline
I've had difficulty with two elements of links on EasyTimeline - parentheses and anchors. To make an anchor (like caca#5) I was able to use caca%235. But caca (food)%235 doesn't work - the link looks like caca28%food#5) - and using a %28 gives caca 25(food)#5. Is there a workaround for this? Thanks. --SPUI (talk) 10:25, 13 May 2005 (UTC)

Aha - I saw the post a while up the page. Replacing the space with %20 worked. --SPUI (talk) 10:28, 13 May 2005 (UTC)

Argh, but now the anchors aren't carrying through. The URL has the anchor but when I click it doesn't actually use it. 15 works fine. --SPUI (talk) 10:37, 13 May 2005 (UTC)

I'll put it on the list. Erik Zachte 10:56, 13 May 2005 (UTC)

Another issue - not sure if this is a bug or something I'm missing. This gives me proper links on the left side. But when I remove the floating 7, the links disappear. --SPUI (talk) 17:30, 14 May 2005 (UTC)

"Yes, this has been reported before. ET does not generate a clickmap when no links are found in the PlotData section. I hope to start working on the todo list within a week or two. Erik Zachte 09:55, 15 May 2005 (UTC)

Strange request
Would it be possible to add the ability to use an image from Wikipedia as the background for the timeline? This would allow dotmaps to be created without making each image separately (though I'm not sure if it would be possible to get both axes scaled). --SPUI (talk) 07:09, 24 May 2005 (UTC)

Sundanese timeline index
On the page http://en.wikipedia.org/wikistats/EN/TimelinesSU.htm I found the title "Graphical Timelines on Sudanese Wikipedia". The correct one is "Sundanese", not "Sudanese". Sundanese lives in Sunda Islands, and Sudanese lives in Africa. kandar 03:16, 6 Jun 2005 (UTC)

EasyTimeline Question
I want to get the Bar titles on this timeline (here) to be at the top of the bar, instead of at the bottom. EG: I want "Leader" to appear at the top of the yellow bar. Is it also possible to have the bar titles at the top AND bottom? --Commander Keane 6 July 2005 11:23 (UTC)
 * Axis labels are always shown to the left and at the bottom of the chart. As a workaround I placed extra labels above the chart with TextData, using absolute positioning. Drawback is that translators will have to reposition these texts again. Erik Zachte 6 July 2005 14:27 (UTC)

GT
Danke, Erik. I left a response at the talk on meta. -SV|t 9 July 2005 00:21 (UTC)

Using Cygwin and EasyTimeline
I think it is better to use politicus with cygwin than compiled for windows environment. It compiles without any error (just a couple of warnings). Cygwin has png libraries. cygwin comes with perl (that might be an advantage :-) ). Emacs works very nicely under cygwin.

I can send you a compiled version. But they are also available from the politicus site. Cygwin version works. I checked. However, I think if you download the cygwin, you can compile it by yourself. If you will be developing more facilities you might like to have an enviroment that you can easily upgrade politicus by yourself and works like linux. Linux is your final target as wikimedia works under it, right? Here is some points that might help you on the way.

1) You can follow the setup rules under the cygwin site. http://cygwin.com/cygwin-ug-net/setup-net.html The default setup works for our purpose. Do not forget to include compilers and libraries while downloading (X11 lib and others will give you errors during the compiling if they do not exist in the system). Reminder; the default only includes the base pakkage.

2) after downloading http://ploticus.sourceforge.net/doc/dl.html?pack=plsrc#plsrc the source code under your directory use tar to unzip it. The compilation is same as explained in the poiticus. However, If you download everything (I advise you), you will see it comes with a prolog compiler. The command line for prolog is pl. Your Easytimeline tries to work prolog instead of politicus. I did not added the directory of politicus (pl.exe) to the search path. Instead I changed the line 3331 in your progam to point the exact location of the program. $pl = "/home/tommik/pl231src/src/pl.exe"

3) System sees the os is windows so it tries to compile to gif. Change the line 235 to this so it compiles to png instead of gif under windows. {$env="windows; $fnt="png";

I would like to help you, if you have problems on the way.
 * Thanks a lot for your advise. I'm going to try next week. Erik Zachte 03:25, 10 July 2005 (UTC)


 * I expect you did not compile with freetype support. If you do two patches are needed. Actually it took me many hours to get this working. Finally got it more or less right. I got several compile errors on X11 libs. First tried to upgrade cygwin and when that failed a complete clean cygwin install, which took hours:

/usr/X11R6/include/X11/Xos.h:156:26: X11/Xw32defs.h: No such file or directory I found this file on the web and added it, hopefully the right version, seems ok. I also had to copy the two files (at least gd.h) from /src/gd16 to /src Erik Zachte 02:06, 16 July 2005 (UTC)


 * I did not get Xw32defs.h. The reason was; I was compiling for linux. When I change the make file for cygwin, I got the error. I guess you can compile pl for using windows widgets or something like that. I do not know any condition that win32 extensions would be required. Sorry, for the taking so much time, which you could used for easytimeline. --tommiks 08:40, 16 July 2005 (UTC)


 * Not at all, it was a great way to do testing. Erik Zachte 11:00, 16 July 2005 (UTC)


 * I worked for a while last week to make ming library work. The remark on the website is correct about using the old version. Newer version is an object oriented version. The library gives error on line drawing routines. I thought I can fix it, but ... I might try couple of hours this weekend, but .... I have a valid reason for ming to work. Please check the section belong to that.--tommiks 08:40, 16 July 2005 (UTC)

Complex Timelines and their problems.

 * When you are developing a map that has couple hundred dates, the image gets so big that it does not fit to size limits. I changed the limits, this time map got so big it lost its attraction. Flash is vector graphics. Sizing works nicely. If I can make the ming library work, I want to see what facilities this library brings. I would like to limit the drawing area to svga size but the graph as big as it can get. Than pan and zoom the image within the drawing area using flash routines. --tommiks 09:00, 16 July 2005 (UTC)


 * You could run EasyTimeline outside Wikimedia with option -b which means 'bypass size checks'. The check was needed in Wikimedia to avoid people making a 10 Gb file just for fun. You could also try SVG automation. EasyTimeline already makes SVG chart. See for example . I saw colleague of mine doing great work with pan and zoom routines in SVG. Basic pan and zoom are already part of e.g. Adobe SVG viewer (works under Firefox too), but he added navigation controls, in fact treated data as 3D so that user could see a cross section for a certain date. Unfortunately he did not want to show me the code. Job protection. Erik Zachte 11:00, 16 July 2005 (UTC)


 * I use easytimeline work on the events (dates) and organize them so that they act as advance organizers. However moving around a flat text file is not effective. Is it possible to have something like two files. A data file and a program file. By playing with the referances in the program file to the data we can shape the image, and keep the dates intact while doing this. This also gives chance to filter the dates without loosing them. Maybe more than one program file to the same data??? Or better two data files, one for point events(at, mark), other for period events(from-to).


 * I'm not sure I understand what you want. A program file? Again for navigation, pan and zoom? Erik Zachte 11:00, 16 July 2005 (UTC)


 * If you seperate the event data, which I mean the date or period and its textual explanation, form the codes (program) that from the events on a unique map by assigning location, color, size and with general plot commands like the period, linedata, textdata, this way, a file (table) of events could be reused for different timelines. This file can consist of hundrets of events. Anyone who wants to develop their own specific timeline to explain their concept can pull the events (maybe using unique event IDs) from the event file and develop their timeline. Lets take EU's development timeline, as an example. By developing indivual countries history timelines, witout rewriting the specific occasions one can create a EU timeline by pulling the events from each country and adding specific EU dates on top of these. ALSO, what I recognize is that timelines are not objective, they are subjective entities based on the perception one takes in forming them. So, an event, like terrorism timeline, can be represented (using the same dates) couple different ways. That is what I was originally targetting. Every differnt timeline has to redefine the dates and events from scratch. If the event data and program (to build the graph) is seperate, this would ease the process. ANOTHER factor is for abstract concepts (such as social movements) dates are not solid. As one continues searching for more information the dates changes (maybe not months). It would be nice to change a date of an event and see it is reflected on all the timelines. I hope I'm more clear about what I really meant this time.


 * I did not know about svg format. It worked fine. I began to read about this format. I think I can use this format. Only disadvantage I can think of is that it is not as wide spread as flash.

EasyTimeline: Lines connecting points on bars?
I asked a question about how to connect points on two bars over on m:Help_talk:EasyTimeline_syntax -- then I discovered that this page is probably the easier way to get in touch with you. Thanks, --MarcSherman 21:11, 21 July 2005 (UTC)
 * This variation does not yet exist. I can put it on the todo list, but don't expect it too soon. By the way what would you use it for ? Erik Zachte 00:59, 22 July 2005 (UTC)


 * Well, a usecase I can think of for the standard wikipedia would be to link up causality in different timelines, or say on a timeline of Kings of the United Kingdom, a link from James I on the England bar to James VI on the Scotland bar.


 * The use case I need it for is on my company's internal mediawiki, where I'd like to use EasyTimeline to document our Subversion branch tree; I want to plot each branch as a bar, and show branch creation and merges as diagonal lines between points on the bars.


 * It would make sense to position lines relative to bar position instead of absolute position, but I realize now I will have to redo the calculation that Ploticus uses for where to place the bars, based on number/width/offset on the page. Like with exact positioning of texts for variable pitch unicode fonts this may involve a patch to Ploticus to return that kind of info, don't expect this anytime soon. With some creativity I'm sure you can work around this limitation and mark transitions with coloured text or something like that. Use anchor/align attributes to put text just before (anchor:from align:right shift:(-5)) or after (anchor:till align:left shift:5) a bar.


 * This brings to mind another important feature we'll be needing soon -- the EasyTimeline docs suggest a max year of 9999 -- is that true, or can the year go into 5 digits? Thanks, --MarcSherman 15:32, 22 July 2005 (UTC)


 * Thanks for all the help, Erik. It turns out that the kinds of charts we needed were easier to do (and maintain) using the GraphViz extension, instead.

Easytimeline requests
Greetings. Is there a place where people can make easytimeline requests? (Not requests for Easytimeline functionality, but requests that someone make an easytimeline for a given article.) For example, the messy scatterplot at List of films ordered by uses of the word "fuck" should definitely use easytimeline instead. Thanks, – Quadell (talk) (sleuth) 14:03, August 5, 2005 (UTC)

Time to align
Hello Erik. I'm finding your EasyTime program very useful and simply cool. I'm only have troubble with it when I try to get things to align. For example I made this and everything worked out fine, but when I tried adding two bars to this, nothing really wants to line up. Anouther question for you is can text be vertical anywhere? Thanks. Zhatt 19:57, August 10, 2005 (UTC)
 * Hi Zhatt, you defined three bars in BarData, if you remove "bar:T text:", the empty bar disappears, which made it seem that the other bars are not aligned. No vertical texts at this point. For a small text you could simulate it with ~ between all chars.
 * One advise use the smallest font size only if absolutely necessary, it makes the charts almost unreadable when used all over. Better break longer texts with ~ and use a different vertical shift. See

Define $wrapped    = shift:(,1)   # shift texts that wrap over two lines slightly up (other texts are shift:(,-4)) Define $nowrapped  = shift:(,-4)  # in war and events sections wrapped is default so use this for exceptions Cheers, Erik Zachte 21:25, 10 August 2005 (UTC)


 * Thanks Erik. I just figured out I had that extra bar defined before I read your reply, but thanks for the other tips. This is a great piece of code and is highly underutilized.
 * Zhatt 21:35, August 10, 2005 (UTC)

Anouther problem
Is there something wrong with this code? I'm showing only code without the tags because it seems when I try to compile that code, Wikipedia either gives me a server error or crashs! It was working fine when I was in YYYY formart, but when I switched to MM/DD/YYYY format, it crashes. What's wrong? Thank you very much, Zhatt  23:16, August 10, 2005 (UTC)


 * I figured out that if I change all the 01/01/YYYY to 02/02/YYYY it works for some reason. I can change them all slowly back to 01/01/YYYY but after a while, I still get a server error. I'm having trouble telling if it's unrelated or not. Zhatt  23:31, August 10, 2005 (UTC)


 * You probably got "The wikimedia web server didn't return any response to your request." The server is out of order right now intermittently anyway. See also . Erik Zachte 23:53, 10 August 2005 (UTC)


 * Heh, yeah, that might be it. Um. One more thing... is there a way to bypass the ImageSize limits? Because this is getting out of hand. Thanks again.
 * Zhatt 05:05, August 11, 2005 (UTC)


 * The image size limits have been introduced for mediawiki (one can bypass them offline) to prevent people from inadvertently or on purpose generating a 4 Gb image and thus fill up the server. I might expand the upper limit a bit in the next version. Erik Zachte 09:17, 11 August 2005 (UTC)

2 links in an easytimeline statement
Erik, is there a limitation to only read the 1st link in a statement? It's not mentioned in the Help. See Timeline history of international cricket and for example, the 1877 datapoint. The link for MCG doesn't appear, but James Lillywhite does. -- Ian &equiv; talk 15:36, 24 August 2005 (UTC)
 * Yes, I'm afraid there is a limit of one link per text segment. Sorry for not mentioning it in the Help. Erik Zachte 23:27, 24 August 2005 (UTC)

Unicode progress
Hi Erik, was wondering if there was any update on the status of Unicode support in EasyTimeline. Have been eager to try it out for Chinese timelines. Thanks! Fuzheado | Talk 09:45, 29 August 2005 (UTC)

timeline question
hi; i've been looking for a new way to make the List of spacecraft and crews that visited Mir easier to read.. i don't know much about this easy timeline, but do you think there is a way of doing it? do you think the outcome would be easy to read? thanks, Mlm42 12:27, 20 September 2005 (UTC)

thanks
I guess you get tones of those, and the most probably more well spelled, but I would really like to thank you for the wonderful easytimline, it is really useful, it easy to understand to, even if making a timeline takes some time. But the result is great. Thanks a lot. /Joakim Larsson 20:21, 25 October 2005 (UTC)

Timeline / time axis
Hi,

Is it possible to create a timeline with the lower figures on the right side of the time horizontal axis, as :
 * 10 9  8  7  6  5  4  3  2

Thank you in advance

Timeline lag
Firstly, I too am very thankful for the timeline syntax, a truly wonderous addition to the Wikipedia. When creating a timeline I'm finding that attempting to preview changes and save drafts often fails to render the .png - the page just hangs. I assume this is down to the variable performance of the WP servers that we all know and love. But I wanted to ask you (and any other timeline builders who may be looking in) whether you have the same problem. Sometimes the submit/preview just hangs, other times it takes many minutes to appear. --bodnotbod 18:49, 9 November 2005 (UTC)

timelina question (axis)
Hi :) I started to build some timelines on polish wikipedia - I've just done some timelines of kings etc - and i have one problem with them - is it possible to reverse time axis? how to do it? it is very uncomfortable to read it from the top to the bottom, espacially when whole timeline is long, - and informations in article and timeline goes in reversed orders. Please reply on ma polish discussion page :)

nameless (My discussion page)


 * TimeAxis = ..... order:reverse See for example Polish timeline Erik Zachte


 * Thanks a lot :) I see, that this question repeats on your page - does exist any timeline FAQ? I am a beginner in timelines, and often have small, typical problems (which aren't explained on meta), and don't want to interrupt you with every single question ...


 * nameless


 * FAQ could be good idea. FOr now just ask, no problem. Erik Zachte 00:17, 27 November 2005 (UTC)

You have probably noticed, that brion compiled new version of ploticus and updated the EasyTimeline for mediawiki projects to handle ttf fonts. Unfortunately, the use of proportional fonts breaks the link-placing mechanism. On the other hand it is rather difficult to find a free monospace font that covers wide character range. I haven't dig into the problem very deep, but it seems solving it would require using perl's GD module. Brion told me that you plan to release new version of EasyTimeline soon, so I would like to avoid duplicate work. Could I see the current state of the new version? I have also a small patch for enabling xrgb, so I'd like to know if I should post it to bugzilla or  just wait. &#39;&#39;--matusz&#39;&#39; 23:56, 1 December 2005 (UTC)


 * So Brion did read my post after all. Just did not bother to answer, even when he caused the problem in the first place, even though I addressed him personally. Please read my post at . Erik Zachte 00:44, 2 December 2005 (UTC)

Piped link in timeline breaks formatting
I tried to disambiguate Pantheon to Pantheon, Rome in the timeline Template:Roman Empire, which broke the formatting (so I have reverted myself). Other similar edits on other timelines seem to work and cause no problems, so I wonder if this is a rare bug or if I am overlooking something. Could you please take a look? Thank you, Kusma (talk) 18:02, 3 December 2005 (UTC)


 * Brion broke EasyTimeline is a shortsighted attempt to bring unicode quick and dirty, without telling or asking me. See also my post at . Brion choose to ignore this, although he did read it. Please complain to him, through wikitech or chat. I can't work on the definitive solution right now. Erik Zachte 01:56, 4 December 2005 (UTC)

So, um, is there any way I could help with that definitive solution, so that nobody feels any need for those quick and dirty half-solutions? &#39;&#39;--matusz&#39;&#39; 13:38, 4 December 2005 (UTC)

Btw, the problem mentioned above is fixed easily by using mono-spaced font, instead of the current proportional one. &#39;&#39;--matusz&#39;&#39; 14:21, 5 December 2005 (UTC)


 * Not really, the script only knows of internal Ploticus font, and has metrics for five available font sizes hard coded. The monospaced font will have different character widths per font size. Some script tweaking would still be needed. I will soon publish the script and guidelines for what needs to be done, so that someone else can take the final steps. Erik Zachte 18:22, 5 December 2005 (UTC)

Disambig fix needed at Template:Timeline History of Chess
Greetings. Template:Timeline History of Chess contains a disambiguation error: "William Jones" should refer to William Jones (philologist). can you fix this? Cheers! BD2412 T 15:12, 4 December 2005 (UTC)

Underscore character in text
"_" (underscore) is translated into a space in timeline text. If I do need an underscore, is there anyway to escape it. Thanks.


 * You can use &amp;#95; for normal text, for link use double underscore (this should work for normal text too, but it doesn't). So ' text:X&amp;#95;Y' gives


 * hmm... Copying this script to my site doesn't seem working. It still shows 'X&amp;#95;Y' in the image (double underscore for link works). For normal wiki text it does work, so I think it's either ploticus (2.32)' or timeline.pl problem.
 * It probably has to do with the unicode feature of Ploticus that recently has been switched on. I remember now that html char support is part of that. I'm not happy with this well meant but quick and dirty unicode patch as it breaks lots of existing timelines. I hope to publish a better version shortly before or after New Year. I'll look into this underscore thing as well.Erik Zachte

Dude... you rock.
I just came across your stuff on European classical music and you're my new hero. --IvanP 20:25, 23 January 2006 (UTC)


 * Gee, I'm flattered :) Erik Zachte 22:24, 23 January 2006 (UTC)

Pie Chart
Hello! love the EasyTimeline; I have just begun to discover the possibilities it opens! I am curious if you or anyone else have plans to port the pie chart type from ploticus as well? -- Dwxyzq 20:57, 26 February 2006 (UTC)
 * No plan, me :( It might be better too have a separate extension for stats charts Erik Zachte 18:24, 28 February 2006 (UTC)

download of Timeline.php
I get a "proxy error" when I try to download Timeline.php or Easytimeline.pl from sourceforge. Are they available anywhere else? --65.110.167.71 21:18, 16 March 2006 (UTC)
 * I pieced together something functional from CVS logs.It's here if anyone else wants it.(Obviously, go to sourceforge.net first to see if the the real version is available )--65.110.167.71 16:27, 17 March 2006 (UTC)

Bar maps in EasyTimeline
There's a bug in EasyTimeline, which I discovered when doing the wrestling timeline at User:kelvSYC/Timelines:

Apparently, the links in the bar area don't seem to be working, and it's due to the fact that the element itself isn't being printed, but the attributes are (creating a bunch of junk text at the top). kelvSYC 18:46, 29 March 2006 (UTC)


 * Yes, a bug. I added an empty link in the PlotData section to trigger generation of code, until bug is fixed (may take a while) Erik Zachte 22:33, 29 March 2006 (UTC)

EasyTimeline / Unicode
Recently I found that EasyTimeline works well with cyrillic in en: (User:Nk/Timeline; look at the bottom) but not yet in bg: (bg:Потребител:Nk/Timeline). Do you know what is the reason and how could we solve the problem? Thanks. --Nk 16:02, 31 March 2006 (UTC)


 * The image was still from before the unicode patch. The image is not rendered every time someone reads the article but only at article save time. Only when the script is different from an earlier version a new image is created. So I added a space somewhere in the script and saved again. Now the text is in Bulgarian.Erik Zachte 20:44, 31 March 2006 (UTC)


 * Thank you very much. I could guess myself :) --Nk 15:21, 1 April 2006 (UTC)

Easy timeline and other templates
Hi, I would like to use easy time line with other templates, mainly color templates, we have a project going on that keeps the color standard for all canadian political parties in any number of given articles using templates see Template:Canadian politics/party colours. If possible can you make the color function read a template? --Cloveious 04:59, 12 April 2006 (UTC)
 * EasyTimeline does not access the Wikipedia database. It is invoked in the background by the PHP parser module. Having said that I'm not quite certain I understand what you have in mind. Erik Zachte 22:00, 12 April 2006 (UTC)

Timeline >> PNG
Hi! Hw can i get a PNG picture from a timeline template ? Thanks-- Clo c lob   €  14:42, 16 April 2006 (UTC)
 * Not sure what you mean. EasyTimeline generates png images all the time, at least on Wikipedia. Just rightclick with the mouse and select 'copy'. If you use a Mediawiki installation on Windows you get a GIF image instead. Copy and past the code in a temporary page on Wikipedia then, just preview, don't save. Erik Zachte 23:54, 16 April 2006 (UTC)

Easy Timeline
Sorry to bother you with yet another ET query :) This one is about wikilinks - my attempts to wikilink the timeline for Richard Francis Burton ended in a horrible failure, with the wikilinks misaligning with the rest of the words (here is the version of the page with the problem). Would you be able to suggest what I am doing wrong, and what I would have to do to fix it? Many thanks, and thank you for your wonderful tool! TheGrappler 21:28, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
 * This problem was introduced when someone updated the ET script for unicode support in a horrible way: ET breaks a text segment with inline links in several parts to render link in different colour, with unicode font text metrics are different. After wikistats update I hope to update the ET script with a better unicode patch, hopefully in June. Erik Zachte 23:58, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
 * Many thanks for your response and all your brilliant work here. It is much appreciated. :) TheGrappler 19:44, 27 May 2006 (UTC)

EasyTimeline
Hi!

I've read that you're the creator of the great EasyTimeline extension; therefore, I wanted to ask you for suggestions how List of European Union member states/timeline, intended for use in the article of the same name, could be improved, streamline, made to look more professional, whatever. Any kind of comment would be greatly welcomed. =] Thanks in advance! &mdash; Nightst a  llion  (?) 09:47, 6 June 2006 (UTC)

Timeline from SMILE
Hi,

I'd like to draw your attention to the Timeline project. I thought it might interest you as the author of our EasyTimeline extension.
 * http://simile.mit.edu/timeline/

Regards, Kpjas 06:45, 14 July 2006 (UTC)

P.S Link to this subpage on your talk page is somehow broken.

=Thanks, Erik Moeller already mailed me about it. It is very nicely done. Very nice presentation and navigation, pictures too. Possibly easier to control (haven't tried that yet). Still Easytimeline gives more control over the layout, more variety in presentation schemes. Yet I expect SMILE will increase in functionality as it is such a promising idea. Erik Zachte 00:54, 15 July 2006 (UTC)

Tour de France again
Template:Timeline Tour de France Winners is malfunctioning, as of the addition of Floyd Landis. The prior version works fine, but adding one line (and incrementing the last year setting) results in overlapping text. Extending the length of the image does not help. Your assistance would be appreciated. --Dhartung | Talk 20:56, 23 July 2006 (UTC)
 * Many months ago a fix was introduced (not by me) for unicode support that breaks exisitng timelines. Now EasyTimeline uses a variable width font and texts with embedded links (which are broken in parts and drawn seprately in black and blue) are positioned incorrectly. The erorr only shows when a timeline script is updated and a new image needs to be generated. I promised a better solution many months ago but still have not had the opportunity to finally deliver, but I will when time and circuamstances permit in coming months. You can revert the article to old script, for which image still exists and add a comment that update needs to be postponed. Sorry for delay. Erik Zachte 21:29, 23 July 2006 (UTC)
 * Thanks for your reply. I've done what you suggest and given the article editors the choice of keeping the Timeline as is or replacing it until a new version is available. --Dhartung | Talk 07:10, 24 July 2006 (UTC)

Future dates question
I've been playing around with EasyTimeline to generate a graphic to plot out the time covered in the books at List of BattleTech novels but ran into a problem with dates in the far future. Apparently, ET won't generate an image if the dates are later than about 2400. Any chance this is slated to be fixed in a future update? I can see it being useful not just for my own purposes but also for other fictional future histories, like Star Trek (though I think all those dates would fall below the cut off) or others. (Of course, even better would be to find out that I'm doing something wrong and ET will handle this situation just fine!) Thanks. --Patrick T. Wynne 21:49, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
 * This has to do with the way Ploticus (plotting package used by Easytimeline) stores dates. As happens with most implementations dealing with date/time the internal representation is number of seconds since a fixed start date. In this case 1/1/1800 if I rememember correctly. So dates before that are not possible anyway. Any representation based on a count of seconds that is implemented as a finite integer number has an upper limit of what it can represent. I hope this makes sense. For your diagram rounding errors due to switching to format yyyy (whole years) might be acceptable? Cheers, Erik Zachte 05:43, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

EasyTimeline
Could be used EasyTimeline to make graphs (not only bar graphs, but also pie graphs, and other)? Please answer in Meta talk page


 * PD: Sorry, I didn't see the "please use subpages" message —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Nethac DIU (talk • contribs) 00:18, 3 January 2007 (UTC).

Image:Timeline_Sovjet_Leaders.png listed for deletion
An image or media file that you uploaded or altered, Image:Timeline_Sovjet_Leaders.png, has been listed at. Please look there to see why this is (you may have to search for the title of the image to find its entry), if you are interested in it not being deleted. Thank you. MECU ≈ talk 23:13, 18 January 2007 (UTC)

General suggestions and a question
Hi Erik, first of all i'd like to congratulate you for the excellent error messages of eazytimeline. they really helped me to create a timeline in a few minutes, with the help of the sintax description page.

However there was one error message that i coudnt understand: that's when it requires a date on the 'x.y' format. WHAT IS the x.y format?? Also, i couldnt put the scaleminor working correctly.

I think on the syntax description page you should present the rendering of each example, and also not show only the piece of code you are referring on each example but the whole timeline syntax, perhaps highlighting (bold?) the specific part you are demonstrating on the example.

I dont want to take more time from you, so i'd just like you to help me out if possible with the issues I told you (the date format -- i'd like to use days and not only years -- and the ScaleMinor). You can see my (very simple yet) timeline on my user page.--Waldir 11:50, 3 January 2007 (UTC)

By the way: the example on http://infodisiac.com/Wikipedia/EasyTimeline/Asian_Theatre.htm does not render correctly in Wikipedia. Also, the code had to be changed: there were errors on DrawLines (that had to be renamed LineData) and textcolor, near the end (that was specified as gray(0.6) and should be only gray, as defined on Colors). After correcting these, the graph renders, but the links are messed up with the normal text. I tested the page#WW2 with FF 2.0 and IE 6.0 but the results are the same.

At last, i'd like to ask if there are previsions for the fix of the bug referred on the timeline above that one on the same page: "TimeAxis attribute 'format' valid but not available, waiting for bug fix. Please specify 'format:yyyy' instead of 'format:yy'." (do i have to congratulate you again on these amazing error messages? lol they're awesome!) --Waldir 13:21, 3 January 2007 (UTC)


 * Thanks for the compliments, Waldir. I did try to provide helpful error messages, but wasn't sure if anyone noticed until now.  I'm really way behind schedule on fixing EasyTimeline bugs. Actually the one where text gets garbled was introduced by a very dirty unicode patch that I had nothing to do with. It breaks up internal links, black and blue texts are rendered separately and now text placement is wrong with the new variable width font. It is an ugly font anyway, but it supports lots of unicode characters. I hope to introduce open source font Vera for Latin font languages when I get to it. It may take a while still. I spent my Xmas holiday on upgrading TomeRaider scripts (Wikipedia on handheld). As for the x.y format : I looked in the code and I'm still not sure. It is a few years since I wrote the extension. Better consider it non-existent for now. I'll look further when I start code upgrade, hopefully in spring, also for your other suggestions. And yes the syntax changed somewhat since I published the WWII diagram on my site, to make it more consistent. Cheers, Erik Zachte 04:51, 5 January 2007 (UTC)
 * Hi Erik, thanks for the answer. I'd just like you to know that i managed to use the scaleminor and dd/mm/yyyy dates using the asian theather timeline (and cutting stuff out as much as i could). My timeline is now the way i want it. About the messed links, i found out that this only happens if the links are placed after normal text in the text attribute. if they are placed in the beginning, it renders correctly. I had some trouble with urls, and had to convert special characters like spaces to %20. I think underscores at least should be allowed... also, on the first occurrence of a text atttribute composed by a link followed by text, it apparently doensnt need ""'s, but on the next occurrences of the same structure, it doenst work if we dont put the whole string between ""'s. One last thing: the timeline i am using shows an extra space on the right, due to the texts, even if they fit in the drawing area that i defined. this makes the drawing appear normally, with the background i defined, but with an extra white margin on the right. Maybe you'd like to take a look at this as well. Keep up the good work! --Waldir 10:07, 6 January 2007 (UTC)

Months
Hi Eric Zachte. Great tools - however, would it be possible for it to support mm/yy-syntax? I need a timeline for an article in which events happened over a few years, without specific dates - only months and therefore the yyyy would make the timeline too crowded, and dd/mm/yy cannot be used. --Lhademmor 08:30, 5 February 2007 (UTC)
 * Someday I will fix the unicode bug and add enhancements, but I can't promise when, as previous pledges were broken, as I have to admit unfortunately. Currently I work on new Wikipedia for TomeRaider release. Erik Zachte 00:17, 6 February 2007 (UTC)

EasyTimeline: font size
Hi, Erik! EasyTimeline is great, but unfortunately it does not follow changes of the font size (at least not in FF 1.5). It would be great if it would; this would contribute much to its accessibility. --Eleassar my talk 11:25, 8 March 2007 (UTC)

Statistics page
Just thought I'd point out in passing that the Statistics page doesn't seem to be working. Verisimilus 19:10, 10 April 2007 (UTC)

Template data in EasyTimeline
Hi, I'm trying to make a timeline on wikipedia that functions as a template, that puts a marker in at the year sent by the template link. So I want to be able to use the syntax at: mark:(line, red) but EasyTimeline interprets the tag literally, not replacing it with a number as specified by the script. Is there any way to work around this? Many thanks!! Verisimilus 19:54, 10 April 2007 (UTC)
 * This is a recurring theme. Unfortunately extensions like EasyTimeline are invoked before templates are resolved. Not much can be done about that :( Cheers, Erik Zachte 21:37, 11 April 2007 (UTC)
 * Ah, okay. Thanks for your reply! I'm sure I'll be able to knock something together with <div&gt;s...| Verisimilus 21:42, 11 April 2007 (UTC)

Thanks!
I've been living in EasyTimeline for 3 days now (this en:Template:Timeline of English monarchs is the result) and it's been a blast (when I didn't want to hurl the monitor through the window). Seriously, most impressive work you've done. We all stand on your shoulders. elzr 03:20, 16 April 2007 (UTC)
 * Elzr, thanks for the compliments. Equally that's a very impressive chart you made. Also with new graphic ideas implemented. I don't understand the color shades for wars. What do the different shades of darkred at the top bar mean? Simultaneous wars? Cheers, :) Erik
 * I see you were inspired by Tufte. I looked it up and yours is more pleasant for the eye than the orignal, thanks to use of color. Very interesting book by the way. I read it some months ago. Erik Zachte 16:47, 16 April 2007 (UTC)
 * I made a small change: I changed all barset commands to bar commands. The end result is exactly the same, but it means no need for skip's and breaks'. Actually barset is mainly needed when one wants a autoincrementing bar position. Erik Zachte 17:16, 16 April 2007 (UTC)
 * Yes! I was inspired by a graph by E.J. Marey that I saw in one of Tufte's books. Here's the graph and here's a paragraph by Tufte commenting on it. I fell in love with it and wondered why Marey covered just a small period of time. When I looked at the huge List of English monarchs pedia I decided to take the challenge upon myself. After which it was a happy coincidence that I chanced upon EasyTimeline, I don't think I would have been able to do the graph without it (scripts scraping the data from the pedias and into ET's syntax did the heavy lifting).
 * Anyway, yes, I think color did spruce the graph considerably. Merging reign and life into one bar and using vertical joints for broad descendancy (instead of only father-son one) seem also improvements to me. Carrying the peace/war bar though was a (costly) mistake and I erased it yesterday. It doesn't work nearly as well with such a big graph and when every war is plotted (it becomes all red; I introduced different shades of it to differentiate wars but it was terribly confusing).
 * Thanks for the barset-to-bar improvement, I knew I had to be doing something wrong to need so many breaks sprinkled all over! --elzr 19:44, 17 April 2007 (UTC)

cladograms?
Hello; I was wondering if the timeline could be used to make cladogram-like lines. Specifically, I've been told that the clade format has accessibility issues, and I would like to try to combine graphs like these with a timeline format like this: User:J. Spencer/timeline that I've thrown together. Do you know if things like vertical lines that have several horizontal lines coming from them can be done in EasyTimeline, or if the clade template could somehow be mated with the EasyTimeline to do it automatically? I think from looking at the English Monarch timeline I could figure out a solution, but I'd like to know if anyone has tried something like this, or if you have any thoughts. Thank you very much for your time! J. Spencer 20:41, 20 April 2007 (UTC)
 * It would be neat to have better support for clades in ET but I have no time to work on it anytime soon. I tried several solutions to draw vertical lines, all of them rather complicated. The solution with LineData expects absolute coordinates, hence image cannot be rescaled afterwards, or bars added, without recalculating all offsets. The solutions with $x1 and $x2 draw the line in several segments, this scales with the image, and adding bars has little effect. By the way: I replaced all hand calculated shifts with one shift and align:left + anchor:till for text labels. At least there ET could do the hard work :)
 * Combination with template solution is not possible: extensions like EasyTimeline are invoked before templates are resolved. Erik Zachte 23:17, 20 April 2007 (UTC)
 * Thank you very much! I really appreciate your help, especially since I just started doing this yesterday!  I see I'm going to have some interesting toys to play with. J. Spencer 02:15, 21 April 2007 (UTC)
 * I was playing with the bar format you'd set up for Opisthocoelicaudiinae, using the #$top bar, $mid bar, and $bot bar lines, and I noticed that it would not accept just a top and bottom for two adjacent rows.  Is there a way around that?  I see that you've been using shortened rows for these lines elsewhere, but I've found it can be mimicked with a line like this:
 * width:1
 * bar:ASI1 from: -72.6    till: -72.4 text:| shift:(0,-12) fontsize:12 textcolor:GR5
 * where a | was enlarged and recolored, and the bar was shrunk. J. Spencer 05:36, 21 April 2007 (UTC)
 * Your chart is an interesting challenge on how far current ET syntax can be stretched
 * I'm afraid there is a misunderstanding. The hash sign is a comment sign so those lines are inactive. Just for the example I uncommented $top and $bot and commented $mid, as you see this works but probably not what you expected. All top and bot lines do no produce a corner line, pointing down or upwards, just a shorter vertical. Erik Zachte 12:22, 21 April 2007 (UTC)
 * I'm not sure what you mean. The character | is a problem?  It shows up fine on my browser (I've used it to join Rapetosaurus and Nemegtosaurus, and Nemegtosaurus with a bundle back in the Early Cretaceous), and the linked text is active. J. Spencer 18:35, 21 April 2007 (UTC)

You said that ET would not accept just a top and bottom for two adjacent rows. I figured you changed $mid bar:SAM2  $salta2 into So I tried to explain that the # sign at the start of the line is a comment sign, it makes the rest of line being ignored. So the chart version that you saw did not have a functional $top and $bot. I kust kept these lines as comments to be able to restore them on subsequent tests. Erik Zachte 22:40, 21 April 2007 (UTC)
 * 1) $top bar:SAM1  $salta2
 * 1) $bot bar:AFR2  $salta2
 * 1) $top bar:SAM1  $salta2
 * 2) $bot bar:AFR2  $salta2
 * Okay, now I see. J. Spencer 02:16, 22 April 2007 (UTC)

I've got a much simpler diagram close to what I'd like to present, at hypsils. I have a couple of questions at this point. First, how can I get the captions Stage, Epoch, Period, and Era to reappear as they do on the timelines above? Second, is there a simpler way to position text data? I'd like to put the title in the top left corner for example, but the auto-size function may interfere with that. J. Spencer 16:52, 22 April 2007 (UTC)
 * I'm not sure why it is needed here, but BarData option text:... restores the labels along the y axis.
 * I tried a horizontal legend
 * The page title is now drawn relative to the first bar with a vertical shift, it will stay there when more bars are added
 * The blue bar with blue text in it, is rather hard to read. Maybe use a lighter blue for the bar ? Erik Zachte 23:05, 22 April 2007 (UTC)

Three bars on one plot, lines
See Talk:World_energy_resources_and_consumption. I'd like to Is this possible? — Omegatron 23:18, 12 May 2007 (UTC)
 * 1) Remove the "date" labels from the axes
 * 2) Combine the three bars into one image, with one above the next
 * 3) Draw lines between the bars showing how one expands to the next

Bars and bars, name distribution
Greetings, I was pointed to the EasyTimeline as an alternative to our (many of them flawed) generated .png we use for name distribution in Icelandic. Example is which has quite a bit of data. This shows the birth year and number of people per year (still living) who were given it as a first name. What manner would you reccomend to solve this, no example I've seen so far does anything similar and the page that should list all examples is currently empty. It is around 3300 images we would need to recreate if EasyTimeline doesn't work for our needs! --Stalfur 04:15, 4 June 2007 (UTC)
 * I finally found something somewhere, and having been attempting my best at, however it obviously requires me to put each year in between at 0 to get the spacing correct for the timing intervals (data is below the graph) as well as unsure how to best tackle putting a 2nd graph (showing the usage as a middle name). --Stalfur 19:36, 5 June 2007 (UTC)
 * Here is a novel approach using LineData and absolute coordinates. These are absolute coordinates measured from the bottom of the image in pixels. The graph runs at y-position 40 (defined in PlotArea), so a vertical line of 100 pixels that start at the bottom of the graph runs from 40 to 140. The positioning could be made more elegant, but this is what EasyTimeline can do right now. Since all graphs probably will be created with a script (?) you could use absolute positioning all the way with "points(x1,y1)(x2,y2)", but that becomes even harder to update manually. Erik Zachte 00:48, 6 June 2007 (UTC)


 * Thanks for the example and the reply! I tried loading this norwegian name (but now legal as an Icelandic one...) but my graph didn't appear. I'll be using scripts to pump out these 3300+ graphs yes! EDIT: It seems that is.wiki is timing out or something creating my graph which appears fine here below? --Stalfur 00:51, 6 June 2007 (UTC)

What about narrower bars so that they are visually separate?

Lets cut with the norwegian Aage and go into something juicier, Árni:

It looks splendid! And it appears on my page, even if the Aage chart doesn't? The Aage one appears here but not on my user page, without showing any error though.

Wonderful tool Erik! --Stalfur 01:42, 6 June 2007 (UTC)
 * Addendum, following some test prints I have reverted to using light and darkgrey (almost black) as the colors in my bars as they are much b/w printer friendly than other variations tested. Red and blue merged so a printout would not give the detailed information while orange/blue was better but still not very clear. Using darkgrey/lightgrey came out perfect in print however. Word of warning to others when choosing colors! --Stalfur 15:35, 8 June 2007 (UTC)
 * Addaddendum, my script has now generated 6600x timelines, not all of which have made it into articles yet but will slowly trickle in. Fantastic stuff. I have noticed an odd bleeding problem, when the value bars dip below the axis they are on, but it only seems to appear when the second value set is so much greater than the first one.
 * Examples:
 * Ósk - second value set greater, first set bleeds down
 * Björk - second value set greater, first set bleeds occasionally down
 * Örn - second value set greater, first set bleeds occasionally down
 * Andri - first set greater, then second, bleeding occurs occasionally
 * Sigurður - first value set greater, second set doesn't bleed down
 * The first 100 values (and occasional others) on this page have graphs with high numbers if you want to peruse this to see if you can locate the source of the bleeding. --Stalfur 00:30, 13 June 2007 (UTC)

Where to Locate SansFree.ttf?
Hi, Dear Erik!

I've installed this wonderful extension in my Wiki (it's in Hebrew, but you may still want to watch it... It is WikiGenia - a genealogy Wiki).

Everything goes all right, except of the Unicode supporting. I've downloaded SansFree.ttf and the propriate version of easytimeline.pl. Where should I locate the ttf file?

Thanks, Arnon
 * NOTE: Arnon meant "FreeSans.ttf" —Preceding unsigned comment added by Peak (talk • contribs) 20:18, 13 February 2008 (UTC)


 * This is a installation dependent issue. frankly I don't even know where Mediawiki stores the font. Here is how someone solved it as described on meta:

putenv("GDFONTPATH=/usr/share/fonts/truetype/freefont/");
 * Install the missing fonts on my linux box (apt-get install ttf-freefont)
 * Modify the TimeLine.php file : added this line after the "isdir" checks of the renderTimeline method :
 * Cheers, Erik Zachte 16:59, 15 June 2007 (UTC)

# in a link
I'd like to link to a specific title of a site, as example: Intel.

My problem seams to be, that the timeline extension interpret the # as commentary instate of an link to an anchor.

Is there a solution for my problem?

I see a work a round like create a page which redirects to the spefic anchor, but I don't like this work a round.

-- MichaelFrey 15:38, 13 June 2007 (UTC)
 * Try to substitute # for %23 (url encoded). --Stalfur 23:33, 14 June 2007 (UTC)
 * See example that follows: # wthin double quotes is preserved. Erik Zachte 16:50, 15 June 2007 (UTC)


 * Thanks. -- MichaelFrey 17:30, 9 July 2007 (UTC)

Problem to display test / legend with EasyTimeline on Linux Ubuntu 6.10 with Mediawiki 1.10 & ploticus 2.33
Hello,

I'm running Mediawiki 1.10 with the "cheap host method", means i'm running with .php5 in cgi. I setup the EasyTimeline extension and it seems to work great. The only problem is that I can't display any text even I have FreeSans.ttf already installed on my system. I followed this tut : http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Help:EasyTimeline_activation

Any ideas why I have this problem ?

Best regards
 * Did you read this as well (on the talk page)? Erik Zachte 21:25, 4 July 2007 (UTC)

After some looking around on the error : pl proc page: 12358: warning: environment var GDFONTPATH not found. See ploticus fonts docs. I followed the advice on the main page (revert to previous version) without much luck. So here is what I did (quick and dirty) : * Install the missing fonts on my linux box (apt-get install ttf-freefont) * Modify the TimeLine.php file : added this line after the "isdir" checks of the renderTimeline method : putenv("GDFONTPATH=/usr/share/fonts/truetype/freefont/"); This has worked for me.

What happened...
...with the timeline during this edit? --Marcl1984 09:55, 27 July 2007 (UTC)
 * A long standing bug introduced by a Wikimedia developer who did not care, even after being warned. Texts with internal links are misaligned with the new unicode proportional font. I promised to provide a proper fix ages ago, but somehow other things keep grabbing my attention. Perhaps, hopefully after Wikimania. Erik Zachte 22:26, 27 July 2007 (UTC)

DateFormat dd/mm/yyyy
Is it possible to allow the format dd/mm/yyyy before 01/01/1800. It will be very useful for greek/roman periods (for exemple : fr:Modèle:Chronologie d'Alexandre le Grand). A french user VIGNERON, VIGNERON 09:26, 3 August 2007 (UTC)

Spaces in bar titles
Hi Erik,

I am editing the timeline on Steeleye Span, and I can't figure out how to get spaces in the titles of the bars, so I am still using underscores. Any suggestions? (please drop me a note on my talk page if you have any, as I might miss a comment here.)

Thanks, --Slashme 14:24, 18 September 2007 (UTC)

Fails to generate a PNG
Erik, first, thank you so much for Easy Timeline, it has made my work a whole heap easier.

However (you knew that was coming, right?) I have found something odd. I'm working on Wikibooks, on The Muggles' Guide to Harry Potter, and I have found that when my timelines get complicated enough, they simply fail to generate any image. Specifically, I'm looking at Timelines | Year 5. Am I doing something wrong?

Thanks again, and thanks in advance for your help. Chazz 16:53, 14 October 2007 (UTC)


 * Of course, the moment I post this, Easy Timeline goes and renders correctly... like having a broken car, if you take it to the mechanic it suddenly works. All I can say is, there was a long time when it didn't work... Chazz 17:16, 14 October 2007 (UTC)

One explanation I can think of is that the file was generated correctly on previous occasions as well, but not served by the image server. I think I saw that a few times. I'm not sure of that explanation though, neither whether that problem would have disappeared some time later. You could try when the problem reappears to wait a while and then refresh the screen. Erik Zachte 23:03, 14 October 2007 (UTC)


 * Actually, I have tried that, and it sometimes works; when it does, it takes between ten minutes and an hour to show up. What spurred my writing to you, though, was that on this occasion it was still not showing up after three days. Chazz 01:03, 15 October 2007 (UTC)

Easy Timeline
Hi Erik,

I Don't know if you're active on Wikipedia, but I'd like to request your assistance with EasyTimeline. I'm having some trouble getting it to work for me. I'm trying to build a timeline of DuMont network programs, at my sandbox page. Is there a way to input months or even days (such as a mm/dd/yyyy or dd/mm/yyyy format) so that the approximate timeline of series can be shown? Any help you can provide is greatly appreciated. Firsfron of Ronchester 07:17, 27 December 2007 (UTC)

New Ploticus 2.40, new color formating unsupported by EasyTimeline
Ploticus 2.40 was released on January 15 2008 and it now allows you to input colors using the hexadecimal format that is used in HTML. Unfortunatly, the EasyTimeline perl script returns an error when I attempt to use this new feature.

EasyTimeline 1.9 Timeline generation failed: 1 error found Line 37: width:15 textcolor:x000000 - PlotData invalid. Attribute 'textcolor' contains unknown color 'x000000'. Specify command 'Color' before this command.

--Billdorr (talk) 09:16, 29 January 2008 (UTC)

float/alignment control
Is there a way to float a timeline to the right? I've tried ways involving div and align="right", but timelines seem to have left margin affinity. Should I give up and simply generate the image, save and upload it and get control over it that way? The distance from a highly maintainable direct solution is unappealing. —EncMstr 07:04, 9 March 2008 (UTC)


 * It works nicely here, but see my attempt—and change if you are so inclined—at User:EncMstr/sandbox. —EncMstr 18:34, 9 March 2008 (UTC)
 * You forgot the closing &lt;/div&gt; Erik Zachte (talk) 22:19, 10 March 2008 (UTC)
 * Sheesh! Thank you very much.  —EncMstr 22:46, 10 March 2008 (UTC)

EasyTimeline future bug
I have been using the extension, but in my use I wanted to use the period from 1 January, 3000 to 31 December, 3000. But as you can tell from this page, nothing happens. No errors, no graph. Any help? Or is this a bug in the code? --Svippong 20:31, 18 March 2008 (UTC)
 * This is a limitation in the date format used by rendering software Ploticus. In fact it is common trait of internal date formats in all kinds of software. The date/time is internally stored as number of seconds since a arbitrary start point. After so many seconds the internal representation reaches its maximum value. Ploticus doc says: "3. Dates use an internal julian date system where 0 = January 1, 1970. Dates as far back as 1754 AD can be handled." The exact maximum date is not specified. Outside that date range only full year numbers can be used. These are stored differently, no constraints here. Erik Zachte (talk) 02:33, 8 April 2008 (UTC)
 * Aw, well, I guess that's too bad then. Is there anyway to "trick" it to write a higher numeral and still act like it is a date it can handle?  For instance when it is "really" 2000, it would display 3000 instead, and so on?  Cause I really need to do dates within the time frame that is from 3000 to 3001.  --Svippong 16:03, 8 April 2008 (UTC)

Of borders and pngs
I have used this great extension to generate the image offline. Thanks for your work, it has improved the article significantly. Dhatfield (talk) 11:57, 21 May 2008 (UTC)
 * Is it possible to generate a border from EasyTimeline? This will help with consistency of appearance in the article. I could use lines, I suppose.
 * Secondly, is it possible to force .png or .gif output from EasyTimeline? The text is much crisper in the raster formats.
 * Lastly, the rendering delay bug had me convinced that this extension was broken, until I used the offline version which worked perfectly. Is it acceptable to you if I edit the description pages to recommend offline development in wikipedia?

Problem with accents
Hi,

We have installed easytimeline on our wiki You can see a time line example here Everything goes all right but we have problems with accents. We have installed FreeSans.ttf like these instructions and we have also modify the TimeLine.php file without success.

Could you help me?

Thanks

Arnolino (talk) 15:11, 24 June 2008 (UTC)

Bug on axis ?
It’s seems we have a bug with the timeline axis on the French-speaking Wikipédia : text and numbers dont more appear. See the discussion fr:Wikipédia:Guilde_des_Guides/semaine_43_2008 : the code is nearly the same on fr:Milly-la-Forêt and fr:La Ferté-Alais but on the first axis are blank! (same bug apparently on fr:Sainte-Gauburge-Sainte-Colombe). Cdlt, V IGNERON * discut. 13:55, 26 October 2008 (UTC)
 * Same on the Dutch Wikipedia. See nl:Oosterweel where the text belonging to the diagram is not appearing anymore. Also it's very difficult to show the diagram itselves because it appears only at some pixels which I have to determine by try and error. See also nl:Lier (België) and others. Sunshineboy (talk) 22:18, 29 October 2008 (UTC)
 * I have added a comment in the "No more text" section. I believe all these are the high priority bug 16085 which has been open on bugzilla since Oct 24th : https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=16085 . Carfois (talk) 10:14, 1 December 2008 (UTC)

Timeline on Classical music
There are complaints (on Talk:Classical music) about, among other things, the font used in EasyTimeline. Is there a reason why it is what it is, and is making it changeable a thing that is at all feasible? (Alternatively, suggestions to improve the appearance of the timeline would be useful.) Thanks.  Magic ♪piano 14:23, 29 October 2008 (UTC)

Plantilla:Demografía Rieti
Hi, Erik. I have being working in some demographic timeline graphics in Wikipedia. And it is happening a strange thing. In this graphic: http://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plantilla:Demograf%C3%ADa/Antrodoco about demographic data of an Italian Town like in other like this (Rieti, Fara in Sabina, Norcia, etc.) the footnote "tomadaos" is misspelled. When I imported the graphics from the Italian Wikipedia to the Spanish one and translated them, I put the misspelled word. Now when I realized about the error and try to correct it (with the word "tomados"), I did the respective change, but the data in the graphic disappeared. When I imported the graphics I could make changes on them, but now I can´t. I appreciate your help. Thank you and forgive my Espanglish.--Eliasjorge4 (talk) 04:16, 16 November 2008 (UTC)
 * I know you are a busy man and sorry for bothering you. I thought it is be if I put the graphic here, and here it is:

With the misspelling tomadaos word in the footnote:

and with the correct word tomados:

Ups, nothing shows except the title. If you could do something I will appreciate it.--Eliasjorge4 (talk) 22:12, 17 November 2008 (UTC)

No more text
Text has disappear on fr:Modèle:Historique des sorties de Mozilla Firefox (and I don’t understand why). Cdlt, V IGNERON * discut. 15:28, 28 November 2008 (UTC)
 * I think this (and the previous post about charts for demography in Italy as well) is the high priority bug 16085 which has been open on bugzilla since Oct 24th : https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=16085
 * I have the same (or similar) problem for the plot on fr:Silly-en-Gouffern chart. There is exactly the same plot on the nl wikipedia nl:Silly-en-Gouffern which is correctly displayed with legend. The French version looks the same but does not print legend, I don't know why. Also, if I add a single " " (space character) at the end of a line, then it gets even worst : the plot is not created at all! I have noted someone had this issue also on page fr:Corbeil-Essonnes
 * I have spent a lot of time on this but I have not found any workaround. I think we just need to wait for this bug to be solved. I hope it will not take too long. Carfois (talk) 10:07, 1 December 2008 (UTC)
 * FYI, this bug is solved now (since 2008-12-09, see https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=16085). Carfois (talk) 08:50, 3 January 2009 (UTC)

Update Statistics
Hi Eric, first let me say "Thank You!" for your continous great work. My question is if is possible to update the Wikimedia Growth Chart. Can you do so? Would be great to have new data about how the single projects have developed. 82.83.252.197 (talk) 15:07, 19 May 2009 (UTC) (Maziminke)
 * UPDATED! Thanks a lot, keep up the great work. These statistics are very valuable for researchers. (Maziminke) —Preceding unsigned comment added by 82.83.205.50 (talk) 11:39, 4 June 2009 (UTC)

Before 1800
Hi Erik,

Is it possible to allow mm/dd/yyyy and dd/mm/yyyy date before 1800 ? I will be useful (for exemple, for fr:Chronologie d'Anne de Bretagne. Thanx, V IGNERON * discut. 09:49, 3 July 2009 (UTC)

moving data out of a header
(first posted at http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension_talk:EasyTimeline#moving_data_out_of_a_header)

trying to create a timeline (shamelessly copied from thunderbird page), i can't make first data row start properly below header, instead half into it. increasing timeline height notably sort of fixes that, but as a result also makes it look quite bad and take up lots more space. timeline in question -. is it possible to manually shift entries below, or maybe fix the automatic layout ? --Richlv (talk) 08:39, 2 September 2009 (UTC)

Timeline Classical Composers Famous
Hi Erik - I appreciate the comments you left at Templates_for_discussion/Log/2009 December 15. Like you, I think most newcomers to classical music would find this timeline useful even if it's imperfect. If we can keep it for now I hope to be able to address some the objections to the content through referencing appropriate lists. The one problem I don't feel fully equipped to address is the issue of the EasyTimeline font (though I've had a look through your source code). I know the issue of the font comes up regularly here. Do you have any suggestions? Could we (1) interest someone else in upgrading EasyTimeline or (2) adopt some other interim fix (perhaps overlaying text once the timeline is rendered without making the wiki markup too complex). Your comments would be most appreciated. --(RT) (talk) 00:35, 18 December 2009 (UTC)

Lunisolar support?
Is it possible to scale EasyTimeline in alternative calendars? I'm looking to use a tropical year lunisolar calendar similar to the Chinese calendar for a fiction project, and would like to use EasyTimeLine to help me manage events. - Amgine 15:41, 7 April 2010 (UTC)

Bug: ScaleMajor's color not settable
Couldn't find any e-mail adresses nor bugtrackers, so i'll just post here. I managed to create a nice timeline and customize it to a certain point, but I'm missing a color attribute on ScaleMajor and ScaleMinor. The scales all stay black all the time. This is no problem on wikipedia, but my mediawiki has darker background :-( Any way around this? —Preceding unsigned comment added by 93.130.80.162 (talk) 14:34, 30 June 2010 (UTC) Hubert Grzeskowiak

Is this still supported?/Install Problems
Nobody has spoken about this extention in about a year here and over a year at MediaWiki. I'm trying to run this on my MediaWiki server but am hitting brick wall after brick wall with either absolutely nothing appearing or getting a "Timeline Error" (I'm not sure which is better). I'm unsure if the MediaWiki instructions are even accurate as I notice references in certain files that appear wrong (eg. /usr/bin/ploticus) and aren't mentioned as needing to be changed in the install instructions. I'm running MediaWiki 1.17 and am just having no luck getting this to work and I've scoured the Internet and have found many similar problems...but no answers. Even 2 hours with HostGator couldn't get the job done! I've followed the instructions to the letter, and when that didn't work, started exploring. Any help is appreciated. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 173.252.16.172 (talk) 10:22, 16 September 2011 (UTC)

Make timeline into a template
I tried to make timeline into a template, by simply copying the code and adding three parameters. See Template:Rabbinic timeline and Akiva Eiger. I have no idea why this didn't work, and whether this can easily be made to work. I'd appreciate your comment here. Debresser (talk) 23:40, 13 August 2012 (UTC)

EasyTimeline on a "more friendly environment"
Fristly, I must say that my English isn't very rich. I've been looking around in Wikipedia for an application that allows me to plot data graphically, but not any kind of data, something like what your EasyTimeline does, and i must say, it's just awesome. The only problem is that for a person with no programming skills it's a little hard to make anything. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying the syntax is hard to learn, actually it's super-simple, but takes too much time to get results. I intended to use ET as a study tool (hope I wrote it right), you see I'm a high school student and normally I do timetables because it allows me to have THE overviw of what's happening in a particular period of time (I think you already know that). So finally, it takes a lot of time to do it with pen and paper, and it also takes a lot time to do it "the programmer way", and my question is: Is there anyway to use your syntax or code, or whatever it's called in a way that people with not plenty of time can interact with it and get fast results not risking to get a bad grade for being such an obsesive-peferfectionist student?. I must add that I also plan to upload to the wiki whatever i do, if it is that i finally come up with something that worth uploading ;). I will appreciate your attention. By the way, my goal is to make a timetable of the whole cuban history, which I must add it's a very biased topic; i've got the concept almost complete, but i need to start working rigth away since I must use it for a very important test.

best regards, and already thanks for your help DAN Wernerholt (talk) 16:28, 8 March 2013 (UTC)

Year zero and arithmetic
Nice extension. Its saved me a lot of work. One obvious thing that its missing is the ability to turn year zero on and off. Sometimes you want a year zero and sometimes you dont. Variables are nice but it would be even nicer if one could do arithmetic with them. One can now change the color of scalemajor and scaleminor but the numbers at the bottom are still black and arent reabable when using a black background. Just granpa (talk) 08:58, 3 July 2013 (UTC)

Also, one can set either height or width to auto but I see no reason one shouldnt be able to set both to auto by adding a command for yearincrement, monthincrement, or dayincrement. Just granpa (talk) 09:44, 4 July 2013 (UTC)

ET Syntax Update
I am wondering if there is any possability in your busy schedual for an update to the Syntax page on MediaWiki? I have spent a fair amount of time looking for a solution to an issue, and just found it in an undocumented attribute (at least not shown there).

On the other hand, if you could provide me with a current list of the commands/attributes etc. I would be happy to update the page. C.Jason.B (talk) 20:40, 6 July 2013 (UTC)

Bug with width parameter in PlotData (does not work if width<2.35)
Hi Erik,

The width parameter does not work properly in the PlotData : if width<2.35, it draws a very thin pale grey line, no matter the actual width and the actual color.

Example:


 * 3 red bars with width=2.35 :


 * and now exactly the same 3 red bars but with width=2.34 :

I know that in 2010 there was not this bug. Is there any workaround to draw bars thinner than 2.35? Or any plan to solve this bug?

Thank you. Best regards, Carfois (talk) 06:16, 4 February 2014 (UTC)


 * The workaround is to draw lines.
 * 84.127.80.114 (talk) 21:29, 5 August 2014 (UTC)
 * 84.127.80.114 (talk) 21:29, 5 August 2014 (UTC)

Image alt text
Images should have an alt text. A command like "AltText" could be implemented to add the alt attribute to the img tag. 84.127.80.114 (talk) 20:28, 5 August 2014 (UTC)

still functional?
Even if it is not still being developed, is it still functional? I'm planning to construct some political party timelines, and it seems just the thing. Is there anything there which is incompatible with current WP syntax?  DGG ( talk ) 14:17, 6 January 2022 (UTC)

timeline: till vs. until
Hi Erik, I just saw that your extension  (EasyTimeline) supports the two parameters   and. This strucks me as odd as "till" is an archaic/historic word which is not used in formal written English any more (except for, apparently, in Indian English) and is considered colloquial language and bad style. You will still find it in book or song titles or in poems, but only because they are closer to spoken English, where it is still used as an abbreviation of "until". In written English it can be almost always replaced by "until", sometimes by "to" or "through". Therefore, I find it a bit unfortunate that it is used in the above mentioned parameter names of your  extension. Given that your extension is using this for a long time now, the parameter names cannot simply be replaced by  and , but I would like to suggest and encourage you to add these parameter names as aliases and deprecate   and   in the documentation, so that their usage will fade out in the long run. It will probably take years until this update would trickle through into Wikipedia, but I would nevertheless be relieved if we could eventually avoid using the old parameter names in Wikipedia sources because seeing "till" there encourages unaware editors to use it also in the rest of the prose, which will have to be corrected. Thanks and greetings. --Matthiaspaul (talk) 08:07, 28 May 2022 (UTC)

Hi Matthiaspaul,

Thank you for your explanation, I‘m not a native speaker of Eglish, so this was instructive to me. However I have to disappoint you, I’m no longer involved in maintaining Easytimeline in any way, for well over a decade. I don’t even know who is. Best regards, Erik Zachte (talk) 11:42, 5 June 2022 (UTC)